Toby's on his way over to Spencer's for a movie night when he spotted Alison sitting on her porch. He tried his best to avoid her, but he still caught her eye. "Toby, hey" Alison says while standing up. Toby pauses and looks at her. He wanted nothing more than to ignore her and run to Spencer's. "Hi Alison" he waves at her awkwardly. "Come over here I want to talk to you". He stutters over his words "I really should be getting to Spencer". "Come on I just want to talk to you for a minute" she says with a smirk. "Fine" he sighs while slowly walking towards her. Alison meets him haft way down the steps. "What do you want to talk about?" he asks. "I just wanted to see if we're okay. I know you said the night I disappeared you forgave me for what happened to Jenna" she says. "I forgave you, but that doesn't make us friends" he says firmly. She frowns "that's a shame, because we were friends once a long time ago before Jenna, before A, even before Spencer". Toby smiles to himself "yeah until I saw your bitchy side".

"I'm sorry Toby. I'm sorry for the way I treated you and I'm sorry for what I said about your mom. I'm sorry for everything" she says almost sounding sincere. He nodes "okay, I should really get to Spencer she's probably looking for me". He turns to walk down the path, but Alison stops him by grabbing his arm. "Wait Toby" she says while turning him around. "Why Spencer?" she asks. "What'd you mean?" he asks. "I mean why did you pick her why are you so okay to kiss her, but not me?" she questions. "For one she's MY GIRL and I love her. She took the time to get to know me when no one else did. When I was accused of murder she was there for me and I was there for her!" Toby was practically yelling at this point. "She may have been there for you, but I am ten times hotter than her!" she yells. Toby shakes his head "you're wrong". "Stop the games Toby I know you wanna kiss me!" she shouts. He shakes his head "never". Alison steps forward and strokes his arm "Come on Toby you want to kiss me forget about Spencer for a minute and just kiss me". Alison closed her eyes and started coming in for a kiss. "No!" Toby shouts while pushing her back. "What the hell!" she screams. "You must be a big fan of near death experiences, because if Spencer knew she would kill you for sure!" he yells. Alison scuffles Spencer doesn't scare me". Toby shakes his head and walks quickly over to Spencer's.

When Toby entered the Hastings house he could smell popcorn popping in the microwave and coffee brewing in the coffee pot. He spotted Spencer standing in front of the fridge with the door open. He chuckled to himself when he heard her mumble and curse to herself as she rumbles threw the fridge. She finally closes the fridge and turns around to see her handsome boyfriend standing there. Her face lights up as she smiles. "Hey Toby" she walks over and pecks him on the lips. "Hey" he says nervously. He was still worked up about what just happened outside. He knows he should tell Spencer, but is afraid of her reaction. He knows she'll be pissed and most likely try to kill Alison. He also knows that if he keeps it to himself and she finds out. Spencer would kill them both. Spencer noticed the worried look on Toby's face. She walks towards him and grabs his hands. "Hey, is everything okay?" she asks with full concern. He fakes a smile and nodes "yeah I was just thinking about how much I love you and how forgiving you can be". She laughs and says "okay, is that all you seem distracted?"

He shrugs his jacket off and lays it on the back of the chair he was sitting on. "Um Spencer you remember when I told you about Alison being rude to my mother?" She nodes and lets him continue. "You remember when I told you my mom walked in on us?" Spencer rolls her eyes "yes". "Well I was just wondering how you would react if Alison tried to kiss me?" he asks. "I would be pissed why do you ask?" For the secant time that night Toby started stumbling over his words as he spoke. "I'm not saying Ali's tried to before or tonight even I was just wondering what your reaction would be if she did". Spencer's face turns red and her eyes fill with anger. "Did she try to kiss you?" she asks. "What" he asks trying to avoid an argument. 'Alison, did she try to kiss you!?" she yells. "Um well uh" he tries to speak. "I'll kill her!" she shouts while standing up. Toby stands up and places his hands on her shoulders. "Spence relax nothing happened I pushed her away its okay" he says. "No it's not okay nobody tries to kiss my boyfriend! I don't care if she just got back from the dead, she's dead!" Spencer yells while heading for the door.

Spencer runs outside and Toby chases after her. "No Spencer! Spencer wait Spencer!" he tries to stop her, but she wasn't stopping. "She is so dead I told her not to cause you anymore trouble!" she shouts while marching up Alison's porch. Without even knocking Spencer barges into her house searching for Alison. "Alison!" Spencer yells. Alison walks out of the kitchen. Her eyes widen once she sees me and a pissed off Spencer. Alison screams in fright when Spencer tackled her against the wall. "I told you to stay away from him if you even think about touching him again I'll kill you!' Spencer shouts while slamming Alison's back against the wall. Toby pulls Spencer away from Alison. "Spencer stop let's just go". "Toby should have been with me, he always belonged with me!' Alison shouts. Spencer steps up and slaps Alison across the face. Alison turns her head back at Spencer and glares at her. "Spence" Toby says while turning her to face him. She looks at him her eyes burning daggers into his brain. He grabs her chin and tilts her head up, so she's looking at him. "You don't need to worry about Alison I love you and only you". Spencer attempts a smile and says "I love you too". Toby puts his arms around HIS GIRL and presses a tender kiss upon her lips. The tenderness gives away to passion.

"Oh! You guys are so gross can't you two at least wait until you get back to your house?" Alison says in discuss. They weren't stopping the two kept making out as if their lives depended on it. Alison almost threw up in her mouth when she saw them kissing with tongue. "Okay, fine I'll leave!" she exclaims while heading for the back door. She opens the door and looks back at the two love birds. She shivered in discuss when she heard moans coming from their mouths. Alison finally walks out and slams the door behind her.

Meanwhile Spencer and Toby were too busy making out to notice Alison leave. Toby presses Spencer's back against the kitchen counter. She giggles into his mouth once he picked her up and set her on top of the counter. She wraps her legs around his waist and moans at the feeling of his tongue exploring the inside of her mouth. Spencer moved her hands down to unbutton his shirt. Once she unhooked all the buttons, his shirt went flying across the room. The next thing to go was Spencer's jacket and scarf. Spencer moaned when Toby began kissing down her neck. "Tobes" she breaths out 'Yeah?' he asks. She pulls away from his kisses and smirks at him "I think we should finish this over at my house". He nodes "oh right". Spencer giggles again when Toby picked her up and carried her all the way back to her place. Once they got there they started making out and ripping off each other's clothes while heading up to Spencer's bedroom.

After hours of making multiple rounds of love to each other the two finally got exhausted and went to sleep safe in each other's arms. The next morning they woke up to the sound of someone knocking on the door. Spencer walked over to her dresser and put on one of Toby's shirts that she's "borrowed" and walked down stairs. When she opened the door she saw Alison standing there with the dark gray shirt that Toby was wearing last night and her jacket. "I think you left some things at my house" Alison says awkwardly while handing them to her. Spencer grabs the clothes than slams the door in her face. "Who was that?' Toby asks while walking down the stairs. "Just Alison returning our clothes" she says. Toby reaches for his shirt, but Spencer yanks it back. "I don't think so it's mine now". "Theft" he teases. She laughs "oh you know you love me in your clothes". "You know" he says in a low seductive voice "I'm starting to think you've been stealing all my shirts so I won't have any left to wear". She smiles and winks "now you're catching on". He smiles and puts his hands on her shoulders "your right I do love seeing you in my clothes, but I like you better without any clothes" They both smirk and go in for a kiss. They start making out when toby moved them to the couch to have a repeat of last night.