"I'm out to get you," a whispering voice said. Pinkie Pie was running in the streets of Ponyville, terrified of getting killed by the mysterious pony. She reached a dead end, meaning one thing- she was done for. A pony emerged from the darkness of the night. She had a straightened mane and had darker mane and skin tones than Pinkie Pie. "Please don't hurt me!" Pinkie shouted, but the pony drew closer. "Your dead to me Pinkie," she said, twitching and acting crazier by the minute. She picked up a knife from the floor, and that's where all was lost. "THIS IS THE END OF YOU!" She screamed and laughed insanely. Pinkie was welling up with tears as she was cornered.

The insane pony came close to Pinkie, and stabbed her with the knife. As Pinkie fell to the ground, she ran off with the knife to go kill some pony else. Her work there was done. In Pinkie's eyes, the place was dark, and soon after the place went dark. It was all over…

…Or was it?

Pinkie woke up, breathing heavily and shocked. She lay there for a while, thinking about whom this weird pony in her nightmares were. She kept on having these nightmares every night, and was terrified of them. It was always about her running from a psychopath serial killer. After lying there thinking about the dream for some time, she went downstairs slowly. She was always worried about the dreams, especially Cheese. Pinkie and Cheese had been together for some time, and she didn't want these dreams to stop their fun at parties at night.

"Hi Cheese…I had nightmare again." A tear went down her face. Cheese hated talking about the dream, but he knew that sometimes he had to. "These dreams have been going on for some time, are you sure that they won't just go away?" He asked. "I don't know, I've been having them for some time now. Maybe Twilight knows what's up with me…" Pinkie walked away slowly to the door. "Where are you going?" Cheese asked. "To Twilight's place. Maybe she can cheer me up and help me get through this." Cheese followed Pinkie and they went off to the castle.

As they went to the castle, they thought about what caused the dreams. Was it fears? Was it some pony in Ponyville? Was it a curse? They didn't know, but there's one thing they knew: Twilight was their only hope. Who wouldn't help a friend in need? "Dreams about a pony out to kill you? Hmm, maybe it's a pony in Ponyville…" After asking Twilight, Pinkie was hoping that she had the answer first time. "I'll look into it. It could be anything. For now, I can't really help you guys." Disappointed, they went home.

With no answer, Pinkie went off for a walk around Ponyville to think things over on what it could be. Meanwhile, Cheese helped Twilight find out what was causing Pinkie's dreams. About an hour of research later, Twilight found the solution, but it wasn't at all what she expected. "Uh Cheese, you know where Pinkie is…right?" Twilight looked horrified. "No, why?" As he too found out the truth, him and the princess ran off to find Pinkie.