Rachel's Point of View
I glanced down at my phone again and chuckled shaking my head; Kurt quirked an eyebrow at me, "Mr. Schue texted me again. He said if I don't bring his favorite nephew to visit once more before I hide him away he won't talk to me for the whole week." Kurt laughed alongside me, "Where are you even hiding Elijah away?" I frowned a bit at the thought, but shook my head, "Daddy and Dad are taking him for the week, that way if I want to see him or he needs me I can be there without having to worry about things getting…messy. If Mr. Schue didn't want to do this five year reunion of the Glee kids I wouldn't be in this situation at all. It is all his fault." Kurt wrapped his arm around me and I let my head rest on his shoulder, "Sweetie we have talked a lot about this before and now would be the perfect chance. He has already missed out of five years and honestly I love her, but I am kinda scared Brittany will slip up." I sniffled and shook my head wiping away the few tears that had collected in my eyes, "If he left me with no problem what makes you think he will treat Elijah any differently? I can't take that risk Kurt." Kurt just nodded mutely and we continued to walk to the choir room, that was until we heard HIS voice.
"Well well well. If it isn't Beyoncé and Berry. The Queen Diva's of McKinley."
I froze as I looked up and came face to face with…Noah Puckerman. "N Noah what are you doing here? The Glee reunion isn't for two more days?" I asked feeling the panic drip into my voice; Puck walked over to us and shook Kurt's hand before turning to me, "I figured I might as well come a few days early. I haven't seen Ma or Hannah in a while so I have been spending time with them. I just came to check out the new Glee club, you heading that way?" I shook my head quickly; I needed to get out of here NOW. I turned to Kurt, "Tell Mr. Schue I will come another time I have to go." Kurt nodded, he knew Elijah was due with Santana any second, but Puck grabbed my wrist, "Berry where are you running to? I just got here; I haven't even gotten a hug." I ripped my arm away from his hand and turned to run down the hallway, but I was too late.
"MOMMY MOMMY AUNTIE TANA BROUGHT ME ICE CREAM WHEN SHE PICKED ME UP FROM KINDY!" I flinched at the sound of my son's voice before bending over and scooping him into my arms as I refused to look at Puck; I saw Santana round the corner panting, I also saw Santana drop her purse and make a bee line for Puck before I could stop her. She forced her finger into his chest, "What the FUCK are you doing here?!" Elijah squirmed in my arms and I just couldn't hold onto him anymore. I let him down and he quickly ran to Santana and pulled on her dress, "AUNTIE TANA! You can't say that word! It is a bad word Mommy said so. Who's that?" Elijah asked pointing up to Puck. I stared at Puck feeling the tears start to drip down my cheek, I quickly wiped them away and knelt next to Elijah, "This is my friend Noah, we used to go to high school together." "He's also you're father," I thought to myself as I looked up at Noah and saw unadulterated anger and betrayal written on his face.
A/N I have had this idea stuck in my head for WEEKS! I had to get it out lol. One-shot for now, but in all honestly I love this idea so much I will be continuing it. Few things, this is AU of course,
Rachel got pregnant before graduation and didn't tell Noah (obviously). The only people who know who the father is are, Kurt, Santana, Brittany, Mr. Schue, and Mrs. Schue (Pillsbury).
I will be doing a chapter with the whole back story, and the next chapter will be in Puck's point of view. Hope you guys enjoyed.