Disclaimer: This is a work of pure fiction and does not in anyway depict the ideas, feelings, thoughts, or lives of those mentioned. I do not own anyone/thing mentioned as they are property of themsleves as well as WWE.

Note: This is a prompt from wrestlingkink! I just reworded the prompt to better fit my personal tastes. This is also posted on AO3 and has been for a few days now. Enjoy! -JJ

Full Summary: Enzo and Cass have been dating for forever and after a night of drinking, and goading from Cass, Enzo finally confesses that he has a secret three way fantasy. Cass, being the wonderful boyfriend he is, has no problem with making Enzo's fantasy a reality. All he has to do is find someone Enzo and him both find attractive and is willing to join their bed for a night.

Chapter 1

Cass pushed the door open to his and Enzo's shared apartment, both of them halfway falling in as Enzo clung to Cass. "You're so wasted baby boy," he laughed, hoisting Enzo up to unsteady feet as he shut the door and locked it behind him.

"Yeah, an' I'm ready t'get these clothes off and get on ya'," he slurred, smirking devilishly as he roughly started yanking his shirt off. He'd had a lot to drink, but he wasn't about to miss the chance for drunk sex. For some reason, whenever he was plastered, every single zing of pleasure seemed to be amplified tenfold. "C'mon, get these off."

Cass only shook his head at Enzo's whining. "Can we at least get to the bedroom?" he asked, leading them through the dark apartment. He wasn't going to waste the time turning the lights on when he knew neither of them were going to make it out until morning.

Once Cass made it into their large master bedroom, he pushed Enzo down on the bed and tried not to bust out laughing as the smaller male fought to get his shirt off. "Ya sure 'bout sex if you're having that much trouble with ya shirt?" he teased, the offending material finally being thrown to the floor, leaving Enzo's once perfect mohawk messy. He bit his lower lip, the fire and lust in those baby blue eyes making his stomach churn with want. Fuck, he loved Enzo's bedroom eyes.

"C'mon baby," Enzo half whined, half growled, lifting his hand and curling his index finger at his boyfriend. "I need ya real fuckin' bad." For emphasis, he leaned back on one hand, the other sliding down his bare stomach to the crotch of his jeans, grabbing the thick outline of his dick.

Cass couldn't ignore that kind of invitation. He pulled his own shirt off and went to the fastenings of his jeans. He toed his shoes off and dropped both his jeans and underwear to his ankles, letting everything pool together. He stepped out and towards the bed, slowly falling to his knees and resting his hands on Enzo's thighs.

Enzo could barely keep his eyes on Cass', the look so intense and perfect. "You're beautiful," he murmured, running a hand through the loose blond hair. "Ya know that? So fuckin' beautiful."

Cass felt his already warm cheeks grow warmer, a soft, tender smirk on his lips. "Yeah?" he murmured, nudging his nose against Enzo's. He heard the soft mumble of confirmation before he moved in and pressed a simple, loving kiss to the sweet lips. "Well, you're 'bout to be real fuckin' gorgeous."

Enzo groaned out in excitement, pulling back from the kiss and leaning back on his hands, watching as Cass removed his shoes and socks before he moved to the fastenings of Enzo's jeans. He bit his lower lip, his vision on slightly blurry. He let out a hiss once the warm air of the room hit his exposed skin, his hips lifting as Cass went to pull the offending material free.

Cass replaced his hands on Enzo's thighs, spreading them wider. He leaned in and ran the flat of his tongue up the entire length of Enzo's cock, swirling around the head to lap up the white bead of pre-cum. He let out a groan of appreciation. Enzo tasted so fucking good. He didn't waste any time. He knew neither of them could handle much teasing. "Hey, 'Zo," he groaned, pulling back and licking his lips.

"Y-yeah?" Enzo returned, running his hand back through the blond silk, fisting his hand in the back. He urged Cass to take him into his mouth, wanting so much more than that teasing tongue.

"What's one of ya fantasies?" he breathed, easing his lips around the head and sucking gently. He slowly eased down the rigid flesh, sucking just a little harder, Enzo's fist tightening in his hair, sending painful prickles through his scalp as some strands were ripped free.

Enzo whined, Cass swallowing around him. He looked down, his cock jumping at the sight of Cass' mouth stretched around his flesh. "This," he answered honestly, his hips starting to gently rock forward. "Just you on ya knees. Lookin' like a fuckin' porn star."

Cass pulled back, unable to contain his chuckle. He should've seen that coming. He pulled Enzo's hand from his hair and pushed him to lay flat as he reached for the bedside table. There on top was a bottle of half empty lube. He popped the cap and doused his first two fingers in the slipper liquid. He urged Enzo to continue as he lifted Enzo's legs up, exposing his tight, puckered entrance.

Enzo let out a gasp, a slick finger circling him but not pressing in. "Fuck," he groaned, on hand covering his face. He felt his entire body start to sear with heat, his heart racing. He had one fantasy he'd never told Cass. "A threesome."

Cass paused, his ears perking up at the soft reply. "Oh?" he asked, his curiosity piqued as he eased the first finger in to the second knuckle. "Tell me about it."

