Hey, so this is my first Supernatural story! It's the first in the series "Missing Pieces" and I wanted to let you all know that the only thing I changed was that Mary died when Sam was 1 and Dean was 5.
By the way, I don't own Supernatural. If I did, I would be a freakin' princess!
Chapter 1
Sam and Dean Winchester were sitting in a diner in a small town in Southern Idaho called Mink Creek.
"Here's your food." the waitress said, placing a plate of food in front of each brother.
"Thank you." Sam said kindly.
"Thanks." Dean said winking at her.
She walked away smiling and Sam rolled his eyes at his brother's sad attempt at flirting.
"Do you have to try to pick up every woman we meet?" Sam asked Dean.
"Yes. You should know that, Sammy." Dean said, "So what are we here for, anyways?"
"Two people: Lilly Smith and Abby Wilder. They were killed in the same week in the same way. Car crash."
"Sooo?" Dean asked, his mouth full of food.
"So, they both crashed in the same place. In the same week. No one had ever crashed there before. Sounds a bit weird, doesn't it?"
"Weird enough for me. Let's go." Dean got up, throwing money on the table to pay for their meal. The two brothers walked out of the diner and towards Dean's beloved Impala. Dean got in the driver's side and Sam in the passenger. Dean started the motor and they sped off.
"Do you have any idea where we are supposed to be going?" Sam asked.
"Not a clue." he responded matter-of-factly.
"Near the edge of town." Sam said.
The two drove on in silence (if you count Dean blasting Metallica silence). Sam just sat there staring at the map and seething at the volume and music choice. About fifteen minutes later, the brothers pulled up at the place where both cars crashed and turned off the radio (much to the relief of Sam) as a police officer walked up.
"What do you think you're doing here? You can't stop here." the officer said.
Dean and Sam looked at each other. Sam did not expect there to be police at the scene. The last crash was last night and he expected all of them to be done here by now.
"No worry officer, we're just passing through." Dean said with a smile. Sam looked at the officer with a similar smile.
"Alright move along." he said, obviously suspicious.
The officer walked away and Dean rolled his eyes and pulled away from the one place in town they needed to be. Dean steered the car back towards town.
"What are we doing?" Sam asked, "We need to get in there!"
"Yes well we won't get much done with that guy breathing down our necks. He obviously doesn't trust us. He might not have bought our usually 'We are totally cops' routine. We are going to wait until tonight and we'll come back. They will have cleared out and we will have the place all to ourselves."
"Ok." Sam replied, nodding.
"Now where's the nearest motel?"
