Story: Some Loves Are Just Meant To Be

Summary: What if Stefan never gave up on human blood and had been brought up a semi-different way? He always thought he wanted Katherine, even after the way she treated him. But what will happen when he meets her twin sister, Elena Gilbert? Will sparks fly or will she just be another woman he can feed off of and use for his own personal games?

Rating: T (for safety. There will be NO language whatsoever, but I'm rating it T just in case something comes up that I choose to put in there. Will never exceed the given rating.) ;) Alright moving on…

A/N: So this is my first Stelena story, and I'm REALLY excited to write it and share it with you! Just got the idea today. I'm not sure where this story will go or where it's headed, but we all love a little drama, right? Mix in a lot of romance in there and you've got a terrific fanfic! ;) Haha. The matchups in this story will be a little OOC, depending on who I decide to stick together ;): Tyler/Caroline; Bonnie/Jeremy (Just because I miss them together ;D); Stefan/Katherine; Damon (will try to get his hands on Elena, of course, as well as Stefan, but you know he's never a committed guy! ;D)…ETC. You all know how the relationships go in the show, no need to tell ya twice! So sit back, relax, and ENJOY!

Please read and review to let me know what you think! Reviews are always the flawless inspiration I need to continue a story, plus constructive criticism is always welcome, too ...OH and any ideas for what you want to happen next, chapter by chapter, would be GREAT as well! Thank you so much everyone for taking the time to read my second fanfic in The Vampire Diaries! :D 3

~Twihardfan3194. (Kaitlyn)

P.S. The characters are out of high school, around the age of twenty. Just a heads up if things seem a little out of the ordinary! ;) Don't want to spring anything too rash. Oh, and Jonathan Gilbert is Jonathan PIERCE in this…you'll see why if you read ahead ;)

Elena Gilbert never planned to move away from New York. The whole idea was truly repulsive to her. Living in the quaint town of Mystic Falls, Virginia did not sound like the most pleasurable way to spend her young-adult years—especially when she had to become reacquainted with her twin sister, Katherine, who had been separated from her at birth when her parents, John and Isabella, divorced. But now that her mother had died in a tragic unsolved murder and there was no legal guardian to take of her, she was forced to move down to the small little town to meet her "look alike," as Elena so often liked to refer to Katherine as.

Jonathan Pierce had come to pick Elena up at the nearby airport, the drive home consisting of awkward silence between the two, for they had never really met in person. Her parents had thought it would be better that way, not knowing who the other parent was so there would not be an aching longing of the absence of an acquainted family member or guardian.

Katherine, having obligated not to accompany Jonathan while picking Elena up so she spend some "much needed time" with her boyfriend, Stefan, sat at home without the proper preparation of meeting her twin. Not that Katherine cared. Elena thought that was just fine—she would deal with the unordinary shock that would come from seeing a clone of herself when she got to her new home. Just as long as nothing too irrational happened, she felt she would be able to handle the situation as best she could.

"Welcome home, Elena," Jonathan spoke, pulling up into the driveway of a beautiful white house as he cut the engine. The town itself wasn't much, but Elena could imagine herself growing up in a home like this. There weren't any flowers in the flowerbed, but the house itself wasn't too twenty-first century to be out of place in Mystic Falls. It was a house that looked like it had been built in the late 1800's, at best.

"Again, thanks for taking me in. I really do appreciate it," Elena said, offering him a sincere smile as she tucked her long dark hair behind one ear. Her chocolate eyes shone with honest gratitude as her father returned the grin and helped his newly allied daughter move her belongings into the home so that she could properly meet her sister…

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

The sound of laughter radiated from the bedroom as Katherine lay over Stefan, his back digging into the bed as she gently caressed his chest and ran light pecks along his chiseled neck. His fingers were tangled in the dark curls that ran down her back and he moaned as her tongue ran over the spot on his neck that drove him insane, moving in small patterns that sent chills down his arms. His arms shot up to bring her face down to his lips, hardly being able to take her constant teasing. She had been doing this for the past thirty-minutes, refusing to give him exactly what he wanted. That's probably what drove him crazy about her—her constant alluring grins and seductive tongue tasting his neck and chest that never gave into what he craved the most.

Her tongue gently skimmed Stefan's lower lip, causing him to lose his breath as she clutched her tighter to him with desperation. He groaned. "Katherine, please. You're driving me crazy."

Katherine gently laughed and ran a hand down his leg slowly, causing his breath to hitch as she pressed herself firmly against him. "My father wouldn't like it if he caught the two of us making out when he brings his long lost daughter home." She looked down at him with a flirty smile and gently kissed the corner of his mouth, and working up his jawline and nibbling on his earlobe, catching the skin between her sharp teeth and tugging gently. He kept his eyes close, enjoying her touch and skin on his, before she sat up on the bed. Her tongue and mouth had tasted nearly every inch of his upper body, but she never kissed him, and it drove him mad. Stefan reached for the shirt that lay on her floor and slipped it on over his head, grumbling in protest. He was never able to get anywhere with her.