Enzo couldn't believe he'd even said it out loud. Damn the alcohol. "You and another guy'd have me tied up and ya'd just… use me," he stuttered, Cass teasing his prostate with the tip of his finger. "Like a spit roast or somethin'. I like the idea 'a handcuffs somewhere."

Cass smirked, taking half of Enzo's cock into his mouth as he slid a second digit in. He bobbed up and down slowly, keeping a close ear on Enzo's noises. He added a third after he felt Enzo start to alternate between thrusting up into his mouth and back on his fingers.

"Ya ain't mad are ya?" Enzo asked, fear tightening his chest.

Cass pulled back completely. He was quiet only as he lubed himself up and eased Enzo up the bed. "No, baby boy," he murmured, pressing a sweet kiss to the corner of Enzo's mouth. He grabbed grabbed a pillow and shoved it under Enzo's hips, raising them up. "I ain't mad." This time his lips covered Enzo's in a desperate kiss. "I wanna keep you completely happy and satisfied." He lifted Enzo's leg up to his shoulder, almost bending his lover in half as he lined himself up.

Enzo's eyes closed, the heat from Cass' dick on his hole making him shudder with pleasure. "Please," he murmured, all rational thought leaving him. "I need ya Cass." His hands shot to Cass' shoulders, his nails biting skin as Cass began to sink in. He grit his teeth, his body protesting at first before finally giving in and letting Cass push in.

Cass' eyes fell shut in pleasure, that tight ring squeezing him and Enzo's tight channel spasming around him. "So tight 'Zo," he whimpered, letting Enzo's leg down to his side. He leaned forward, his forearms on either side of Enzo's head, their eyes meeting and noses brushing against the other. He smirked. "Tell me more. You want two cocks in ya at once?"

Enzo's entire face blanched before filling with color. "I… I don't know… 'bout that," he murmured, turning his gaze from Cass. He hadn't given the fantasy too much deep thought, not since him and Cass were in a committed relationship and he really wasn't looking for anything outside of it.

"Don't be shy baby boy," Cass breathed, leaning in and pressing kiss after kiss to the sweaty neck, nibbling at the jumping pulse. "Tell me exactly what you want." He felt Enzo's legs wrap around his waist as he finally came to the hilt. He pressed kiss after kiss to the other man's neck, breathing words of encouragement.

"I wanna get fucked an' have the other suck me off at the same time," Enzo whimpered, his hands tangling in the long blond hair. He clung to Cass as he started to slowly pull out and sink back in. "I wanna feel both a 'ya in my mouth at the same time." A gasping hiss filled the air as Cass hit his sweet spot head on. "I want ya to praise me while it's goin' on."

Cass made mental notes of Enzo's words, dedicating them to memory as he tried not to get lost in the other man's voice. "Yeah?" he asked, his pace picking up, their love making turning a little rougher. He eased up, smiling but not missing the sudden flash of fear in his lover's eyes. "Who do ya want fuckin' ya while I'm praisin' ya?"

Enzo looked away. He found a few guys in the locker room attractive, but he'd never admit that to Cass. Even if they were just talking hypothetical right then, he knew just how jealous and possessive Cass could be. He shrugged, letting out a yelp of pleasure as Cass' speed increased, sending pleasure coursing through him. "Cass!"

Cass only smirked, pressing his forehead against Enzo's, one hand sliding between them and wrapping around Enzo's weeping erection. "I'm pretty close already 'Zo," he murmured, jerking him rough and fast. He knew it was the alcohol that had his body so close, but also Enzo's fantasy. While he was perfectly content to staying in a completely monogamous sexual relationship, he wanted to indulge Enzo and keep him happy.

"Me too," Enzo answered, pushing his body up into Cass', their lips brushing together in sweeping kisses. His entire body was strung so tight, the pleasure so immense. Just another flick of Cass' thumb over the head of his cock had him screaming out as he came between their sweat slicked bodies. "Cass!"

Cass couldn't hold on, the broken cry of his name mixed with the pulsating of Enzo's walls around him and the rising tension inside him broke completely as he roared out his lover's name. He coated Enzo's insides with his release, his breath harsh and ragged as he shook.

Enzo smiled, his body laying boneless against the mattress. He loved the way it felt with Cass came inside him, claming him in the most intimate way. He let out a disappointed whine when Cass pulled back and out.

Cass collapsed next to Enzo, opening his arms and wrapping the smaller man up in them. "C'mere baby boy," he murmured, running his hand through the damp, blond mohawk. He pressed a kiss to the top of Enzo's head, listening as his breathing evened out. He laid there, thinking over everything Enzo had said. He was completely confident in their relationship that adding someone for a single night wouldn't do any harm. He trusted Enzo with everything, so why not spoil him and cross this fantasy off the list? He nodded, his eyes closing, a smirk on his lips. All he had to do now was find someone that he could trust in their bed.

(A/N): This will be multi chapter, but not long. I just needed to do something to get my mind off Shadows and I just miss writing my boys! Welp, until next time!

JacktheSinister_JaketheJust