A/N: This is my take on what happened when the Warblers returned to Dalton after Sebastian threw the rock salt-laced slushie at Blaine in Michael.
"Sebastian, what the hell was that?" Nick yelled when the Warblers walked back into the school; Nick and Jeff followed Sebastian into the rehearsal room. "You obviously tampered with that slushie; Kurt told us the worst thing those things could do would be some ruined clothes, not someone freaking out about their eyes burning."
"Goes to show what happens when you listen to Gay-Face," Sebastian sneered. "Not that any of you little bastards would've known, a little rock salt never hurt anybody; besides that slushie wasn't meant for Blaine, it was supposed to hit Kurt."
"You are such an asshole, you know that, Sebastian?" Nick said, moving closer to the taller boy, who merely smirked at him. "What's your deal with Kurt and Blaine? Did Blaine turn down your advances or something?" Sebastian's smirk became a scowl as he grabbed Nick by the neck and slammed the smaller boy against the wall.
"Listen here, Duval," he snarled, ignoring Jeff pulling on his arm to release Nick. "I don't know what you may have heard, but if you ever bring that up again, I will kill you. Do you understand?" Nick didn't answer. "I said do you understand?" He slammed Nick against the wall again. Nick nodded while glaring at Sebastian. Sebastian let him go and walked away, but not before he turned around. Nick, who leaned against the wall rubbing his neck, froze; Jeff by his side. "And one more thing, if either of you tell Kurt and/or Blaine about this, it gives me another reason to kill you both." Sebastian left the room and Jeff nuzzled next to Nick.
"I love you, Nicky," he whispered.
"I love you too, Jeffy," Nick replied, stroking the blonde boy's hair.
"I think Blaine did turn him down or something; besides, we should go apologize to Blaine and Kurt, no matter what Sebastian says," Jeff said.
"In the morning, we'll go to the hospital, okay?" Nick promised.
The next morning, Nick and Jeff slipped out of Dalton unnoticed and drove to the hospital. The two walked up to reception.
"Is there a Blaine Anderson here?" Nick asked.
"Yes, third floor, room sixteen," the receptionist said. The boys were nervous as they rode the elevator up; both had encountered the temper of Blaine's boyfriend Kurt and were terrified of it. They walked towards room 16 and heard Kurt's soft voice flowing from the room.
"You go in." Jeff pushed Nick in front of him.
"Oh hell no, you go in. It was your idea," Nick said. Jeff poked his head in.
"K-Kurt?" he said, trembling. Kurt looked up and he strode towards the door; if looks could kill, Jeff would be dead in a microsecond.
"What are you two doing here?" Kurt demanded. "Come to hurt Blaine again?"
"Kurt, we're sorry. We had no idea what Sebastian was planning," Nick said, taking Jeff's hand. "Can we see Blaine?"
"Kurt, who is it?" Blaine called.
"Come on." Kurt nodded and led the two into the room.
"Blaine, Nick and I are so sorry about what happened," Jeff said, biting his lip. "He told us himself that he had put rock salt in that slushie and it was intended for Kurt."
"I know you guys would never intentionally hurt either of us, and I accept your apology," Blaine said, smiling softly. His eyes widened suddenly as he looked at Nick and Jeff's hands. "Did you two finally get together?"
Both boys blushed and nodded. "Yeah, Jeffy finally admitted his feelings for me about two months ago," Nick explained.
"Shut up, Nicky. I did not. You told me you loved me," Jeff said, lightly smacking Nick's arm.
"Aw, aren't they cute? Already got Nicky and Jeffy," Kurt cooed and Blaine chuckled.
"And the world now has Niff," Blaine proclaimed.
"Anyway, guys, um, we just wanted to apologize on behalf of the other Warblers. Sebastian didn't tell any of us about the slushie," Nick said. "But he said he'd kill us both if we told you."
"You guys aren't afraid of him?" Blaine looked up.
"No, we're not. He's all talk," Jeff shrugged.
"Nick, Jeff, you have to listen to me," Kurt said quietly, bending down in front of the two boys. "Sebastian isn't just talk. You saw what happened last night, but you don't know why he wanted to do that to me, do you?" The boys shook their heads and Kurt sighed. "Sebastian wants Blaine, but because Blaine and I are together, he sees me as an obstacle and he'll stop at nothing to get me out of the way. I don't want you guys to get hurt. Promise me you'll stay away from Sebastian."
"We promise," Nick and Jeff said simultaneously and Kurt embraced them.
"Hi, is there a Blaine Anderson here?" Sebastian asked, walking into the hospital, a bouquet in hand.