A disclaimer: I do not own anything wrestling or anything, I borrowed from other media.
During his time away due to Seth Rollins injuring him, Finn feels betrayed by Bayley due to her growing crush on Rollins. When an Alexa (with a new Harley Quinn gimmick) connects with him, how will this affect Balor on his return?
The Balor & Bliss Club
The arrival of Harley Bliss
After winning at Summerslam and becoming the first ever Universal champion, Finn Balor was announced to have suffered an injury leading to him stripped of his first world title on the main roster. As time went, Finn began to feel depressed from being put on the self though no one seems to notice because of his mask in the form of his fake smile he shows. To make matters worse, he finds out that Bayley has nearly forgotten about him since she begun to date the man who caused his injury to start with, Seth Rollins. Granted he's slowly becoming a changed man since Triple H betrayed him and is currently dealing with his wounded leg, Balor felt ultimately she betrayed him by choosing to date Seth over him.
As the road to WrestleMania grew closer, Finn couldn't help but feel doubtful that they won't clear him to wrestle so he can return in time to an impact at the biggest WWE PPV. Despite the consistently working out to keep him in shape, WWE doctors still feel he's not ready yet.
"Who I'm kidding, more than likely they won't let me at least compete in the Royal Rumble match. Probably don't want me to have a bigger reaction than Roman Reigns nor would they let me do a revenge story angle on Rollins with him being hurt as well for I would love to get payback on him." Finn sighs to his self in his usual gloomy tone.
Out of nowhere, he hears the doorbell ring, and that snaps him out of his thoughts. "Who on earth would that be?" Finn wasn't expecting any visitors considering he hadn't much company since his time away from the traveling other than his family and at during the earlier days of his recovery Bayley.
Heading to the door and opening it, Finn's eyes go wide in shock from who he sees behind the door. "Alexa?"
Alexa Bliss, the Smackdown's women champion after defeating Becky at TLC in a table match, face the former universal champion with a nurse like attire and her hair in her usual pigtail.
"Hi, Finny. May I come in?" She greets him in a very adorable tone that throws Balor off even more.
"Finny?" He wonders to his self before moving to the side to let her enter. "Um, I guess?"
Alexa skips insides happily and takes a look around the room. "Nice place Finny."
"Thanks. So may I ask why are you here not that I have an issue with you but this is very unexpected especially in that attire." Finn curiously asks hoping he didn't come across rude to her.
Alexa playfully giggles. "Of course you weren't expecting me silly, for I figure I come by to surprise you by being your nurse and help you become better for your return."
Her response left Balor, even more, confused than before. "Help me? Not trying to be funny but you and I aren't exactly the best of friends granted we both had moved from NXT to the main roster with us being on different brands with not much interaction. Therefore, I still not understanding why the sudden interest and what's up with the whole acting like Harley Quinn thing?"
They were in his living room at this point when Alexa slowly walks over to him. "Well at first it started out as just me cosplaying the character for the Suicide Squad movie until I decided to add her personality to my character. As far as you go..."
Alexa aggressively pushes Finn on to the couch and straddles his waist before continuing, "I always been attracted to you ever since NXT I thought you were hot especially when you go all Demon King mode but of course when it came to the ladies you were with Bayley the most. I didn't make my move at the time because I thought you two were a thing. Later I found out I was wrong, but by that point, we got drafted to different brands."
Ignoring the fact that Alexa felt right on his lap, Finn could understand from her perspective on why she didn't approach him back when they were on NXT.
"So I told myself if I became the women's champion on Smackdown I will say how I feel and true enough I defeated Becky and won my first ever championship. Now that I have done that, the focus is on you Finny."
Alexa goes in to kiss him, but Finn stops her causing a frown to form on her face. "What's wrong? You don't like me?"
"Man if looks could kill." Finn shakes his head saying, "No I'm not saying it's just... okay let's say that I buy to all of this, how exactly are you going to help me become better for my return on Raw when you are on Smackdown?"