"It isn't like we wouldn't be able to hear him. Isn't that what being a vampire is about? The added abilities that mortals don't have?" he questioned as he sat next to her, raising an eyebrow quizzically in her direction.

She smiled and planted herself on his lap, wrapping her arms around his neck and drawing his face closer as she replied. "It's about power, Stefan. Don't you know that? We're so much better than those pathetic humans. We have so much more potential." She sighed with small disappointment and caressed his cheek. "Have I taught you nothing, Stef?"

Stefan closed his eyes against her touch, reminiscing in the power she had over him. They had been together since their senior year in high school—two years. It seemed like lately she was pulling away even more than usual, her temptations towards him and constant teasing becoming more pronounced. It seemed like she was just using him for her own personal lust games now, but for some reason Stefan could never let her go. Her body called to him much too strongly to ever let her go. He needed her. He craved her desperately. She was the one who had made Stefan what he was. He owed her for that.

"About this twin sister of yours—Elena. How do you feel about her coming to live with you? Or more importantly, with us?" he asked with a small wink. He usually snuck in through Katherine's window every night once her father was for certain asleep. Without her, sleep was nothing.

Katherine let out a peel of laughter. "Does it matter? My father would have taken custody over her anyway. It doesn't matter what I think. He's going to get his favorite daughter to live with him, and I'm going to be pushed aside even more than I already am. She'll be Daddy's little angel, and I'll just be the other half of her."

"You don't honestly believe that do you? That Jonathan doesn't care about you? He's known you his whole life, Katherine. You're the one he took when you and Elena were separated at birth. Don't you think that means something to him—to you?" Stefan questioned, gazing deep into her brown eyes. They were so beautiful; he couldn't help but involuntarily lean closer towards her. Her scent made his mouth water, drawing him in as she spoke softly, causing him to lean in more as she ignored his words.

"I don't mind, really. Gets him off of my back. And allows us more time to…" She grinned, trailing off as she planted a hard kiss on his mouth. He sighed in content. This was what he had been waiting for, for what seemed like an eternity.

Her body molded into his as she crushed her small waist against his chest, breathing in her scent and tasting her in his mouth before the front door flung open and closed and he forced himself to pull away for some much needed air after going for a straight five minutes. But even then Katherine's lips never left his skin as she placed sloppy kisses on his neck, causing him to weakly give into his craving for her and push her down on the mattress. It was his turn to take charge as he trailed her body with his hands…

"Katherine! Stefan! Come and meet Elena."

And just like that the moment was practically over. Just when Stefan thought he had Katherine all to himself for once, her father was there to ruin it all, or some other distraction. Katherine ran her hands over Stefan's chest, clawing his torso as she bunched up his shirt in her fists, and arched her back as she continued to kiss him with a newfound hunger. This was not the Katherine he knew, but he would take it. He roughly gripped her arms as his mouth moved in sync with hers, quick and desperate, as he pushed her further down on the mattress, knowing there was no possible way he could hurt her. He couldn't get close enough to her. Not the most attractive make-out session, but one full of passion, lust, and need, as she kissed every inch of his face…

"Now, you two! What are you doing up there?" And just like that Katherine was gone from underneath him. Even though he was a vampire himself, he would never get used to her sudden disappearances no matter how long they were together.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Elena stood in shock at the woman who descended down the stairs, beautiful dark curls hanging down her back in a curtain, her lips slightly smudged a deep red. She had the same exact eyes and bone structure as Elena, but somehow still Elena felt somewhat self-conscious in the presence of her twin. Though the two girls possessed the same gene, they couldn't be any more different.

While Katherine's hair ran down in spontaneous curls, Elena's hung lose and straight on her high cheekbones. Still beautiful hair, but nothing like the wild curls that framed Katherine's heart-shaped face. Katherine's lips were a profound red and her eyes were done up in perfect eye liner and smoky eye shadow, thick lashes curling upwards in beautiful arches towards her eyebrows. Elena possessed the same eyelashes and lips, but hers were coated in a light layer of chapstick and her eyes didn't nearly hold so much makeup. Both girls were breathtakingly gorgeous, but held their own type of beauty, whether outwardly or inwardly.

"Elena," Katherine grinned, descending down the stairs with a gorgeous man on her arm. He had brown tousled hair and a chiseled face. And his eyes—Oh my gosh—the hazel-green pools stared deep within Elena's soul as he looked her over with shock and realization that Katherine really did have a twin sister. As if this news was finally settling in for him. This had to be the guy Stefan that Jonathan had told her about. He was like a living Adonis in the flesh—possibly better looking.

