"Amy, come look at this," the Doctor said. "Come see what I found."
"What is it?" Amy asked.
"It's a picture of you from high school that the TARDIS spit out. I don't know why. It just did for some odd reason," the Doctor replied. "Look."
Amy looked at the picture. It was indeed her from high school. She was sitting on her bed looking down at something. The Doctor tried to see what it was, but it was too small to make out. Amy tried to remember what year it was, and then she remembered. She remembered the exact day and the very details of every event. She had never told anyone, not even Mels or Rory. It was her very well kept secret.
"I remember that day," she spoke vaguely.
"What happened?" the Doctor asked curiously. "Anything interesting happen?"
"Doctor, before I started dating Rory, I had another boyfriend in high school. His name was Billy. Rory, of course, always hated him and said something bad was going to happen to me if I kept seeing him, but I always brushed off. Well, Rory was right, but I never told. I never told anyone except Billy, and when I did, it didn't end well. You have to keep this to yourself. You can never tell anyone," Amy said strictly.
"I promise. Now…what happened?"
"We had been dating for like 5 months, and things started moving really fast," Amy started, "and I mean really fast."
"You got pregnant, didn't you?"
"I never meant for anything to happen. We were young and stupid and careless," Amy said through her sobs. By now, the Doctor was holding her, trying to calm her down.
"I believe you. I really do. What did you do then?" the Doctor asked. Amy could tell from his speech that he really did believe her and felt sorry. He truly did.
"I told him. I told him as soon as I found out. After I told him, he asked me what I was going to do, so I said I couldn't be…you know. I just couldn't, so I went to the doctor's office."
"Did you have a…" the Doctor started. He couldn't say. He just couldn't.
"Yes. I felt really bad about it. I hated doing it, but I just couldn't be pregnant. After it was over, we tried to go back to normal, but it was just impossible. Then one day Billy and I got in a fight. He said that I was a terrible person for doing it. I tried to calm him down, but he just kept going. Then he dumped me and broke my heart. Later night, he called. I thought he was trying to apologize, but he was really just calling to tell me about how I was worthless trash," Amy cried. She couldn't stop the tears. They just kept coming.
"Amy, you are not a bad person. You are a very good person who had to make a very difficult decision at a very young age. You made a mistake with Billy and had to make that decision. It wasn't your fault. Just think of how different your life would be if you had kept it," the Doctor said.
"I probably wouldn't have Rory, I wouldn't be here with my best friend, and River and Melody would have never had existed. "