The Dare
Author's note: This story idea came to me as I was watching undressed it's an old show that used to be on MTV. What if the girls on vampire diaries were having a girl's night out and played a truth or dare game. This is another Bonnie Damon story as well; Bonnie Jeremy are not together in this story either. The sacrifice played out as it did on the show with two exceptions Stefan never left with Klaus and the Damon Elena kiss never happened; one other change Klaus took Katherine with him when he left mystic falls.
Chapter 1: Truth Or Dare?
Bonnie, Elena, and Caroline decided to have a girl's night out against Bonnie's better judgment because she just knew that things in her life didn't ever go as planned especially in mystic falls. She would have bailed on the idea completely if it wasn't for Elena and Caroline persisting that she comes with them.
"I mean it guys this is a really bad idea; why are we doing this again?"
"Chill and relax Bon, we so need to do this because if one more bad thing happens and we all die tomorrow then at least we will have fun tonight. Besides we haven't done this in so long, you know just hang out without any men around; speaking of men, when are you going to get one Bonnie?"
Bonnie was drinking something and started coughing when Caroline asked her that question.
"Caroline, why did you ask me that question and besides all the good men are taken by you and Elena."
Elena spoke up, "That's so not true, I mean sure, I have Stefan but Caroline is single again or haven't you heard? Matt broke up with her because of the whole she's a vampire thing. Isn't that right Caroline?"
"Oh yea, I did hear something about that but I guess that I assumed that they really broke up because of Tyler."
"What where did you hear that? There is nothing going on between me and Tyler we are just friends."
"Oh, sorry if I misspoke but that is what people are saying around school."
"I just bet that it was that Amy girl, she always had a crush on Matt, she's probably happy as hell that Matt dumped me. He claimed that he just couldn't handle the whole supernatural world that I live in now. As far as Tyler goes though, I actually think that there could be something there but I'm scared of following down that road because of the whole, I'm a vampire and he's a werewolf thing. Plus this is the added bonus that we have become really good friends and if we tried it and it ended badly then I would lose a good friend too, you know? Hey you totally changed my focus from you to me; we are not talking about my messed up love life; we are talking about the fact that you don't even have a love life ok? Now where was I? Oh, right finding you a man; let's see who is single in mystic falls right now? Matt but he is out for obvious reasons, there is Tyler but he's totally crushing on me, oh I know Stefan's brother Damon, he's single right?"
Bonnie's face turned three shades of red, then she said, "Oh hell no, for obvious reasons as well."
Elena spoke up, "Why not Bonnie, he is single and attractive, what's wrong with you dating Damon?"
"Seriously, me and Damon Salvatore dating, yea I don't see that ever happening in my future. And what's wrong with him? Where do I begin first, how about the fact that he's a psychopathic, sadistic, serial killer, vampire, or how about the fact that he abused Caroline? I have an even better reason how about the fact that he is in love with my best friend? Are those not enough good reasons for me to steer clear of him altogether or what?"
"Relax Bon; I was only kidding about Damon because I knew that it would tick you off severely, come on now let's play either truth or dare or we can play I never, which do you guys want to play?"
"Fine let's play, I never and then we can play truth or dare ok."
Elena spoke next, "Ok, I'll start I have never kissed a werewolf before." "That's not fair; you know that I am the only one that kissed Tyler here."
"No that's not true Caroline but he wasn't a werewolf then though so it didn't count."
Elena Caroline both stared at Bonnie in sock with their mouths hanging open. Then they both said at the same time, "When did you kiss Tyler?"
"It was at one of his parties awhile ago; and technology I didn't kiss him but he kissed me. It wasn't a big deal which is why I never told you guys about it happening, so just drop it."
Elena had to ask, "Well tell us about it now, was he a good kisser?"
"I don't remember it was too long ago; ask Caroline if he was a good kisser."
"Well Caroline?"
"Let's forget about this and go back to playing the game."
Bonnie replied, "Fine, I never had sex with a vampire."
Elena replied, "I never kissed my boyfriend's best friend."
Caroline replied, "I never had two brothers in love with me before."
"This is not fair Elena, because Bonnie has yet to get any points."
"Don't worry, I have a good one, I have never set a vampire on fire with my mind before."
Bonnie relied, "I have never had sex with anyone."
"Wow, Bonnie, so you have never given up your v-card?"
"No, I was waiting to be in love and it just hasn't happened yet."
Caroline replied, "Fine, moving on, I have never had a double vampire looking like me."
Bonnie replied, "I have never been turned into a vampire before."
Caroline replied, "I have never given a vampire a migraine before."
Elena replied, "I have never had magic powers before."
Bonnie replied, "I have never been in love before."
"Ok new game, let's play truth or dare." Caroline declared.
They all agreed to start playing truth or dare.
"I'll start, Bonnie truth or dare?"
"Why do I have to start first?"
"You have to be first because you are the most inexperienced out of all three of us."
"Fine, ok I choose truth."
"Is it true that you let Tyler go up your shirt, when he kissed you?"
