I don't actually remember much of what happened in this episode but I did watch this small clip from it and I want to add my spin on what should have happened when Christy knocked on the door. Episode: The torn identity

Coop had been telling her all week; look for signs. This had to be some sort of sign. But what about al those signs that pointed to Billie? Phoebe thought to herself.

Flash back - Phoebe was lounged on her couch watching some random movie that was put into her DVD player as Billie curled into her side. Billie's head was resting on her shoulder, her legs were tucked next to her on the couch but were resting slightly on Phoebe's thigh as she draped her arm over the blonds shoulders, making sure that their bodies were in a comfortable position whilst being as close as possible.

Feeling a bit flustered, Phoebe attempted to pay closer attention to the moving figures that danced along the screen. Just as she did this Coops words of advice came rushing into her conscious mind 'be open to love'. At this point she couldn't think straight. Here she was sitting on the couch watching what she could only presume to be a romantic comedy with a woman whom she was beginning to have feelings for.

Noticing the uneasiness radiating of the older woman, Billie laid her hand on her thigh and made small comforting circles on it - end of flashback.

Deciding that it was a better idea for her thoughts not to get the best of her Phoebe became overwhelmed by the man that stood below her balcony. After all he was saying all the right things to her as he called out to her with a bunch of red roses in hand. But part of her wasn't so sure that she wanted to give him a chance. She was becoming lost in the words he was saying, when panic raced through her veins as loud banging on her door suddenly filled the room.

Please keep the noise down, she thought as she made a few small glances between her guest bedroom where Billie was sleeping and between the man on the street, before she attempted to get rid of the man. Why are people always so loud? After a few seconds she started to get annoyed with him as he did not seem to understand that the person behind the door was waking up her houseguest.

"What's going on?" Billie mumbled as phoebe moved off the balcony.

"I don't know" phoebe sighed, leading the way as they moved together towards the door to find Christy there. She gave another sigh as she opened the door, annoyed by the person before she knew who they were. They work her up, she tried to deafened herself, not that its their fault but they should have at least some courtesy not to be so loud.

"Christy? Hey, what's wrong?" she asked opening the door wide but deciding that she was better off standing in front of Billie. Not that Billie needed to be protected by her own sister, but because some part of her felt the need to do so. Girl you have it bad, the voice in her head teased knowing that Phoebe's had strong feelings for the blond.

"Billie, I need to talk to you" came the demand.

Panic, there it was again. The need to protect was there too. This is ridiculous, there is noting to be worried about, she attempted to convince herself.

Bulging eyes popped of the blonds' head, "what happened to you?" Billie asked noticing her wounded arm whilst ignoring her sisters demand. Part of the younger witch felt a tingling sensation run down her spine telling her that something was not right. She trusted her instincts, after all she survived this long on them, so she stayed behind Phoebe with her arms crossed.

"Piper attacked me" Christy spat, holding out her wounded arm to show her sister. Part of Christy hated how much her sister was close with the Halliwell's and wanted to put an end to their friendship, but the more sensible part of her knew that Billie was far to attached to them, particularly to Phoebe.

Phoebe's eyebrows shot up, not believing her sister would do something so drastic without a reason. This isn't right. She's not telling us something.

"What?" Billie asked, not quite sure the eldest Helliwell would attack Christy without some reason and not quite believing that this was telling the honest truth. There has to be something missing, Billie thought but refused to move towards her sister.

"Okay, you know what?" Phoebe all but asked, "you're going to come in and were going to talk about this" she continued, gesturing the girl inside.

"No! I'm not coming in," Christy spat. At this point Billie noticed the slight cold hearted edge in her sisters voice as she moved away from the entrance. She couldn't quite grasp what was going on around her. Shaking her head to clear some confusion, she was slightly outraged as Christy demanded that she was to get out of the condo.

Raising an eyebrow before turning around, Phoebe wasn't quite sure what was going to happen next. She watched as fear, disbelief and shock ran across Billie's face as the younger woman tried to figure out what she should do.

I hope she doesn't leave, she thought slightly taken back by this. What? Okay that's not what I meant, she tried to convince herself, it just because I have a strange feeling that she wont come back. Just to think of this made her uneasy, she didn't want to loose her not after the way she was beginning to feel.

Christy waited on with a cold hearted stare as Billie remained glued to the floor. What do you think will happen? Billie will follow you out on the street and believe you? That she wont ask questions? Christy thought, getting more worked up by the second.

Should I continue? Tell me what you think.