I'm terribly sorry to post one of these, but I've looked high and low and am now desperate.
I'm looking for a story about Puck and Rachel. It starts w/ them post high school, dating, and in the midst of a bit of roleplaying in the bedroom. Rachel tells Puck it was always her fantasy in high school that he would ask her out. Puck decides to take her home to Lima. The plan backfires since Rachel really doesn't like to be surrounded by the place/people that didn't believe in her. Puck's sister helps him come to this realization. And in the end Puck dances w/ Rachel at his sister's high school dance (I think they're the chaperones).
It may have been deleted, but if it's still out there, I'd really like to reread it and any help would be much appreciated!