Bonnie turned bright red as she said, "No, that is so not true and I would never. If you are so concerned about what happened why don't you just ask Tyler then? He was so drunk that he doesn't even remember kissing me but trust me it went no farther than a kiss. If you don't believe me then just ask his mom, because she walked in on us and then I left because I was beyond embarrassed by the whole situation ok?"
"Fine, I believe you but it just sort of threw me when you told us that he kissed you. Moving on now, it's Bonnie's turn to ask one of us a truth or dare?"
"Oh, I know who I'm going to ask; Caroline truth or dare?"
"I am so choosing truth."
"Ok, truth who is the best kisser that ever kissed you?" "Um, let me think, I'm not sure, Damon's kisses were hot but Matt's were sweet, I think that I will have to say Tyler is the best kisser because his kisses were hot, sweet and a bit spicy as well. Ok, my turn again, now Elena truth or dare?"
"I will pick truth."
"Oh, I so have a good one for you, tell me is it true that you are just leading Damon on or do you want both Salvatore brothers as Katherine did?"
Elena got real red and mad, "That is so not true at all. I love only Stefan but I can't help what Damon feels for me though. I would never ever be with him, even if Stefan and me didn't work out, I would never be with his brother, the same way that you guys would never be with Stefan if we broke up right?"
"No of course I would never do that." Bonnie said looking at Caroline.
"Oh, what are you implying that I would because of Matt right?"
"I wasn't implying anything Caroline but you kind of tend to cross boundaries; especially when the opposite sex is involved."
"Just what are you implying Bonnie, that I'm a boyfriend stealer?"
"No, of course not that came out wrong; what I meant to say was that you just didn't follow the girl code when you started dating Matt. The only reason that Elena didn't say anything was; because she was so in love with Stefan; and so wrapped up in the supernatural world that she didn't even notice at the time. Besides she probably figured that you guys needed each other because at the time you guys were the only humans that didn't know about the supernatural world and I guess she wanted it to stay that way."
"I know and that was really wrong of me and thanks for bringing up Matt again considering how that ended for me."
"Sorry I didn't realize that he was such a touchy subject still."
"Ok let's move on with the game then, who's turn was it next?"
Bonnie spoke up, "I think that it was Elena's turn to pick and ask someone a truth or dare question."
"Ok, I pick Bonnie, truth or dare?"
"I pick dare."
Caroline said, "Oh, we are so deciding what to make her do together but after we go to the grill first."
"Why do we need to go to the grill?" Bonnie complained as if she didn't want to leave.
"We have to go and get drinks and besides I want to dance, let's go."
"Fine but if we run into the demon then I am so out of there."
Caroline says to Elena quietly "Ok, great let's go then, because I have a plan on what to make Bonnie do."
The grill was crowded as they walked in but there was no sign of any of the men that they new personally, which Caroline considered a good thing for her plan to work.
"Ok, we're here, now what is my dare?"
"Elena, you do the honors, we discussed it and we both agreed."
"Ok, watch the door to the grill, the next person that walks through it in the next 5 seconds, we want you to run up to him or her and kiss them; full on the lips with tongue too."
"You guys so can't be serious? I mean anyone could walk in that door."
"Please with your luck it will probably be a hot guy like Tyler, just do it now?"
"Fine but just wait until, it's your turn, I will get even."
Bonnie went towards the door and for a minute it looked like Stefan would be the guy that she was going to kiss. He opened the door but before he could enter Damon walked into the grill as Stefan was holding the door open. Before she could change her mind, Bonnie walked right up to Damon and before he could utter a word she was kissing him on the mouth hard. As she started to pull away from him, he pulled her back to him tighter and started to kiss her more deeply than before. Caroline and Elena were standing there in shock as everyone was watching Damon Salvatore and Bonnie Bennett were heavily making out with each other.
Stefan chose to speak up at that moment, "Um, excuse me did I miss something? Damon? Bonnie?"
They broke away reluctantly from each other.
Bonnie spoke up first, "It wasn't anything, and it was just a stupid dare."
Even as she said these words they felt hollow to her as if she were lying to everyone including herself. As she was talking and started to turn away, everyone could tell that she was affected by Damon's touch, much more than she would ever admit to him.
Damon pulled her back to him, and said, "Wow that was some kiss for just a dare. Are you sure that you didn't like it just a little?"
Bonnie's face got bright red, then she said, "Oh please you wish. I know why I kissed you but why did you pull me back and kiss me again?"
"I don't need a reason for kissing a beautiful woman, who was all over me as you were. Besides I didn't see you struggling too hard to get away from me. What was that about?"
"I told you it was a stupid dare; you act as if your god's gifts to women or something but your more like the devil's plague on humanity instead. I did try to get away from you too but you were holding me in place."
"Why didn't you use your powers on him Bonnie?"
Caroline asked her because it sure looked like Bonnie enjoyed Damon touching her.
"I just didn't have time to react to him; that's all, now drop it."
"Fine, let's go, I'm bored now."
Then the girls all headed towards Elena's house for the night. It's a week later after the kiss; when Bonnie sees Damon again by accident. She shows up at the boarding house because she thought that Elena was meeting her there.
