A/N: I have no idea how OkCupid works, just so you know. I've done a bit of research but that doesn't tell me much, so please forgive me if I don't get things right. This is based on two lines in the episode 'And the Icing on the Cake'.
For a couple of days now, Caroline has been on OkCupid, trying to find a match. There were various guys she got, but out of the few, there was one that caught her eye. Jon Walker, if she wasn't wrong.
He seemed perfect – he looked terribly good, and according to him, he was rather gentlemanly. He was in between rich and poor, and had a many things in common with Caroline. She had been chatting with him for the past day or so, and the longer they chatted the more perfect he seemed.
..::..
Three days ago, before Max had left the house to get another packet of poor people chips, she had walked behind Caroline browsing through something on the laptop. Max decided to take a peek.
Well, who would have thought that Caroline was on OkCupid, under the fake name Ashley Burns? Max grinned before turning away and pushing the door open, acting like nothing had happened.
When she got back, she created this fake account and started to screw around with it, answering the questions how she'd expect Caroline would, and soon enough, she found Miss Ashley Burns. Max being Max tried her best to think of a male equivalent of Caroline.
It was sickening, the whole time she chatted with Caroline. It was simple once she got the hang of it, 'Jon's' dream scenario or things would be what made Max gag and throw up, such as walks on beaches and faith. But waiting to reveal to Caroline – or 'Ashley' – that her dream guy was her roommate all along would be so worth it.
..::..
All the talking about love made Max think about Deke and the awkward 'I love you' that morning. She needed to talk about this. And who else better to talk about it other than the blonde giraffe sitting outside?
And perhaps at the same time Max could tell her that she was the one Caroline had been talking to.
And what else would she have done?