A/N: I am back with more John/Seth!
The inspiration for this fic pretty much came out of nowhere.
Although, I really love stories where straight men get seduced by gay guys.
I just started writing one day and I was able to keep going and not get blocked.
This was supposed to be a one-shot about 3,000 words long, 5,000 tops and it got away from me.
It took on a life of its own, but I had a lot of fun writing it!
I can't wait to hear what all of you think!
Disclaimer: I don't own any of the wrestlers, they all belong to WWE. If I owned John or Seth, I'd never leave my apartment.
He Gets What He Wants
John is spending a rare Friday night in with his best friend/roommate/love interest, Seth. They're eating deep dish pizza and popcorn while they watch an old horror movie. John's phone has been vibrating almost non-stop for about an hour.
"Who are you texting?" Seth wonders.
"Evan. He's trying to talk me into going over to his place," John answers.
"You can go if you want to," Seth tells him.
"I can see him tomorrow night," John replies.
"It's Cody's 21st birthday tomorrow. We promised that we were going to take him out," Seth reminds him.
"I forgot about that. I'll just see Evan another time then," John says.
"I'm surprised that you're even here. You're normally out with one of your boy toys on a Friday night," Seth mentions.
"You sound jealous," John teases.
Seth rolls his eyes. "Whatever. You're just actually fun to hang out with when you're not trying to get into my pants."
"But I'm always trying to get into your pants," John half-jokes.
"It's never going to happen," Seth firmly declares.
"You keep saying that. I'm going to make you eat those words one day," John promises.
"No, you won't," Seth argues.
"I think you keep resisting me because you're scared," John gives his opinion.
"No, I keep turning you down because I like women," Seth explains.
"That's not it. I've seduced plenty of straight men," John counters.
Seth playfully hits John with a pillow. "Just accept the fact that you'll never have sex with me."
"Giving up isn't in my nature. I'm going to pursue you until you beg for me to fuck you," John crudely comments.
"On that note, I'm going to my room," Seth announces.
"Good night," John responds.
"Good night," Seth repeats.
Seth is fresh out of the shower and fully dressed. He's standing in front of the bathroom mirror as he brushes his wet and tangled two-toned locks. John needs to get into the bathroom to get his razor. Instead of asking Seth to move over, John sneaks behind him and brushes his body against Seth's.
"John, stop," Seth tells him.
"I'm not doing anything. I'm just in here to get my razor," John states with a smirk.
"You're practically humping me. It's making me uncomfortable," Seth lets him know.
"You mean it's turning you on," John comments.
"Stop being gross," Seth retorts.
"Are you really prepared to go to a gay club tonight? You're going to get hit on and groped all night," John informs him.
"You'll protect me, right?" Seth asks.
"I don't know. What am I getting out of the deal?" John wants to know.
"Other than sex, what do you want from me?" Seth questions.
"A kiss," John responds.
"No, definitely not," Seth protests.
"I just want a chaste one at the end of the night. I won't use tongue," John vows.
"I can't," Seth replies.
"Yes, you can. Just think of it as like kissing a family member," John suggests.
Seth sighs. "Ugh, fine. If you try sticking your tongue in my mouth, I'll kick you in the balls."
"I'm a man of my word. I won't break your trust," John insists.
"I'm going to call Roman to see how far away that he is," Seth changes the subject.
The music is playing loudly and all of the lights are bright and colorful at Plan B. Cody is excited about going to a gay club for the first time. John, Seth, and Roman immediately take Cody to the bar. Once they get the attention of the bartender, they all order Cody a shot. Cody quickly downs them and he starts feeling the effects soon.
"Come on Johnny, let's dance!" Cody exclaims as he grabs John's arm.
The dance floor is very crowded, but Cody and John make their way to the middle anyway. John isn't familiar with the song that's playing, but Cody is. He sings along while he seductively moves his hips. John has never thought of Cody in a sexual way, so he feels a little uncomfortable.
After a while, everyone's full attention is on Cody and John. Without warning, Cody jumps into John's arms. He tilts John's head down slightly and kisses him. The audience around them cheer and shout for more. John gently pushes Cody away and retreats back to the bar.
"What the hell was that?" Seth demands.
"He kissed me! I only returned it because I didn't want to reject him in front of all those people," John explains.
"Whatever," Seth replies as he walks off in a huff.
"What's his problem?" John asks Roman.
"He's very protective of Cody. He doesn't want you to hurt him," Roman answers.
"Cody is like a little brother to me, so I'm not remotely interested in him like that. He's the sweetest guy that I know, so even if I was interested in him, I would never hurt him," John comments sincerely.
"Do you only want Seth because you can't have him?" Roman questions.
John shakes his head. "No. It's more than that. Seth is special."