"Elena, is anyone here even?"
"Yea, I'm here but Elena's gone off somewhere with my pathetic excuse for a brother. Why are you suppose to be meeting her or did you just want an excuse to see me again?"
"Yea right you wish Damon as I told you before the kiss; it was only a dare and nothing more so please don't let it go to your head?"
"I think that you are just mad because you liked kissing me a way too much."
She was going to say something but her phone started ringing; it was Elena.
"Bonnie, hi I am so sorry I forgot that we were supposed to meet up after school; Stefan surprised me with a picnic in the park and I guess we just got caught up with each other. I will make it up to you for dinner my treat ok?"
"I guess I do have to study later, so pick up a pizza and I'll meet you at your house at eight ok?"
"Yea, that sounds great see you then."
"Wow eight that's almost three hours away what will you do with your time until then?"
"That's none of your business Damon. I'm leaving now."
"Wait, we still need to talk about what happened last week."
"There is nothing to talk about; it happened it's done with and it will never happen again."
"I don't believe you; in fact I think that the only reason that you stopped and pulled away was because Elena and Caroline were there; in fact I think that you wouldn't have stopped kissing me if they weren't there."
"That is where you are wrong; I don't like you at all."
"Really, well prove it then?"
"How could I prove it to you?"
"Well no one is here now; so if you really didn't feel anything when you kissed me before kiss me now?"
"Will it shut you up and prove to you that I don't like you?"
"Yea, it will unless you're too scared to kiss me?"
"I'm not scared of anything and I'll show you how much I'm not scared."
With those final words Bonnie pulled Damon to her softly and kissed him on the lips. It didn't last long as she pulled away after a few seconds but he pulled her back to him more fiercely and said, "My turn now."
He started kissing her passionately; he held onto her as if he was afraid she would disappear at any moment. What surprised Bonnie the most was how responsive she was to his touch. After a few moments she was clinging to him as if she needed him to breathe air. Before either one of them even realized what they were doing; they ended up in his bedroom.
Before it went any further than a kiss; Damon stopped and said, "If you want me to stop then you better say something now?"
Bonnie responded with, "No, please don't stop touching me."
Before she could even think to change her mind both of their clothes were ripped off in a matter of seconds. Damon wasted no time; even if she would regret it later, he had to have her now.
A few hours later; Bonnie awoke first, "Oh, my God, what have I done?"
Damon heard her and smiled then he said, "I know, I'm good but it wasn't God that made you feel like that it was me."
As he tried to reach for her but she shrugged him off; saying, "Oh my God what time is it?"
"I don't know almost eight o' clock why?"
"I was supposed to meet Elena like five minutes ago. She is probably wondering where I am now."
She searched for her phone and noticed that she had at least five missed calls; four from Elena and one from Caroline.
Before she left she turned to Damon and said, "This never happened got it?"
"Will it never happen again?"
"No, I have to go but you better keep your mouth shut or else."
After she left she called Elena, "I am so sorry, I forgot about my history homework until the last minute; I was doing it and I lost track of time. I am on my way to your house now ok?"
"Yea, no problem but why didn't you answer your phone though?"
"Oh the battery was dying so I put it on the charger and shut it off to charge quickly but I'll see you soon ok?"
Bonnie couldn't believe that she just lost her virginity to Damon Salvatore of all people; it felt surreal to her. Damon didn't even realize that Bonnie was a virgin until after she left and he saw the few drops of blood on his sheets. When Bonnie arrived at Elena's house Caroline rushed out to meet her.
The first words out of Caroline's mouth were, "Oh, my God Bonnie Bennett who did you give your v-card to? You better tell me now?"
"I don't know what you're talking about? I didn't have sex with anyone."
"Wait, I bet I can figure it out, you don't even have a boyfriend and you are not the type of girl to just hook up with someone."
As Caroline pondered who it could be a familiar scent it her and she didn't like it one bit.
"Oh my God you had sex with Damon Salvatore, why would you do that Bonnie?"
Bonnie tried to cover the truth but it was hard to do when there was a vampire involved who could smell Damon all over her.
So she did the only thing she could, she confessed. "Ok, fine I admit it, I had sex with Damon, please don't tell anyone?"
"Fine, I'll keep it a secret but you have to tell me how it happened in the first place?"
"It just happened earlier today, it wasn't a big deal. He dared me to kiss him again without you guys there and I did. It just didn't stop there though; I'm not sure what happened but I wanted him in the worst way. I know that I should regret it but I don't; I feel ashamed that I don't regret it though. I just don't want anyone to know about this ok?"
"Fine, I can keep a secret you know. Will it ever happen again or was this just a onetime thing with Damon?"
"No it will definitely not ever happen again; it was defiantly a onetime thing."
"Ok, but you might want to comb your hair unless you want Elena knowing that you had sex because you have bed sex hair."
Bonnie was in such a hurry that she didn't even notice how messed up her hair was; she fixed it before she went inside to see Elena though. She just hoped that no one else could guess what she was doing merely a few minutes ago with Damon.