This topic came from Tumblr, really. I saw a shitload of gif sets about making Kevin and everyone who had died into a team in Heaven to take down Metatron. So, me and CastiellaWinchester94 wrote the following together. We edited each other's and will be posting on my account for this story more as we continue to write. Thank you Cas! Love you!
The last thing Benny remembers for sure is that he got Sam and his friend to safety in Purgatory. He stayed behind to do what he had always done best, hunting and killing monsters like him. And he did, for a very long time.
Until one day the swell of vampires was too much for Benny to handle alone, and it left him pinned to a tree, his machete in the hands of some unknown vampire. Benny didn't think about how to escape, no, he thought of what Hell was like. Because there was no way that he was going to Heaven. Benny closed him eyes as the vampire swung the blade around to his neck. He was ready for the pain.
But there wasn't any.
Instead, he felt like he was lying down somewhere...somewhere nice. And somewhere familiar. A jazz band played softly in the distance and Benny could feel grass underneath him. He opened his eyes and found a brilliant blue sky above him, puffy clouds framing it.
"What the Hell is this?" Benny asked to himself as he sat up. He heard a man chuckle softly and Benny was on his feet and turned around. There was a guy, kind of short, with a scraggly face and kind eyes. He was smiling at Benny sincerely.
"Hello Benny. It is wonderful to finally meet you." The man said, reaching out to shake Benny's hands. Benny backed away and bared his teeth.
"Who are you, and what happened!?" Benny snarled, and the man, instead of being afraid, laughed.
"No need to be hostile here, you're safe. You are in Heaven." The man explained. Benny looked around and finally recognized the area. It was New Orleans, when Benny was a kid. The town was brand new but still beautiful. But Benny shook his head.
"I am a monster. There ain't no way I ended up in Heaven. And who are you?" Benny demanded.
"My name is Chuck. Or, as many other call me...I'm God."
"Yeah, and I'm that vampire from Twilight. Now tell me who you really are before I gut you like a pig!" Benny shouted. Chuck, or whoever he was, raised his hands in defense.
"I'm just here to talk, Benny. I don't want to hurt you. It's about Dean and Cas." Chuck said, somewhat sadly. That caught Benny's attention right away.
"What about them? Are they hurt, or dead?" Benny inquired, getting closer to Chuck.
"One of my children, Metatron locked all the angels out of Heaven. But he did worse to Castiel. He stole his Grace and made him human. Dean just lost Sam and his friend Kevin. He is not fairing well. You see, Sam was dying, so Dean either had to let him die or let an angel possess him to heal him from the inside. The angel claimed to be Ezekiel, a 'good' angel as you might say. However, Metatron found him and revealed him to be Gadreel, the angel that doomed man by letting the serpent into the Garden of Eden. He killed Dean's friend and told him that Sam was gone. He is not gone, just tucked into the body further, so he cannot eject Gadreel. Now, Castiel and Dean need help to reopen the gates of Heaven, but from the inside. So, I am constructing a team of hunters and other people who have ever helped the Winchesters. You are one of the most qualified to help them." Chuck finished, and Benny looked at him.
"So, you're makin a kill the angel dick, no offense ta your kid, team so we can reopen Heaven to the angels? What about Cas' Grace thingy? Can we get it back?" Benny inquired, and Chuck nodded.
"If I can get to Metatron at his weakest, then I could not only get Cas' Grace back, but also kill Metatron with a single touch. I do not want to kill my son, but if he does not give up the Grace, I will do it. And remember Benny, you have a choice here. You can either come with me and help Dean and Cas out, or you can stay here. This is your personal Heaven. New Orleans, 1875, around the time you were growing up. You can enjoy yourself here for the test of Eternity. So, what is your choice?" Chuck finally questioned. Chick held hos hand out in a handshake and looked at Benny for the deal. Benny thought for only a second before taking it and shaking.
"I'm ready to kick that angel's ass from Heaven to Hell."