"The different brands part I'm still working on, but since you hardly back traveling yet, there are times we could see each other. I know you want revenge on Rollins not just because he put you on the self and more than likely they people will under estimate you because you got hurt. So it will be my job to bring out the side of you that will show everyone why you are the main event draw while being the best girlfriend ever." She explains to him.
At this point, Finn Balor's alter ego the Demon King decides to make his presence known for he hadn't been able to with Balor's depression keeping suppressed. Somehow unknowingly Alexa brought him out, but Finn didn't want her to know this.
"I like her, much up your speed then Ms. Hug everyone."
"Who asked for your opinion? Regardless I didn't summon you."
"Does it matter? To answer your question, Ms. Harley Bliss, here words trigger me, and in my opinion, she is what you need. What we need."
"Harley Bliss?"
"Well, she acts like the Harley Quinn character and her last name Bliss so why not?"
"... Anyways how would you know that she will like me when you're in control if anything you could scare her off if you took control."
"Or I take control, and she likes me enough to want to know what this Demon King can do."
That idea makes Finn tense up for the last thing he needs is for someone like Alexa to think negatively of him because Demon King couldn't act like a gentleman like him.
Alexa grew concern that Finn had seemed to zone out on her. "Finny?"
Finn focuses his attention back to her. "Sorry about that, you know this is a lot to take in at once Alexa. Why don't we get to know each other more and go from there?" Since Bayley moved on, it's not like he couldn't, and if Alexa had wanted a chance to date him this long, it would only be fair that he gives her a chance and see what happens from there.
Alexa grins widely at Finn's idea. "I would like that a lot."
*Later that day*
The two WWE stars went the rest of the day relaxing and learning more about each other. The topics involve Finn's time in NJPW with the Bullet Club as well as Alexa's life before wrestling, their likes and dislikes, and about their selves. Finn begun to find Alexa engaging to where he wondered how things could have been if they had of did this in the past. Finn also explains to Alexa the reason why he and Bayley hadn't become a couple because she friend zoned him and didn't want to ruin the bond they had which piss Alexa off, in her mind that sounded like a sorry excuse. However, Bayley's loss would be her gain.
During the talk, Finn did notice during their conversation that Alexa felt on him a lot making him a bit nervous while Demon King enjoyed it.
Unfortunately, it was about time for Alexa to get back on the road for she had places to go to as champion. "As much as I hate to leave you right now, I have to be back on the road for the Smackdown shows, but I will try to see you when I can."
Both sighing Finn walks her to the front and confesses to her saying, "I will admit at first I was unsure about you coming over, but now I'm delighted that you did. Hopefully, this won't be the last time."
"Oh, it won't Finny. The Royal Rumble is coming up since the event is a Smackdown and Raw PPV maybe you could come to the show a support me in my match if you can?" She presses her back on the door and gazes at Finn with a dreamy expression making it hard for him to resist her anymore.
"Maybe I will and hopefully I can get in the Rumble match this year." He looks down until Alexa encourages him.
"Here's hoping you do. Otherwise, we will come up with our plan." Finn looked back in her eyes and broke his restraint towards her with the two kissing each other passionately leading to Finn lifting her up and pinning her to the wall causing Alexa to wrap her legs around his waist continuing the kiss. When the kiss session ended, the two reveal huge smiles on their faces saying their goodbyes until they meet up again.
AN: This will be my second wrestling story that takes place in the same universe as my AJ/Charlotte story but on the Raw side of things since both stars are currently on the Raw Roster. How I decided on this pairing cause ever since Alexa did the Harley Quinn look I wonder what it would be like if she took on a gimmick like her and since Finn is my favorite, felt that he should have returned as a heel, I figure why not put the two together.
Like my other story it will follow some of the current events on Raw but with some changes towards Finn's return if I continue to update this.