A/N:

This takes place in season 5 after episode 11, when Roger starts to suspect Kate is part of little Ben's disappearance. Except in my version, Roger ignores Jack's advice and reports Kate to Horace the same night, and Miles is successful in deleting the tape with James (Sawyer) and Kate taking Ben. Therefore we don't have the problem with Phill.

Most of the flashbacks are from what's actually in the show, but I will add a few of my own ideas for dramatic purposes. Cause y'know. Drama. Dharma. Lol ok let's get started! *whispers*Dharma drama...

Bang Bang Bang! Roger banged on the door of Horace Goodspeed's medium sized, yellow dharma house.

"Damn it, now what?" Horace said aloud to Amy. He got up from the bed he had been laying in with Amy and walked to the door. Bang band bang! Roger banged on the door again impatiently. Roger opened it, clearly annoyed, to a partially drunk Roger.

"What do you want, Linus?"

"Horace, listen to me, she did it! I know she did! She's one of them! She took my boy!" Rambled Roger as he pushed his way into Horace's living room where Amy stood confused.

"Uh, Amy...Um..." Horace gave her a look that she almost instantly understood. She smiled at Roger, and walked back into the bedroom silently. "Roger, what's going on? Slow down."

"Horace, that girl, the new one with the dark hair and freckles...Kate I think.." Roger took a breath and continued slowly, "I think - no - I know she has something to do with my boy being taken."

"What'd ya mean? Austen? How could she-"

"When Ben disappeared, I didn't see her until a few hours after he'd been gone. And then she comes to me later and says I shouldn't worry and he'll be okay, and then when I asked her what she meant - Horace, it's her."

Horace looked Roger straight in the eyes for a good five seconds, processing what he was just told. He took a deep breath, and grabbed a rifle, storming out of the house with Roger right behind him.

Kate opened her fridge and bent over to peer inside. The dharma initiative kept everything stocked well, including the refrigerators of their employees. She reached in to grab a white carton of orange juice. She still had her blue dharma jumpsuit around her waist, but she had taken off her socks and shoes. Her feet were tired from the long day it'd been - taking Ben to the Others, and then for the rest of the day she tried to aquatint herself with the motor pool and its tools, but she mostly ran errands for Juliet.

Jack was visiting with James and Juliet at their house, when the three of them stop their conversation at the sound of a loud thud - the sound of Kate's door being kicked in.

Just as Kate started to pour orange juice into her glass, thud! Her door had been kicked in, causing her to jump and drop her glass on the cold, hard tile floor.

Jack, James, and Juliet rushed outside in time to see two angry men with guns storm into Kate's house.

"What the hell?" Said Juliet, honestly expecting no response.

"Kate." Said Jack and James simultaneously.

Jack started to dash over to her house, but was stopped by James's arm.

"Stay here, doc." Said James, in his calm voice that still clearly displayed worry.

Jack stayed put on the porch with Juliet and watched as James walked quickly over.

Kate stood in the corner of the kitchen, with her hands up by her head.

"W-what's going on?" Kate's voice hesitated.

"Shut the hell up, you know exactly what's going on!" Roger shouted at her.

"I-I think there's been a mistake" started Kate. "I don't kn-"

"shut the hell up!" Roger shouted again, slower but louder. This made Kate shift in fear, causing her to step on the broken glass she dropped moments before.

"Ah!" Kate said quietly in pain.

"Yo, what the hell's goin on in here?" Asked James as he walked in.

"LaFleur, tie her hands" Horace ordered.

"How 'bout you answer my question first?"

"Shes one of them. She's the one who took my boy!" stated Roger, Horace still pointing his gun at Kate.

James sighed as he shot a glance at Kate, before walking to the motor pool to get zip-ties.

"James, what's going on? Where's Kate?" Jack asked, as he walked quickly behind James.

"James?" Juliet pried after there was no response to Jack's question.

"Listen to me, they figured it out about Kate" started James as he continued walking swiftly to the motor pool. "I ain't got no choice, or they'll figure it out 'bout me, too. If that happens we ain't got no chance here...or ta help Kate. Y'all just gotta let me do my thing, I gotta plan. Ya just gotta trust me, got it?"

"Y-yeah." Jack said, stopping in his place even as James continued walking, Juliet hurrying behind him.

"James, what-" started Juliet.

"Where do ya keep the zip ties?" James sighed as he started rummaging through the metal motor pool drawers.

"What?" Juliet asked in surprise, pretty sure she knew what they were for.

"Where are they?" He asked again, this time stopping to tower over her in order to get an answer.

Juliet sighed and closed her eyes, before answering, "second drawer from the top, all the way on the left."

James yanked it open, then pulled out two zip ties.

He returned to Kate's house with them clutched in his hand. He clearly - at least to Jack - did not have a plan. He was panicked, and fumbling over his own thoughts racing around his mind. Damn it, Jack. We'd made a life here, and then you all came back. Things already were starting to decline rapidly. The 'mix-up' at sign-in with Kate? The burning dharma van? The fire? And now Sayid? And Ben? There was too much happening too fast.

"Here" said James, handing Roger the zips ties.

Roger walked over to Kate and turned her around, and slammed her face onto her kitchen counter while tying her hands behind her back.

"Wait, I need shoes" said Kate, once again cutting her feet on the broken glass as they started to march her out of her house.

"No ya don't" said Horace.

James couldn't say anything to help her, not without blowing it all. All he could do was shoot her a regretful glare as she was forced by by Roger.

A/N:

Yes I know Lost ended several years ago, but I found it on Netflix and I love it! Binged all the way through it😂

I'll update when I can. Please review! Thanks for reading 3