"It is so nice to finally meet you! Of course I would know that you are absolutely gorgeous! I mean, you are my twin, after all," Katherine said with a sly grin and laugh, coming up and stopped in front of Elena with the fakest cheery smile she had ever seen in her life. She didn't offer her a hug but looked to Jonathan, who was examining the girls' reunion. It seemed to be going better than he had dreaded.

"It's nice to meet you too, Katherine. You're stunning yourself." It wasn't a lie. With Katherine's sense of fashion and confidence, she could bring any guy to beg on his knees for her without even trying.

"I know." Katherine's plastered a grin on her face as she clutched her boyfriend's hand at the shock on Elena's face. "I'm kidding! Loosen up," she winked. Turning to Stefan, she trailed a hand down his face and looked lovingly—lustfully—into his hazel eyes. His knees turned weak at her touch as he grinned and tilted her chin up to gently kiss her lips. Elena watched with bitter disgust and noticed that Jonathan had fled the room.

"He never sticks around for too long," Katherine spoke up once she broke the kiss, noting Elena's searching eyes for her father. Elena turned to shoot Katherine a quizzical glance as Katherine explained, "He's always busy. Don't get used to the idea of having this wonderful dad around who will always be there for you. You might as well be an orphan. He's always working, you know." Katherine shrugged her petite shoulders.

"Katherine…" Stefan warned, Elena hearing his voice for the first time. It made her heart flutter, which absolutely annoyed her as she turned the other way, his eyes catching hers.

"Oh, relax, Stef. I'm only messing with the poor girl." She shot a smile at Elena and planted a hard, possessive kiss directly on Stefan's lips before releasing his hand and sauntering out of the room. Elena could only guess that Katherine had seen her eyeing her boyfriend and was trying to make a point. Don't even think about it.

"I'm sorry about that," Stefan said a few moments later when Katherine had left the house with an inexplicable exit. "She can get to be…too much sometimes. Even for me," he admitted, weighing Elena's reaction with a stunning crooked smile. She was exquisitely beautiful, he thought. There was something different about her that separated her from her twin sister—something real and genuine that you couldn't find just anywhere…

"It's alright. She's just warming up to the idea of me being here," Elena responded, mostly trying to convince herself as she turned to face Stefan's mesmerizing eyes, much closer than she had been aware of. She gulped and slowly took an intimidating step back. "It can't be easy finding out that you aren't an only child. Especially when that sibling happens to possess your very gene."

Stefan nodded and dug his hands into his pockets, clawing his legs. Her scent was intoxicating, reeling him in like nothing he had ever felt before. He was not used to being around human girls alone like this, unless he picked one of them up at a bar and compelled her to let him feed on her like Katherine had taught him not long ago when she turned him…

"Are you alright?" Elena murmured, watching him closely with soft eyes. She sharply inhaled as she looked closer and took a step forward. Stefan looked up at the mirror behind her head to see what was causing her to react in such a way, and quickly turned away once he saw the red clouding his eyes and the rough cracks in his face.

"You're eyes…" she whispered, barely able to choke out the words. "What's wrong with them?"

"Ah, nothing," Stefan said stiffly, blinking his eyes rapidly as he fought to breathe evenly and get rid of the craving her blood brought to him. He felt her warmth drawing closer and reached up a hand to his cheek, the skin smooth once again.

"Stefan, look at me," Elena requested, turning him around so that he was face to face with the Katherine look-alike. He gazed deep into her brown eyes, and was amazed at the unaffected kindness he saw there. Never once did that look cross Katherine's eyes—he always just saw lust as well as vain and fake trustworthiness. With Elena, there was nothing but pure honesty and virtue.

"You know my name," he murmured, gazing deep into her eyes until she silently blushed and looked down at the ground. How easy it would be to just feed off of her, right then and there. With Katherine and John gone, it would be simple to compel her and snatch her up to Katherine's room for a quick few minutes…

"Jonathan mentioned you when he told me about Katherine," Elena said, looking back up again as she tucked her hair behind one ear and bit her lip. Something about her movements left Stefan speechless. What was he thinking? She was just an ordinary girl! A human! He fed off of weak humans…he wasn't supposed to find them interesting and enticing.

But that's exactly what he thought about Elena. There was something about her…and no matter how much he loved Katherine, he had to know what made her so different from her twin sister and any other human girl he had come to know.

So what did you think? Pretty good? I would like to know! Please review and also any suggestions and what should go in the next chapter or happen in the story would be nice too! Also what characters do you want me to bring in next? Are you liking the relationship between Katherine and Stefan? THANKS and I'll try to update as soon as I can, since I'm always SOOO busy! :/

~Twiharfan3194. (Kaitlyn)