I have an idea of making one shots for the Edolas characters about their past. In Earthland, Natsu and his teamates had sad pasts, so I guess their counterparts also had sad pasts.

Father ?

I thought you love mother.

Loved ? What does that mean ?

And who is this ? Mother just past away weeks ago, and you brought a woman, a woman in our house ! Maybe I am being too sensitive...

Wait. Isn't she the woman who slapped mother ? Why is she here ? Why are you with her ? Who is she ?

Tell me father. Tell me .

No. You are lying. You said that you love mother. You said that she's your one and only. You promised that you will love her forever. You swore that you won't fall for another woman...

Father. I want the truth. I am a kid but it doesn't mean I am that stupid. Don't lie to me. Don't lie to mother.

Are you asking me to forget her ? Are you serious ? She is my mother ! She is your wife ! How could I ever forget her ? How could you !

Look in my eyes. Look in them. And tell me the truth. Don't tell me that you don't love her anymore. I don't want to hear that. Please.

Stop that. Stop it. STOP IT ! You are lying ! I don' t want to hear it anymore... You love her ! Not loved ! Tell me you love her, and get rid of this woman !

W...What ?

You slapped me... you slapped your daughter because of this woman ! I remember it now...there were times that mother always got red prints on her face. Is... it you or her ? Or you two do it together ?

Ha.

You hit me twice. Right on the face. Because of I've said the truth. Am I your daughter ? Do you love your daughter ? Do you ever, love your wife and daughter ?

Haha.

The third. You are hesitating at the question, right ? I know.

You said yes ? But I can smell the stink of insincerity in your voice. Can you ? Who will you choose, your daughter or this woman ?

This women... made mother sad. Mother was crying because of you two. How dare you make mother sad ? HOW DARE YOU ?

Ouch. This one hurts. A lot.

I never thought blood was that sweet. I never thought I would have a chance to taste it. Thanks to you , my dearest father.

Father.

Can I still call you father ?

Oh. I 've got your permission now. But I don't want to call you by that name. You are not my father anymore. Not when you start betraying us. Me and mother.

Ah. There you go.

I guess you won't stay silence forever, right ? But that isn't polite to hit someone before you talk, right ?

You've quite forceful, woman.

I won't hit you back. I wish I can. But I promised mother not to hit any woman that he brings. I thought you were kidding, but it turns out he did bring a women home. But I will obey my mother's orders, no matter how nonsense they were.

Excuse me ?

You want me to call you 'mother' ? honestly ? Do you think you really deserve it ? I am trying to respect you, lady. So don't talk stupid.

What is that ? A... whip ? Where does that come from ? No. You won't do that, you won't do that...

But seems that I've underestimate you.

Look at that. LOOK AT THAT.

Ah, I am bleeding. Beautiful drops of red. And you, father just turned away. Nice way of being a father. Oops. I forget. Former father, FORMER father.

Now I can see it. The sadistic smile on her face. Can you see it, former father ? Oh. I forget. You are love blinded. How can I forget ? Foolish me. I should be glad that you two don't use the power of teamwork.

Another fountain of blood. No way I am going to cry. No way. Not in front of you. Instead I am going to laugh. Can you hear that ? Haha...

is quite deep. But that doesn't stop me from laughing. I am fine, I am alright. I am happy, you know ? I am a cheerful girl. Lalala...

The man went out and smoke as the woman continued her whipping. When she tasted the mixture of blood and tears, the little girl displayed a smirk.

I hate liars.

Erza goes first because I love her. I thought Erza will act tough and strong when she's broken. Maybe too OOC. Inspired by a mess it goes by he is we.