Chapter 1: The Usual Disappearance
Sam and Dean sat in a coffee shop near the back of it. Newspapers scattered the table.
"How about this, a woman killed in the middle of the woods. Blood turned grey," Sam suggested. Dean shook his head. "That is called nature, not the supernatural," he replied with sarcasm. Sam sighed and looked back the newspaper. "Then how about this, 8th grader mysteriously disappears in alleyway. Witnesses claim she went in but never came out. All that was left was a shoe." Sam looked at his brother. "Think it might be our case?" he asked. Dean nodded. "Worth checking out," he replied. The two brothers got up, left the check, and walked out.
"Honey these are detectives," a man said as he led Sam and Dean into the living room of a fairly large house. "They wish to speak with us." a woman, cuddled on the couch, looked up at them. It was obvious she was crying and miserable. "H-Hello. I'm Lisa Schmitt," she said dryly. Dean held out his hand. "Sean Soot," he said as they shook hands. "So what has been happening with your daughter?" he asked. "Before the disappearance. Anything different?"
"Now that you mention it, Maddie was acting different before the disappearance," Mr. Schmitt said. "More secretive. It was like she was pushing us further and further away. We used to be such a happy family together too." Sam and Dean exchanged glances. "I guess it was because of the accident," Mr. Schmitt continued. "Accident?" Sam questioned. The father nodded. "Maddie was on a trip with her aunt and uncle. The car crashed. Surprisingly our daughter got out of it without a scratch. Mary and Jo on the other hand… Mary survived, just barley. And Jo was killed. Dean nodded, as if unsure what to make of it. "Thank you for your time," he said as he shook Mr. Schmitt's hand. "We'll tell you if anything comes up."
"What do you think?" Sam asked while they were driving away from the house. "I don't know what to think," Dean replied. "The girl could have made a deal with a demon… but the damn thing would've left the body." "So this is different?" asked Sam. Dean nodded. "I wanna visit that alleyway."
When they reached the alleyway, the two got out of the car. The walls looked like they were ready to swallow whoever walked in whole. "Creepy bitch huh?" Dean muttered as they walked in. Sam got out the EMF detector. The alleyway was empty. A large brick wall stood at the end. "Anything?" Dean asked. Sam shook his head. "Nothing," he replied. They looked around for a little longer before leaving. "I don't get it. Not even the EMF picked up anything," Sam said.
"Well it might not be a spirit then," Dean said. "Might be a Demigod or a person. Who knows." Sam thought for a moment. "Didn't the father say that Lilith became secretive and was pushing everybody away?" he asked. "Yeah but what does that have to do with this?" Dean asked. Sam looked at his brother seriously. "I've heard of cases like this before. Girls between the ages of 10 and 16 pushing their family and friends away," he explained. "And then disappearing without a trace."
Dean suddenly gasped. "Dad looked into this before!" he exclaimed. "I remember him saying it was strange almost… magical. He talked to one girl about it. She said nothing. Next time he went to talk to her again, she disappeared." "Well it's settled then. We look into this a little longer," Sam stated.
A girl watched the two men drive away. They were close. So close. Another Witch had come to the alleyway. The girl was relieved. Choosing a case like this was something the Winchesters should have never done. The girl hoped they would never come back.