"This was a great idea!" Said somepony.

The confused clone looked around, only to find ponys that looked exactly the same, dozens of them, all staring at her, then she realized… fun! Of course! She was a clone of these people, it was so much fun to have herself bounce around. Suddenly every pony went to the pool once again, and started bringing out even more, oh yes, Pinkie Pie!

This was so much fun, all of them, bouncing around. "Maybe I should try cloning myself again, and then my two clones cloning themselves, and then those four clones cloning themselves… and then… lots of fun! I would never miss out on anything in ponyville!"

She stepped towards the pool and said the charm that granted a clone of you… she whispered,

"And into her one reflection she stared, yearning for one whose reflection she shared, and solemnly swear not to be," suddenly as she said the words, dark thoughts, dark… fun… went through her mind. She could never do that, never, she was made when thinking of fun, fun should be her only thought... then she said the last words… "Scared, at the prospect doubly there."

Another Pinkie Pie came out, and she looked just as fun as the others, thinking of fun! The new Pinkie started to bounce around like all the others, but one could always notice something off… uncanny about that one. Maybe it was the wide smile, larger and more happy than the others, or the eyes with small pupils, but one could always agree that it was, uncanny.

0

The horde of Pinkie Pies had gone, gone for good, Pinkie Pie had cloned herself, and had finally got out of it, to be honest the five other ponies didn't actually know if the Pinkie Pie that won was the real Pinkie Pie, but they knew that there was only one now. Except they didn't. They thought that, but in the back of Fluttershy's head she asked, "Wait, couldn't there be one more, er… one we could have missed, I mean, there were a lot… heh heh… nevermind."

The other ponies looked at each other, and it came to the sudden realization that she was right. "There could be another one of them, and they could get more, and more, and more… until the whole world is covered with Pinkie Pies, and then they would double that! Then double that… oh this is bad… extremely bad!" Exclaimed Twilight, frustrated at not realizing this sooner.

"Well what should we do… cast a spell that allows us to see how many Pinkie Pies are in equestria, and where?" Asked Applejack.

"Um… i've never heard of a spell like that… it would take searching, and the whole crystal library might not even have anything like that!" Pointed out Twilight.

"Then we have to search, or just put a rock over the cave... that's it! Put a rock over the cave, if we do that nobody can get in!" Realized Rainbow Dash.

"Or out," whispered a small voice, belonging to Fluttershy, "if somepony is in there, then they would get trapped!"

"Nonsense, if anypony dumb enough to want to go in that horrid place after what happened, then… I don't know…" Rarity said.

"Look, there isn't gonna be anybody in there, and that's final." Applejack decided, glancing towards the dreaded forest in which the horde of Pinkie Pies came from.

Twilight sighed. "I'm just mad this whole situation had to happen."

They headed off to the evergreen forest, it always felt like the eyes of creatures from the unknown were watching them, every single breath must have been heard to the corners of it. Finally, they got to the entrance of the cave, they worked together, and finally sealed it, using Applejack's strength to their advantage.

The cave from the inside was now dimly lit, the pool slightly reflecting. Yet, after they thought no one was in there… there was. It was Pinkie Pie, yet, Pinkie Pie was with them… that didn't make sense… well of course it could make sense. Pinkie Pie is smart, and smart enough to not get caught by Applejack while he was rounding them up. This Pinkie Pie was the one the real Pinkie Pie noticed something slightly off about… The clone looked around, it was almost pitch black, except for the faint light of the pool. No... she didn't need to clone herself. She just needed to find a way out.

She looked around and saw a tunnel, the only one, and she followed it. For miles, she followed it, hell-bent on getting through to the other side. Finally, after almost a days walk of climbing, squeezing, and jumping, there was light. She got out, the daylight as bright as looking straight into the sun. She was in the middle of the evergreen forest, "Right," she said to herself. She knew this path... right in front of her was zecora's hut. Perfect. She went up to the door, and knocked. Tap Tap Tap. Zecora answered. "Hello Pinkie Pie, what brings you here?" She asked.

"I'm looking for something, a dream maker, perhaps." She replied.

"Of course, I'm sure you have a good reason to want something, that can make dreams, what is it?"

"I want to put… er… Gummy's birthday party, yes, it was so fun that i'm sure they would love to have it in their dreams!"
"But wasn't your pets birthday a week ago?"

"Yes, but I just thought of this idea now!"

"O.K. then, you can borrow it, return it by next week."

Pinkie Pie ran off with it, smiling, in an uncanny way, waiting to use it. She had a plan, a plan to do what she always wanted to do.

Nighttime came, Princess Luna was probably watching over the night, this was the perfect time. Pinkie Pie snuck up to where Rainbow Dash had been sleeping, on a tree, and used the potion, let her drink it, and made the dream. It was a dream of torture, pain and misery. All cause by Pinkie Pie. The evil clone left immediately, for Rainbow Dash woke up only moments after.

She kept causing the dreams, five more times, even putting it in a cupcake for rainbow dash to eat, and then get affected by in cloud city. She could almost read Dash's mind, as she went crazier and crazier, with each dream, and Pinkie Pie behind her, secretly watching.

Finally, almost a month of waiting, Rainbow Dash went to Pinkie Pie's, the real Pinkie Pie's, shop. Pinkie Pie asked if she wanted some cupcakes, and this made rainbow dash look sick, she had purposely affected Rainbow Dash's dream for they're to be sleeping drugs in that cupcake, even having dreams on the real Pinkie Pie to give her a random cupcake.

The conversation went on, and then suddenly, to Pinkie's happiness, Rainbow Dash picked up the knife, and said, "Pinkie, please, just go, leave, now!"

"Uh… is this like a prank or something?" asked Pinkie Pie, "Here have a cupcake!" You wish it was a prank. Suddenly Rainbow dash slit part of Pinkie Pie's snout, the one watching from the window laughing maniacally, inside. "WHY COULDN'T YOU JUST STAY AWAY!" Rainbow dash stabbed her again and again, until there was barely any life left. Pinkie Pie muttered a few words, but it was too hard to hear outside of the glass. She wasn't dead, the clone new that. Rainbow Dash shouted, "SOMEPONY, ANYPONY, HELP!"
Rainbow dash ran out of the shop, and the other Pinkie Pie came in. Pinkie Pie, thinking it was Dash, said, "You… you stabbed me… stay away from me."

"Oh poor Pinkie Pie, I didn't stab you, Dash did, Dash did, Dash did..." The voice echoed into her mind. The only thing the stabbed pony thought, Dash.

Part 2 coming out soon.