Chapter 1- Sue's Plan

It was all Sue's idea, Emma thought as she sat at her desk and cleaned obsessively. She made sure there wasn't a speck of dirtiness anywhere. Oh gosh, this is way too mean to do to Will. But... he deserves it, Sue said he slept with April and made out with Shelby, that's cheating, Emma was thinking. The one thing that was eating up at her was that Will was too nice to cheat and that Sue's plan was way too mean and humiliating. Emma had learned from being friends with him and dating him that Will indeed was a very sensitive man. Now that she thought about it that was one of the things she loved about him. A quick image popped into Emma's head, Will with his hazel puppy dog eyes that were pooling with tears, his eyes reading how could you do this?. Emma Pillsbury could not bear the thought of Will crying but it was too late. The more she tried to convince herself that Will was a horrible person, the more she found he was not horrible but sweet and kind. It was too late though, and in thirty minutes when Will walked through the double doors to McKinley High School he'd find himself feeling more hurt , ashamed and confused, than he ever had in his life. Now Emma thought back to the day Sue confronted her with the plan and the news. Emma was sitting in her office organizing paper clips when Sue walked in.

"Hello Erma, I have some devastating news for you about that curly haired clown you're dating," Sue said.

"What is it Sue?" Emma replied thinking that is was just going to be another cruel insult aimed at Will.

Sue got up and closed the door. "A couple months ago I bribed his landlord into letting me put baby monitors under his couch and bed," Sue continued while Emma rolled her eyes. " And guess what I found out? He's been cheating on you!" Sue exclaimed proudly.

Emma's mouth formed a small 'o' and tears pricked at the corners of her eyes, as she muttered a small 'what'.

"Yes, he has been a bad little boy," Sue carried on. "William slept with that drunk April Rhodes and made out with Shelby Coracon, another Glee club coach. It's a shame I really thought he liked you."

Emma was now sobbing while she said quietly, "Sue please just go."

"No," the Cheerios coach replied confidently. "I have a plan to destroy that gelled-hair maniac once and for all,"she said.

"I'd like to hear about this plan," Emma declared.

"Schuester's a very sensitive man, so we need to hit him where it hurts. This is going to be a two part plan. First we're going to put up posters with his face on it, with a caption reading slut or easy. These will be posted all over the school, he'll be so embarrassed and hurt he'll probably quit his job as the singing little misfits coach," Sue said smiling, and then she looked up at Emma who was fidgeting and... taking notes!

"Are you sure Sue? This sounds kind of mean even for what he did," Emma questioned.

"Not at all, Elmo. Time to move on to part two of the plan, at lunch the day we put up the posters, you have to confront him. Tell him you know about Shelby and April and throw in a couple personal insults too. Even better confront him in the teacher's lounge in front of everybody, he'll be crying by the time you're halfway through your speech."

"I don't know Sue, that sounds a little harsh. I mean Will's not that bad, he's been really nice to me," Emma said. Although she was saying Will was so nice, she really wanted to go with Sue's plan. She was really mad at Will but mostly hurt, and she wanted to hurt him the way he hurt her.

"The niceness is all part of his act, Esme. Now let's get down to business. I want a poster of SpongeHair SquareChins every two feet throughout the school. That way it's like he's taking a walk of shame to his classroom."

"Okay..." the guidance counselor uneasily agreed.

Emma snapped out of her flashback and looked at the clock, ten minutes were left until Will and the rest of the school would come in and see the posters. Sue Sylvester walked into the guidance counselor's office, "Well Esmeralda we finally did it. Schuester probably won't even last the whole day with the posters and the confrontation you're giving him at lunch," Sue exclaimed evilly.

"Um, about that I'm not sure I want to confront him," Emma replied uneasily.

"What do you mean? We've come this far, we can't stop now. You're going to confront him at lunch." And with that Sue marched out of her office. Just then the bell rang, butterflies consumed Emma's stomach as she was about to ruin Will Schuester's life.

When Will walked through the double doors to McKinley High, he was very confused. First off, all the students were pointing at him and laughing with the exception of the glee kids. They just looked at him with longing and sorrow in their eyes. He pushed through the crowds of obnoxious high schoolers to see why everyone was laughing at him. Then he saw them, they were everywhere... posters of him with two bad words on them. His face flushed red and thoughts raced through his mind. Oh my God, who did this? More importantly who found out about Shelby? Was it Sue or...Emma? But Will couldn't picture his sweet, innocent Emma doing this. Oh God, now she's going to find out! He thought. Will swallowed hard fighting back the tears that were threatening to spill over. His thoughts were interrupted, when he heard Principal Figgins yelling his name, "Schue! I need to see you in my office now!" the principal's face showed genuine concern along with some confusion.

Will wiped his hazel eyes free of tears and walked fastly into Figgin's office while avoiding stares, whispers,and laughter from the students around him. "William, what's going on?" the principal asked.

"I don't know," Will replied looking down and taking sudden interest in his shoes.

"Well, I will catch these hooligans. Okay? And if you want to leave at any time in the day you may," Figgins said.

"Thank you sir," Will replied walking back to his classroom, as his eyes were brimming with tears once again. This was going to be a long morning.