"So you won't get bored with him after sex and move on?" Roman wonders.
"No. I could never get bored with Seth," John states.
"Maybe you should let him know that. He probably thinks that you only want him for sex, that you will use him and then dump him like the others. I think that's the main reason he won't give in to you," Roman shares.
"Seth is the only guy that's ever made me nervous. He makes me smile and laugh constantly. He's smart and he challenges me. I hate when he's in relationships. I get a sick feeling in my stomach when I see him with someone else. When he's happy or excited, it truly makes me happy. I've never felt like this about anyone before," John confesses.
"You're in love with him," Roman points out.
"I'm not. I do care a lot about him though," John clarifies.
"And now you're in denial," Roman adds.
John has a reply prepared, but the words don't escape his lips. He sees Seth drinking a beer at a nearby table with some guy. Seth is innocently talking to the stranger and he seems oblivious to the fact that he's being eye fucked. John turns to approach them, but Roman holds him back.
"I swear if that guy fucking touches Seth . . . " John trails off.
"You're acting like a jealous boyfriend. Calm down," Roman tells him.
John takes a few breaths hoping it will calm his nerves. John has so much pent up energy and he needs a way to release it. He pulls out his cell phone and he opens his messages. John sends a text to Evan asking him if he wants to come by the club. Evan agrees and says that he's on his way. John puts his phone away and tries to stop looking in Seth's direction.
Evan doesn't stay far from the club, so it only takes him about 10 minutes to get there. He walks in and immediately spots John at the bar. Evan smiles when John notices him. Evan sits in the seat to John's left and he greets him with an innocent kiss on the mouth.
Evan notices Roman on John's right. "Is he a friend of yours?"
"Yes, this is Roman. Roman, meet Evan," John introduces.
"It's nice to meet you," Roman politely replies.
"Likewise," Evan responds.
"If you don't have any plans later tonight, why don't you come to my place," John suggests.
"Really? I thought you never invited me over because of your roommate," Evan mentions.
"Don't worry about him. I want you to come over," John insists.
"Ok, sure," Evan answers.
John orders a beer for himself and a drink for Evan as well. Evan starts talking and John tries really listening to him. John is still focused on Seth and he hates himself for it. The whole reason John invited Evan was because he thought that he would provide a nice distraction.
John continues half-heartedly listening to Evan while also keeping an eye on Seth. John sees the guy laughing at something Seth says before he then slyly runs his hand down Seth's arm. Evan is in the middle of a sentence when John angrily walks away. John marches over to the table where Seth is and he violently snatches the guy's hand from Seth's arm.
"Keep your hands off of him!" John yells.
"And what if I don't want to?" The stranger challenges.
"Dean, you really don't want to fuck with him," Seth warns.
"I'm not scared of him," Dean tells Seth.
"My dad was a boxer. I can knock you unconscious with one punch," John promises.
Dean smirks. "Is Seth really worth fighting over, though? I mean he's a hot piece of ass. I definitely wouldn't mind bending him over and making him scream my name. But I can find guys like him anywhere. He's really not all that special. If you take the blonde out of his hair, he'd just look like a common slut. . . "
John reaches around the table and grabs Dean by his collar before he can say any more disparaging remarks about Seth. John punches Dean so quickly that his hand is a blur. Dean falls down and John is ready to punch him again. A security guard comes before John can do any more damage and he kicks John out of the club.
"Go find Cody and meet me in the parking lot," John instructs Roman.
"Are you ok?" Evan asks once he, John, and Seth are outside waiting for the others.
"Nobody fucking talks about Seth like that! Who the fuck does he think he is? I'm tempted to go back in there and finish kicking his ass properly!" John shouts.
Seth soothingly rubs John's back. "Relax, Johnny. Everything's fine. Just calm down, ok? I don't want you going to jail for manslaughter."
John focuses on Seth's comforting touch and it helps him keep his composure. John still wants to rearrange Dean's face, but he won't because it will upset Seth. Evan watches as Seth continues massaging John's back and whispering encouraging words into John's ear. Evan almost feels like he's intruding on a private moment. Roman joins them a few minutes later, but Cody's not with him.
"Where's Cody?" Seth wants to know.
Roman grins. "He's not coming with us. He's also not going home alone."
"You can't let him leave with a complete stranger!" Seth exclaims.
"Why not? John does it all of the time and he's perfectly fine," Roman points out.
"John is perfectly capable of defending himself. Cody's fragile," Seth remarks.
"He'll be fine, Seth. Now get in the car so that we can go," Roman demands.
John's adrenaline is still pumping when he gets back to his apartment and he wants to take the edge off. As soon as Seth unlocks the door, John starts taking Evan's shirt off. John throws Evan over his shoulder as he races for his bedroom. He lays Evan on the bed and he doesn't waste time stripping him of the rest of his clothes.
