The Witch
~Cast~
Jared Padalecki-Sammy Winchester (Buffy)
Chad Michael Murray-Lucas Scott (Xander) (One Tree Hill)
Misha Collins-Castiel Hannigan (Willow)
Alona Tol-Jo Harvell (Cordelia)
Jim Beaver-Bobby Singer (Giles)
Jeffery Dean Morgan-John Winchester (Joyce)
Sophia Bush-Brooke Davis (Amber) (One Tree Hill)
Nicki Aycox-Megan Madison (Amy)
Anna Paquin-Sookie Madison (Catherine) (True Blood)