*Note: Set in early season 14*
"What'd we got caption?" Olivia said as the team walked into the bullpen "Four women, all raped and tortured in Manhattan. Two in Central Park, two in an alley. This guy seems to strike in twos. All the women said he was rough, and he was armed. Benson, Fin. Munch is out sick, you'll be switching partners for now. The victims are very scarce of men. They've demanded all their doctors be women and request the cops are as well. Rollins, Benson go interview the vics they're still at the hospital. Fin, Amaro, you go to the crime scenes. Stay alert! This guy is quick and he is dangerous." And with that, Cragen sends the detectives on their way.
Amanda and Olivia arrive at the hospital and each get a description of the suspect. They decided it would be easier if they split up to take statements so the women didn't feel crowed. Once the sketch artist came to the hospital Olivia and Rollins returned with a sketch of the perp and got a hit off it by the time they got back to the squad. "Name is Jeffery Milligan, lives in Manhattan, drives a blue van, and works at a shipping yard." Olivia reads off the screen to the caption "Pick him up." Cragen says. As Rollins and Olivia head out, Amaro and Fin walked in with another sketch. The two women hear Cragen tell them to also pick him up after they ran their suspects name and with that, they all head out.
Amanda and Olivia arrive at Milligan's apartment under 10 minuets. They knock on the door as they announce theirselves before kicking down the door. They walk in, guns raised, and search the small apartment. Once they clear it, they call it in to Cragen telling him Milligan's not there. "Cragen said Nick and Fin are running down a lead and that we have stake out duty on Milligan." Olivia informed Amanda "Got it." The young detective says as they walk back to the car. Around ten minuets later Fin and Amaro called Amanda and asked if they need anything. The girls told them were were getting hungry and could go for some pizza so the boys went and grabbed them one and brought it back to them. "Anything?" Fin asked as they rolled up next to the girls and handed them their food "Nothing so far. How about you, any leads?" Olivia asked "Same for us. All we've got is a name, a face, and a car." Amaro says "Yeah same here." Rollins "Cragen's calling, we got a hit. You two have fun." Amaro says as they leave the girls with their pizza and drinks as their stake out begins. What felt like hours had passed and they had only seen a woman and a young child go in and out of the building. No one has seen Milligan in days, they'd be lucky if he even came home. Olivia's phone lit up, bringing Amanda out of her thoughts as she saw the name Calvin pop up. Olivia smiled and replied to the text. Amanda had heard mentions of a Calvin in past conversations but she never knew who he was. Amanda saw Olivia's bright smile dim as she looked at the picture of herself and a young boy at what looked to be a carnival. "You good?" Amanda asked, trying not to be nosy. "Yeah..That picture just..Took me by surprise." Olivia said. Amanda tried to hide the curious look on her face but Olivia noticed it and decided it was something she couldn't avoid. "Calvin's mother Vivian.. I took her case. She gave me parental custody of him. She was on a slippery slope and thought he'd be better with me. We got pretty close.. He started writing his name as Calvin Benson. He said it was because I.. Because I saved him..." Olivia managed to choke out "His mother came back into his life shortly after that and decided he's better with her parents then me. She took back custody and told me I couldn't see him again... I can't even describe how grateful I was when his grandparents told me I could see him whenever I wanted. We took that picture soon after they told me that. We all went to the carnival. One of the best days of my life." Olivia says. Amanda opened her mouth to reply but was stopped when a thick white spray came out of the air vents causing them to start choking. The windows wouldn't bust. The doors were stuck. They were passed out in seconds.
When Olivia woke, her hands and feet were taped to a bed. Rollins was sitting in a chair, taped to a pole. A man stood in the corner smiling as he realized Olivia woke up. "Hey sweetheart." He says, Olivia struggled with the restraints when she realized who he was... Milligan.