Okay so all I remember is:

Jessica sets Bella up on a blind date (whom is Alice). Bella becomes flustered and angry because she isn't a "lesbian". After the date, bella can't stop thinking about Alice, and regrets? not talking to Alice. When Bella goes to the gym with Jessica she sees and talks to Alice again. At some point there is a party they all go to, and Alice brings Leah as her date, and Bella gets flustered and upset again because she is processing her feelings for Jessica. As the story goes on Alice and Bella end up together and they go through some stuff and ultimately make up during Alice's roller derby competition, where Bella proposes.

Ayayayay so I got some reviews and It was Butterfly Panic by XDreamlessx In case anyone else reads this and is interested. Bad news it was pulled awhile back but if anything changes I'll update this just for awareness.