"Slow down, John. There's no rush," Evan tells John.
"Sorry. I just really want to fuck you," John lewdly replies.
Evan groans at John's crude, lust-filled words. John quickly takes off his shirt and steps out of his jeans. Evan barely gets a chance to admire John's body like he normally does. John pounces on him and Evan loves that John isn't afraid to be rough with him. John alternates between sucking on and biting Evan's nipples. Evan moans loudly when John's mouth makes its way down to the sensitive skin of his inner thighs.
"Shh! Seth is right down the hall," John reminds him.
Evan takes one of the pillows that he's resting on and places it next to him in case he needs to scream into it. John licks 2 of his thick fingers before he spreads Evan's legs wide. John slides both of his slick fingers in at the same time because he knows that Evan can take it. Evan bites his lip at the slight burn that he feels when John fingers him hard.
"Fuck! I need your cock," Evan begs.
John smiles and nods. Evan is nice and sweet, but he has a dirty side and John loves it. He reaches in the drawer beside his bed for a condom. He puts it on quickly and doesn't waste time entering Evan. Both men groan as John begins thrusting at a steady pace. Evan wraps his legs around John's back and his arms around John's neck.
John starts pounding into Evan aggressively and Evan lets a moan escape. John throws the pillow that Evan is now clutching on the floor and encourages him to make noise. John's headboard is banging loudly, so he doubts that Seth will be able to hear anything else.
"Damn, Evan. You're taking my dick like a fucking champ," John compliments.
"You know that I love it rough," Evan retorts.
Evan reaches in between their intertwined sweat drenched bodies to grab his cock. He's pretty sure that he can cum untouched, but Evan wants the extra stimulation. Sensing that Evan's orgasm is imminent, John wants to help him get there.
Evan cries out when John starts hammering away at his prostate. Evan is dizzy from the immense pleasure. John leans down to gently bite Evan on his neck. The pain mixed with the ecstasy, sends Evan over the edge. Evan's body quivers as he shoots spurt after spurt of cum onto his chest.
"Wow! That was so fucking intense," Evan comments once he has caught his breath.
John likes having his partner cum before he does. Now that Evan's done, he can chase his own orgasm. John hears a noise from Seth's room and it distracts him. John's eyes close and he immediately starts thinking about Seth. He imagines that it's Seth underneath him instead of Evan. John's brief fantasy is enough to make him cum hard. He's panting and perspiring profusely when he rolls off of Evan.
"I need some water," John announces.
John quickly puts on a pair of sweatpants as he heads toward the kitchen. Seth and John open their doors at the same time and they're both going to the kitchen. John grabs a bottle of water from the refrigerator while Seth rifles through one of the cupboards. John sits down at the breakfast bar and clears his throat.
"Um . . . I'm sorry if I kept you awake," John apologizes after he takes a sip of water.
"I'm awake because I'm waiting on Cody to text me back. Although, you and Evan were quite loud," Seth replies.
"If you gave me the chance, I could make you scream in pleasure too," John promises.
"Speaking of that, thanks for defending my honor tonight. I wasn't really affected by Dean's words or anything, but it was still nice of you to take up for me like that," Seth sincerely says.
"I was just doing what I told you I would do. You know, I never got my kiss," John mentions.
"I kind of forgot about that," Seth remarks.
Seth is leaning against the counter and he tries to calm his racing heart when John approaches him. Despite the fact that John is normally a person of his word, Seth is afraid that he'll take the kiss too far. John can sense Seth's uneasiness, so he makes sure to move slowly. John lightly runs his hand up and down Seth's arm before leaning into him. Seth can feel the hairs on his arm standing up. The anticipation is killing him.
"Just do it already," Seth rushes.
John shakes his head. "Oh, no. I'm going to take my time and enjoy this."
John tilts Seth's head slightly so that they're eye-level. He doesn't remove his hand from Seth's face. John traces over Seth's facial hair with his fingers and he's surprised at how soft it is. He manages to get even closer to Seth. Their foreheads and noses are touching. John closes his eyes and before he can gently cover Seth's lips with his own, he hears Evan come into the kitchen. The moment is ruined and Seth puts some distance between them.
"Are coming back to bed?" Evan asks.
"Yeah, just give me a minute," John grunts in an irritated tone.
"Ok," Evan says as he walks back to John's room.
"Can I get a rain check on the kiss?" John wonders.
Seth chastely kisses John on the cheek. "No."
A/N: I hope that you enjoyed this first chapter!
I love Evan and I don't write him that much, so I wanted to add him briefly to this fic.
I broke this up into 3 parts, so there are 2 more chapters left.
I look forward to reading all of your reviews!
I hope to update soon!