Now You See Me...
Pretty Little Liars Fan Fiction by PrettyLittleStephie ( .com)
This Fan Fiction is set in the AU where Jenna and Alison are friends upon Jenna's arrival. But what happens to that friendship when Jenna finds out a secret about Ali that could cause Ali's downfall?
Prologue: An Arrival
17-year old Jenna Marshall looked out the passenger side window of the moving truck as it rolled up to the curb of her new house. She and her father were moving in with her new stepmother and stepbrother in Rosewood, Pensylvania. It wasn't too far from her former home in Philly, but it might as well be different countries. Rosewood was perfect, pristine. Not a piece of grass was cut too short and every lawn looked perfect. Philly was nice, but it was a bit more urban than Rosewood seemed to be. As the trucked came to a stop, Jenna opened the truck door and slid out of her seat, propping her sunglasses on the top of her head. She took a good look at the house she and her new family would be inhabiting. It was very big. Much bigger than the house they lived in back in Philly. She then turned her focus towards the other houses on the street, all as perfect and pristine as her own. She wondered what kind of people lived in those houses. Would her best friend live there? Or her worst enemy?
She turned back towards her house as she saw her stepbrother, Toby walking up the driveway with a box in his arms. A tiny smile curled up at the corners of her lips. She slowly followed him up the driveway, watching as he made his way up the stairs to the bedrooms. She let a few seconds pass before she continued to follow him as he lead her to a bedroom in the back of the hall. She stealthly walked into the room, quietly closing the door behind her as she walked up behind him. Once she reached him, she gently wrapped her arms around his waist. As she rested her head against his back, she sighed, "You know, I think this move will be really good for us. Don't you agree?" Toby shook his head, pulling away from her, "No, Jenna. I'm starting new here. Whatever happened between us can't happen again." Jenna, trying not to be let down by his response, smiled playfully, "You say that now..." She said softly, "But will you be saying that later?" She asked with a soft giggle as her fingers began undoing the buttons of his shirt. Toby pulled away from her hold, turning towards her with a stern look on his face, "What did I just say, Jenna? Never again." He said as he walked past her and back out of the room. She turned, watching him as he left the room. She wasn't ready for their relationship to be over. There had to be some way to keep him with her. But what?
Later in the day, after most of the things had been put away, Jenna decided that now was as good a time as any to take a walk around the neighborhood and get herself acquainted. Who knew? Maybe she'd meet one of her new neighbors. Just as she was turning down the next street, she heard a laugh. Jenna stopped at the curb, looking around for the owner of the laugh. It obviously belonged to a girl, possibly Jenna's age. Suddenly, a pretty blond girl, who just happened to be Jenna's age, came running out of someone's backyard. "I'm sorry! I gotta go. I'll come back later, okay?" She said, blowing whoever that was a kiss before turning and running down the street back towards Jenna's street. She didn't know why, but Jenna was very intrigued by this mystery girl. She had this feeling that the girl would end up either being her greatest ally or her worst nemesis. Either way, Jenna had this incredible urge to know her. And just who was that person she was talking to? She placed her sunglasses back on the bridge of her nose, that trademark smirk of hers appearing on her face as she continued her walk down the next street.