A/N What would have happened if one of Natalie's Eggs (Teacher's Pet) came back to Sunnydale?
&&&
Nathan French smiled as he walked up the steps to Sunnydale High School. It seemed fitting to come back to the place where he was born.
Xander noticed something was wrong, Buffy and Willow has both stopped talking and where staring at the man walking up the steps. "That must be the substitute English Teacher" Willow smiled.
"God he's hot," Buffy commented before Nathan walked up to them.
"I'm looking for English Room 259." He informed the two girls who had lost all verbal ability.
"I can show you where it is." Cordelia came up in her skimpy cheerleading uniform. "It's nice to finally have a real teacher around here for once. I'm Cordelia Chase and these losers are Xander, Willow, and Buffy. You won't have to remember their names."
"I'm look forward to seeing all of you in class," He said before he followed Cordy into the building.
&&&
Xander didn't like it. All the girls, not just Buffy, Willow, and Cordelia, but all the girls right down to Amy and Harmony seemed to be under this new teacher's spell. Okay so the guy could quote Shakespeare. Who couldn't? He needed reinforcements. He needed Giles. "Hey G-Man, I need to talk to you."
"Is something wrong with Buffy?" Giles looked up from his book in concern for his Slayer.
"And every other girl in Sunnydale. They're all gaga over this new English Teacher." Xander said sitting down at the study table with Giles.
"Xander, don't scare me like that. For a moment I thought it was something serious."
"It is something serious Giles, this guy is working some bad mojo on the girls."
"I highly doubt that."
"Okay so why did they all raise their hands when he asked who would read Juliet for him?"
"I'm not saying that they do not find this man mildly attractive. I'm saying that it falls under the realm of normal teenage hormones. Unless you can give me some more disturbing information than my Slayer is actually paying attention in English class I'm afraid I can't help you."
"Oh I'll find something on this guy just wait and see and then all of you will feel stupid for doubting me." Xander stood up and stormed out of the library.