AN: I have not actually seen tvd, so I apologize if anyone is ooc. If you politely review telling me that (and how ) someone is ooc, I will try to fix it so long as it doesn't interfere with the story I have planned. This fic is mainly bamon with hefty sides of defan, baroline, and steroline. Also not particularly Elena friendly. As to when this fic occurs, put it at some point after stefan returns from klaus, Caroline is dating Tyler, Elena is dating Stefan but falling for Damon, and Bonnie and Jeremy broke up. If no such time exists, just treat it as minorly au.
Standard disclaimer applies. Anything recognizable is not mine and belongs to associated writers. Hope you all enjoy.
"I still don't know why we need to do this. Obviously Stefan is your soulmate." Caroline complained.
"Because I have to know for sure." Elena groaned. "I need to know if I belong with Damon or Stefan and if Bonnie can help me with that then I want to find out."
"Elena, if you don't know by now, a spell giving you the answer won't make your decision for you. Magic can't make up your mind for you." Bonnie pointed out quietly.
"Bonnie, please do this for me. You and Caroline are always pointing out how I need to stop waffling between them. If this will help me decide, shouldn't you help me?" Elena begged. "Please? For me?" she pouted when she saw that Bonnie was about to crumble.
"Okay. But I still don't think this is such a good idea." Bonnie sighed.
Caroline rolled her eyes. She never understood where Bonnie's unfailing loyalty to Elena came from. Sure, they were best friends from childhood, but Elena hadn't been an especially good friend to Bonnie the last couple years. But Caroline knew better than to say anything right then. She decided to mention it to Bonnie later, took a seat around the kitchen table, and watched as Bonnie set up everything she would need for the spell.
Bonnie lit five candles and set them in a circle around a mirror on the table. She looked at her grimoire, probably memorizing the spell Caroline thought, and then began to chant.
"Deliberatione speculo speculum magis quam ostendunt. Ostenderet , alterum dimidium." She repeated the spell three times, then handed the mirror to Elena. "Just look in and it should show you the face of your soulmate."
Elena gulped. "Okay. This is it. Here goes." She looked in the mirror. "Tyler?" She gasped.
"WHAT?" Caroline shrieked, snatching the mirror to take a look for herself, not believing that Elena stole another guy from her. "Elena, what are you talking about? That's Stefan." She sighed with relief.
"No. That's clearly Tyler." Elena snapped, trying to take the mirror back and looking in again. "See?" She held it up for Caroline.
"Nope. Still Stefan."
All three of the girls froze with simultaneous realization. "No. no, no, no, no, no, no." Elena whispered.
"This CANNOT be happening." Caroline stated while staring at Elena in horror.
Bonnie started laughing. "I can't believe you're dating each other's soulmates."
"It's not funny. It's super weird." Caroline moaned.
Elena sighed. "Bonnie, why don't you see who your soulmate is? Take our minds off of this awkward situation."
"Oh no. That is a question I would rather answer for myself. Besides, this is way more entertaining." Bonnie snickered again.
Caroline was starting to get really irritated with the whole situation and Bonnie's complete lack of sympathy, so she picked up the mirror shoved it at Bonnie, saying "If I have to know who my soulmate is, so do you."
Bonnie tried to close her eyes but it was too late. A horrified look appeared on her face followed by a shriek. "NOOOOO!"
