Gibbs's eyes were wide with shock as Mike finished telling him how his life would be if he had never killed Pedro Hernandez.
"What happened to Tony in that situation?" He finally managed to ask.
"You sure you want to know Probie?" Mike asked.
"Yes" Gibbs replied.
"OK but, just a warning it ain't pretty." Mike replied.
See when Kate could have shot Ari but, just couldn't do it in your world he shot Gerald but, in this universe she still couldn't do it but, in this world he shot at her. Now he missed but, her fiancée Tony shot and killed him. He also brought Ziva in when she was arrested and well there is no easy way for a man to say or hear this but, she well kicked him in a place no man wants to be kicked. That cost DiNozzo his ability to have children. Of course Kate wanted kids so she and Tony decided to get a sperm donor. A man named Robert Calverez well Kate fell in love with him and she wound up cheating on Tony with him. Said he was a "real man". She got pregnant with his child and broke off her engagement to Tony. Second women to break his heart and you know what a bitch that can be. The team gave him no respect after you left and your leaving hit him really hard that's true in both worlds. However in this one Gerald never got shot thus Jimmy never joined Ducky and well Jimmy was the one who got Tony through your absence and the team's lack of respect. So Tony had nobody to turn to. About a month after you retired they found him face down in his apartment surrounded by beer bottles. Alcohol poisoning he'd been gone a week nobody even cared to check til his neighbors called the police because they hadn't seen him and smelled something funny.. You know who came to his funeral? One person Jenny Sheppard and she only came because she was the Director of NCIS and Tony was an active agent so she had to.
Gibbs was horrified Tony had basically killed himself granted this was fake but, it could have far too easily have been real. Tony was such a nice guy deep down and he didn't deserve a funeral attended by only one person who had to go at such an early age from alcohol poisoning. He deserved to die in his sleep at an old age and have a large funeral attended by his family and friends. Gibbs was so thrilled Tony had that chance.