It was after the Born This Way performance. Rachel was smiling at herself in the mirror. She realized that she didn't need a new nose to be beautiful.

She already was.

Then she heard the bathroom door open. She turned to see who it was.

"Noah? What the hell are you doing in here!" she whispered, just in case there were any girls in the stalls

"I love you" he said quickly

Rachel couldn't believe what she just heard

"You're the first girl I've ever…."

"Told that to" Rachel finished his sentence

"Yeah" he gave a half smile

"I want to be with you. You're the only one who actually knows me. For real. You don't think I'm a Lima Loser, like everyone else in this school"

"Noah, I…"

"Please say you love me back" Puck already knew the answer, and his heart was being crushed

"I still love Finn" she said, seeing the hurt in his face

"WHAT'S SO GREAT ABOUT FINN HUDSON!" he yelled, slamming his hand against the wall

"Noah"

"Forget it!" Puck yelled, and stormed out of the bathroom

"Noah, wait!" Rachel called after him

"Don't bother, Rachel" Quinn stepped out of the stall

Rachel's eyes went wide. She heard everything.

"I think It's time we had another talk" she stepped up to Rachel

"Listen, and listen good. Finn is mine. Nothing is going to change that"

"He picked me over you" Rachel said softly

"WHEN ARE YOU GOING TO GET OVER THAT RACHEL? God." Quinn yelled

"If I were you, I'd go find Puck, and say yes. Because, you're never going to have Finn"

"You don't know that" Rachel said, in tears

"I do. I know he will never get back with you" Quinn said, and stormed off

Then she stopped, and turned around

"Just be happy someone is in love with you. Even if it is Puckerman" she said in a disgusted and annoyed voice, and walked out

Rachel looked at herself in the mirror, and began to cry