Alfred
"You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become a villain."
-Harvey Dent, Batman: The Dark Night
01. RussAme "Fall"
Alfred used to be good. He used to be an angel, a hero. But, all that changed.
No one could really pinpoint when the shift started, but Alfred supposed it could be when he met Ivan.
Ivan Braginski was a beautiful man – at least, on the outside. Alfred later foud he was wicked and corrupt, but it was too late for him. He had already fallen in love with Ivan, and in doing so, broke the rules all angels had to obey.
Ivan was a fallen angel.
02. CanAme "Love"
Alfred missed Matthew the most. They lived together, died together, and spent the afterlife (rather, the part of the afterlife Alfred spent in Heaven) together. They were brothers – adopted brothers, rather – and sometimes more. They were best friends and, occasionally, lovers.
That was something else that caused Alfred to fall – his impure love for his (adopted) brother.
Still, he missed Matt. He may partially blame Matt, but he still missed him.
He still loved him.
03. USUK "Debt"
Of all the Fallen Angels Alfred met in his time as one, Arthur was the most intriguing.
He spoke in a snobby British accent and his speech was littered with curse words, despite his claims of being a gentleman. He was also the only one to attempt to fix his ragged clothes and manage to make himself appear presentable.
But what was really interesting about Arthur was that he was nice. When Alfred first fell, he took him in and showed him he ropes, while the others were content to let him struggle on his own.
For that, Alfred was forever in his debt.