AN: read the first one for a detailed summary
AN: I do not own any of the characters, they belong to their respective owners
"Alright," Scootaloo started, "this one I think will be the scariest yet"
-Here Kitty Kitty-
"A few years back, my friend Fluttershy had this big black cat she used to take care of. She found it a kitten and it was sick at the time, so she did what she normally does and took it under her care. Soon enough, it did recover and grew into a healthy adult, but something was off about the way it stared at you if you gazed at it in a certain way. It looked like, this is the only way I can desribe it, as if it had a wickedness to it...like it wanted to get you. Eventually, a gypsy I know named Zecora came by Flutter's shack to adopt a pet for herself since she was lonely. After looking around, she saw the cat and immediately wanted it, so she adopted it. Well, a few months ago, me and three of my friends, who's names are Rainbow Dash, Sweetie Belle and AppleBloom, as well as the town drunk Berry Punch decided to go into Everfree Forest, which it just so happens Zecora lives, to find a way for me to earn my cutie mark. After a full day of no luck, we had wandered deep into Everfree, and near the mysterious Zecora's home. Rumor around Ponyville is she is not only a gypsy, but a witch that nopony knew was home unless you heard her call out "Here Kitty Kitty" so we were extra cautious, until a plastered Berry Punch saw the black cat scratching its back on a nearby tree by the hut. She came up with the idea we should scare the cat, which I did not like but I was outnumbered 4-1. I stayed back while the rest of the group snuck up behind the cat, which was so wrapped up in scratching itself it did not notice the company it was about to get. When they were close enough, Rainbow let out a barking sound, making the cat jump and let out a loud screech as it took off behind the hut as they all started laughing uncontrollably. What I saw, and they didn't realize, was it had circled around the hut and was sneaking up on them, the predator becoming the prey. I could have warned them, but I chose not to since they needed to learn their lesson. Their laughing was soon quieted when the cat emitted a low growling sound. As they turned around, they saw the cat in an attack position, foaming at the mouth, and its eyes were blood red. What happened next will haunt us to our graves and actually managed to sober up Berry Punch, every step closer the cat got to them, the bigger it got causing them to freeze in fear. It continued to grow until it was at least twice as big as a panther, at which point Rainbow was barely able to mouth the words "time to go" and we all started running back the way we came. No matter how fast we ran, Dash was too scared to think to fly by the way, the cat remained right on our tails, remaining a few feet behind us the whole time. It chased us until we reached the edge of Everfree Forest, where it stopped and hissed one more time before turning around. As it descended deeper into the woods, it shrank back down to its normal size. To this day, none of us want to go back into Everfree so we don't risk another encounter with the cat again. The End."
Most of the group was now scared out of their wits and huddled together "Wow," Wanda said, "that really is scary. I am surprised you did not have nightmares afterwards."
"I did," Scootaloo said, "so who is next?"
"I will go" a young boy said