A/N: For once, I really don't know what to say. Here's a story based loosely on 'Sarah Smiles' by Panic! At the Disco, and it's a collaboration with contest winner bluecinderella4. I hope you all like it, and you should check her out. She's the bomb diggity. (Hehe, funny word)

Summary – Robbie gets a new girlfriend named Sarah. He's in love. She's in like. His friends are in disgust. Turns out, Sarah is not who she says she really is.

Disclaimer: No ownage, just simple borrowing.

Sarah Smiles

Chapter 1: Girlfriend

Beck Oliver and his girlfriend Jade West walked through the entrance of Hollywood Arts. Beck observed his friends, Andre, Cat, Tori, and Robbie all crowded around a petite dirty blonde.

"What's going on?"He asked, as he walked up to the group, Jade following reluctantly.

"Beck, Jade, I want you to meet my girlfriend, Sarah." Robbie introduced, a huge smile on his face as he held the girl, Sarah's, hand.

"Hi." Sarah said, shyly.

"Nice to meet you." Beck greeted, looking at Jade to see a smile upon her face.

Jade let out a small chuckle as she inspected the blonde"You are Robbie's new girlfriend, huh?"

"Yes. Nice to meet you, Jade. Robbie had told me a lot about you. About all of you."

Jade's smile quickly disappeared. "Well, I hope it was all horrible things." Jade turned around, leaving the group of teenagers.

"I'm sorry about her." Beck apologized as he followed her.

"Okay... so how did you two meet?" Tori asked, politely.

"We were introduced to each other at a birthday party." Sarah smiled, and Tori found herself staring for a second. Sarah had a breath-taking smile. The kind of smile that could make you weak-kneed and want to obey Sarah's every wish. Those were always the dangerous ones.

"Ooh, fun!" Cat's giddiness distracted Tori from her recent thoughts. "Whose birthday did you go to?"

"It was a party for my ex-boyfriend's little sister, Ashley. I mean, I know it was awkward to go to your ex's place, but I don't have any siblings and his little sister was the closest I've had to one. It's not every day someone close to you hits the double digits and I wanted to help celebrate Ashley's tenth birthday."

"What was Robbie doin' there?" Andre curiously questioned.

"Well, there was a mix-up with the entertainment their mom hired and my ex suggested Robbie bring his puppet to entertain the kids. I thought he was funny," Sarah cuddled up close to Robbie and her look became more of a seductive look, "and cute." She rubbed her nose with his nose while doing a sort of flirty giggle. "Those are very rare combinations in a guy." She pulled away a short moment after. "Anyway, it was awesome meeting you all," her demeanor was back to being all innocent and smiley as if her seductiveness never came out. "I'll see you later?" Sarah asked Robbie.

"Yeah, totally," Robbie agreed.

"Bye Robbie," she gave him a kiss on the cheek. "Bye everybody," she waved to them as she left.

"So," Robbie had a sort of anxious smile on his face as if he was seeking approval, "what do you guys think of Sarah?" Yep, approval seeking.

"She's really smiley," Cat commented with a smile on her face.

"But what do you think of her?"

"I think she smiles a lot."

"I mean, do you guys mind if I go out with her?"

"Why should you ask us?" Tori questioned back. "Robbie, if you like her then go out with her."

"Really? Thanks guys, that means a lot to me." The warning bell rang. "I guess we should get to class huh?" The others said nothing. "Well, see you at lunch." Robbie went off in one direction.

"Hey, Andre, you wanna walk me to my class?"

"We have the same class next," Andre said this with some confusion.

"So do you want to walk to class together?"

"We always do."

Tori leaned closer to him. "I need to talk to you about someone."

"Oh…well, yeah, I'll walk to class with you."

"Cat, wanna walk to class with us?"

"No thanks, I gotta get something anyway."

"Okay then, see you later." Tori (and Andre) started walking off in the opposite direction as Robbie.

Cat made sure they were out of sight before going off to her locker. Once at her locker, she grabbed the necessary book and glanced to the side of her locker. Inside of her locker was a taped picture of her and Robbie in their younger days holding up hearts they made for each other as a school project. Taking the picture down, she read what he wrote on the back.

Happy Valentine's to Miss Valentine

And she smiled to herself remembering when Robbie gave this picture to her the past Valentine's Day. He said his mom had given him back every picture she had with him in it (which was rude of Mrs. Shapiro to do that) and that was one of the pictures. That same day, Robbie had asked Cat if she wanted to spend the day with him. And what did she say. "Oh, Robbie, that's sweet, but I can't." When he asked her why she lied about having plans. Then she watched him leave broken-hearted. "Maybe some other time!" She called to him. This made him smile back at her.

…but now this opportunity slipped from her grasp. Fighting back tears of regret, she put the picture back and went to class.

Meanwhile, Tori and Andre stood outside their classroom. "I don't like her," Tori whispered.

"Who, Cat?" Andre inquired.

"No, Sarah."

"What's wrong with her?"

"I don't know for sure, but I do know she's all wrong for Robbie."

"But Robbie seems really happy. And I think she seems happy with Robbie."

"I don't think she is."

"She's not," another voice startled Tori and Andre so much that they let out small screams. The voice belonged to Jade.

"Do you know something about Sarah that we don't?" Tori questioned to Jade.

Jade let out a more sly chuckle. "Believe me, I know plenty." She walked away, arms folded over her chest, and glancing back briefly to see the confused faces of the two teenagers. "What do you think she meant by that?" Andre asked, his head turned to side a little, thinking of possible answers. "I have no idea… let's get to class." Tori said pulling his arm towards an open classroom door.

A/N: So… what do you guys think? Let us know in a review, and next chapter will be posted ASAP. :)