Hey everybody. This is my first story so don't be shy with your reviews. Thanks.
"Come on Casey, we're going to be late for the party", Derek said getting impatient
"Come on Casey, we're going to be late for the party", Derek said getting impatient.
"Just go on I'll meet you there", Casey shouted from her room.
Derek arrived at the party in his hockey uniform and a backpack with an extra costume (a Michael Myers costume). He had a surprise for Casey later. Meanwhile, Casey saw that her princess costume that had been lying on her bed had a huge stain on it.
"Sorry Casey, I was coming to get Freddy, my new imaginary friend, out of your room when I spilled my juice on your costume", Marty said sadly.
"That's ok Marty, I'll just borrow something from Emily." Casey said, trying to reassure her little stepsister.
About 20 minutes later, Casey and Emily arrived at the party. Emily dressed up as a nurse while Casey dressed up as nobody in particular (maybe a movie star). She wore a black dress, her blonde wig (the one she wore when spying on Derek and Emily), sun glasses, and different make-up. Interestingly only Emily knew that it was Casey; no one, including Derek recognized her. This fact came in handy when Casey saw who came in next.
"Oh no, it's Max. He's still bitter over the way we ended last week. I can't talk to him right now it's too much" Casey said.
"Hey Emily, hey Em's friend" Max said as he was passing by.
"Phew, that was close. I can't believe he didn't recognize me" Casey said relieved.
"Hey, I'm going to say hi to Derek. Will you be okay alone?" asked Emily
"Yeah, I'll be ok as long as I don't have to face Max" Casey responded.
Emily walked across the room towards Derek while Casey sat down on the nearby couch.
"Hey Derek" Emily said.
"Hey Em, is Casey here? I really need to ask her something?" said Derek.
"Yeah, Casey should be around. Your not going to do anything mean tonight, are you Derek?" asked Emily.
"Oh course not Em. Chill-ax" Derek reassured her. Of course Derek had something in mind.
Derek then went into the bathroom to change into his Michael Myers costume. He remembered how freaked out Casey was after watching Halloween. Unfortunately for Derek, when he returned, Derek couldn't spot Casey. There was no girl in a princess costume present. He figured she must be outside or something. He'll get her later, he decided.
"Cool costume dude" said another Michael Myers to Derek.
"Ralph?" Derek exclaimed.
"Yeah dude, chicks dig Michael Myers right. The dude's hilarious especially in Austin Powers" said Ralph.
"Wrong Michael Myers man" Derek said as he walked away hysterical.
Meanwhile, Casey, after seeing Max, needed someone or something to get her mind off him. She looks around for Emily, but can't seem to find her. She spots a spin-the-bottle game and figures why not. Max isn't in the game.
After about 15 minutes and a few more additional people playing, it's Casey's turn to spin. The bottle spins and spins and gradually slows down. The bottle stops and Casey looks up and jumps. It was a guy in a Michael Myers costume.
Thank God it isn't the real Michael Myers. Otherwise I'd be gone already, thought Casey.
Casey and "Michael" go into the closet. She pulls the light string down to turn off the light and he closes the door. For the next 7 minutes, Casey has the best make-out session of her life. She felt something more than what she had with Max, or any other guy. Whoever this was, he was the best kisser she had ever encountered.
Who is this guy and have we met?, thought Casey.
When the 7 minutes were up, there was a knock on the door. Casey turns the light back on only to find that her mystery guy had already put his mask back on. When Casey left the closet she saw Emily and sprinted towards her friend to tell her the news.
"Emily, I just had the greatest kiss with a guy in the closet. I wonder who he was? Do you know whose wearing that costume?" asked Casey.
"Well, I saw three Michael Myers' running around. One I think was Ralph because he complimented me on my shoes. The other though I have no idea and I believe one left already" responded Emily.
"I'm going to find the other two and get to the bottom of this. And I pray that I didn't just kiss Ralph!" said Casey. Casey scans the room intently looking for a Michael Myers. She then spots one in the kitchen. She hurries over to confront him.
"Hey, excuse me" Casey says as she taps "Michael" on the shoulder.
"Hey Blondie, what's up. Nice shoes" said "Michael" or should I say Ralph.
"Hey Ralph were you playing spin the bottle game earlier?" asked Casey sheepishly.
"Naw dude. I played that game once it made me all dizzy watching that bottle spin" answered Ralph.
"It must have been the one of the other Michaels but which one and who was it?" wondered Casey. Then suddenly a group of jocks came through knocking Casey down along with her wig.
"Dude, your hair fell out. Don't worry, you remembered your back-up brown hair. Can I keep you blonde hair?" asked Ralph.
"Yeah sure" replied Casey, still a little disoriented from the fall.
As Casey was getting her bearings back, Derek entered the room. Since Casey was no longer wearing the wig, he immediately spotted her. He snuck up behind her a grabbed her, causing her to jump.
"Boo!!" exclaimed Derek.
"Derek you jerk!!" exclaimed Casey. As she said that she fell over again.
"Happy Halloween Casey!" Derek yelled as he left the room.
I can't believe Derek. I'm going to so get him… wait a minute. Was that a Michael Myers costume he was wearing? Oh no did I just kiss Derek!?
"Em, I think I found out one of the mystery Michael Myers was. It was DEREK!! Oh my god Emily, what if was Derek in the closet?!" screamed Casey..
"What are you going do Case?" asked Emily.
"I don't know Em. I don't know" responded Casey.
To be continued...