Summary: What if Christopher was not Rory's real father, but who else could be?

It was late at night and Rory was talking to Chris on the phone. Lorelai could hear her daughter talking to him about her day and what has been happening. Lorelai just sighed and closed her eyes. If only she could tell Rory the truth. If only she could tell Chris the truth. He deserved to know the truth. So did Rory. She hated herself for making Rory think Chris was whom he was. Her parents will hate her when they find out the truth. Why did she tell Chris that day? Why didn't she tell the real guy? She sighed and started to head out the door then remembering she had to tell Rory she was leaving.

Lorelai: Rory I'm going out!

Rory: Where, it's 10:00 at night!

Lorelai: Why Luke's of course. We can't live without his precious coffee

Rory: (laughing) Ok mom bring me back one

Lorelai: Ok sweets.

Rory smiles and heads back to her phone conversation with Chris.

~Luke's~

Lorelai walks into the diner not caring that it says closed. Luke looks up and smiles.

Lorelai: Coffee for the go. Make that 2

Luke: Coming right up

Luke: So where's Rory?

Lorelai: Talking to Chris

Luke: Oh

Lorelai gets her coffee and leaves when she walked through the door she hears Rory telling Chris the words that he never deserved to hear from Rory's mouth.

Rory: I love you dad

Lorelai sighed. Chris didn't deserve to hear those words, Luke did.

A/n: So what do you think? Please tell me what you think.