This story happens after the events of thronecoming and Spring Unsprung so there is spoilers
and I don't own any of the characters of Ever After High
Chapter 1
Allistair POV
At the Rebels table, "I'm so excited about PROM" says Cedar Wood. All the girls at the Rebel table start squeeling." What about you Allistair" asks Madeline Hatter looking at me with her big turquoise eyes. "Yeah me to" I say. But I'm actually not cause I don't know who to ask to the prom Maddie or Bunny I like both of tem a lot and I'm scared if I ask one of them out the other one relationship with me will be ruined. "Allistair, ALLISTAIR" shouts Madeline Hatter. "Huh, yeah". "You sort of spaced out, what are you thinking about" says Lizzie Hearts. "Oh nothing, I have to get to class". I lefted the Castletria. " That was weird" says Madeline Hatter.
In Chemistry, "Hey Allistair" says Bunny Blanc smiling. Her smile makes me want to smile. "Hey Bunny" I say. "Why did you leave the Castletria so awkwardly". Think of a lie quickly. "I had to do something". "Like what". "I had to ...". "It doesn't matter anymore" says Bunny Blanc cutting me off. "So about prom who ar ...". "Um, I need to go" running out of Chemistry and going into Wonderland Grove.
"That was a close one" I say catching my breath. I see a grin appear and I know who it is. "Hey Kitty" I say. "Hey Allistair what brings you here" says Kitty. "I need help". "Well I'm kind of in the middle of my cat nap but I can spare a minute or 2". "Okay so there two girls and you don't know which one to chose , how would you know which is the right girl for you". "Is this about Madeline and Bunny". "How do you know" I ask. "I know a lot of things, like you running out of Chemistry and leaving Bunny there confused". That move was so dumb of me. "First what do you like about Maddie". "She makes you feel special and knows how to cheer you up when your feeling down and has a huge heart for anyone". "And Bunny". "Her smile makes me feel warm in side and when she with you it just makes me happy".
Flash Back
In Wonderland, night time next to the pond
"Hey Alli" says Madeline Hatter
"Hey Maddie" I say. "What are you doing here at this time"
"I can ask you the same think" she says with a giggle
"Just think" I say
"About what" she asks
"Stuff" I respond
"Hey Alli, you know you can tell me anything I always be there for you" she says holding my hand and smiling
That's how I fell in love with her
End of Flash Back
"Well my opinion is that you like both of them equally" Kitty says. "Now you need to decide which one you want to be with" says Kitty disappearing again. Leaving me in Wonderland Grove alone. Its going to be one tough decision.
Thank you for reading first fanficition.
Who do u think he'll choose Madeline or Bunny