"Take off your boxers, I can't reach." she insisted. I winced and pressed my lips together. I tried to speak but the words stayed lodged in my throat. Her grey eyes burned holes in me as I did nothing.
"C'mon," she sighed, "I'm your girlfriend. Don't you trust me?" I did trust her. I trusted her with all my life. I trusted her enough to tell her my Achilles' heel. I also trusted her enough to fall into Tartarus with her. I nodded my head vigorously and forced the words to come out of my mouth.
"Of course I trust you," I promised, "It's just that…" Trailing off, my cheeks flushed red. I could feel them burning as she narrowed her eyes and stood up.
"What? I mean," she exhaled lightly out of her mouth, "If you really don't want me to I won't. I thought that you would be okay with this."
"It's not that," I hesitated, "It's just that I wanted the first time for you to see me naked to be something more, uh, special than trying to get a tick out of my leg."
I shifted uncomfortably and pressed my back against the wall of the handicapped stall. I began to regret agreeing to the hike. When Jason and Piper invited us on a short hike through a preserve near their new apartment, I didn't think anything could go wrong. Monster attacks had been less frequent and I hadn't seen Jason and Piper in weeks. But after we finished the trail and were checking for ticks, which we were warned had been showing up more recently, I felt the sharp prick on my upper, upper thigh, right next to my… you know. When Annabeth spoke, it surprised me so much I almost jumped. What she was saying surprised me even more.
"Let's just do it here, then." she stated blatantly. I stared at her and tried to put the pieces together as best I could.
"Like," I croaked, "Like sex?" My voice had dropped to a whisper. She nodded and looked at me like a child who was having trouble understanding an assignment.
"Yes. Right here. Right now. Sex." I took a deep breath and thought back to the times we'd fooled around together. We had only gone to second base. We didn't want to move too fast. After the war with Gaea was over, we took things even slower, as if we had recently met and were a couple for the first time.
"In the stall?" I squeaked stupidly. Of course in the stall, Percy. Dumb, dumb, dumb. What did I expect? A secret room that appeared when the toilet was flushed, filled with lit candles and a heart – shaped bed? Gods, focus, Percy.
"How much more obvious can I make this?" she groaned, "Take off your boxers. Or do you want me to do it for you?"
"Um, are you sure, Annabeth? Because this is a really big step and I don't want to take things too fast and I - " She shut me up by lightly pressing her lips to mine.
"We don't need to do this right now if you're too nervous." she explained, "We can wait if you want."
"I'm not nervous." I pointed out even though I was. What if I messed something up? What if it got awkward afterwards? Annabeth could obviously see right through me and she knotted her fingers gently in my hair. "I just thought our first time would be in a bed." I murmured shamefully.
"Well, we aren't the average couple, now are we?" Annabeth retaliated.
"No, we're not." I agreed.
"We make do. So…" Annabeth's breath smelled like vanilla and the warm puff of it made my groin twitch, "Are we doing this or not? Jason and Piper are waiting. We have to make this fast."
"Then let's go." I grinned and felt a sudden rush of adrenaline as Annabeth tugged my boxers down. I closed my eyes and tried to be patient as she dragged them down to my ankles at an excruciatingly slow pace. I didn't even see her pull out the tweezers until I felt a sharp pinch where I was bitten by the blasted tick.
"Got it." Annabeth announced, pride and lust in her eyes, "Now where were we?"
The tweezers fell to the tiled floor with a soft ting. Annabeth caught my lips in a rough kiss; her tongue brushed over my lower lip and along the roof of my mouth. I could feel her breasts pressed against me and I tugged on the hem of her shirt, silently asking for permission to take it off. Annabeth lifted her arms up and I pulled the shirt over her head. I draped it over the stall doors and grazed my fingers over her toned stomach. I felt her grinding into me and the wonderful friction made my head spin.
Gods, she was so perfect. She yanked my shirt over my head and joined it with hers, which was now on the verge of falling off the barrier. She took her ratty sports bra off and dropped it to the floor. I placed both of my hands on each breast and massaged gently. I saw her jaw clench and her throat restrict as she bit back a moan. Sweat gleamed on her forehead from the hike. I felt her hands work the buttons on her jeans against my stomach and I gripped her hips.
After several seconds, her jeans and underwear were on the floor and kicked under a different stall. My dick throbbed and tried to control myself as my naked, oh gods so naked, girlfriend stood in front of me.
"Are you ready, Jackson?" she purred.
The thought had just occurred to me and I cursed myself for being so reckless, "Do you have a condom, Annabeth?"
"I'm always prepared." she stated, "And say my name again."
"Annabeth." I hissed and paused before saying, "Of course you carry a condom around, I mean, who doesn't nowadays?"
"You, Seaweed Brain." she countered.
"Touché."
Annabeth turned so her back was on the stall. I closed my eyes as she rolled the condom on. I grabbed her butt and hoisted her up so we were level. Her legs wrapped around my waist and I held her up by her ass; she threaded her fingers in my hair. I positioned myself and slowly fit my length into her, wanting to make the experience as painless as possible. She didn't complain. We eventually got a rhythm going and I bit back moans. She was so tight that I was afraid I'd lose it as soon as I entered her.
"Go faster." she told me and I picked up my pace. The stall door rocked slightly back and forth. Bang bang bang. I opened an eye to see her swollen lips and forehead still gleaming with sweat, but not from the hike. I kissed her again, wondering what she was thinking. I squeezed her ass and she moaned loudly. I can't last any longer, I can't I can't I can't.
"Oh shit." I muttered and she let out a whimper. That made me lose it. I felt her nails dig into my hair as she felt it too, the shared orgasm rippled through our bodies, threatening to make us both scream and give away our secret sex session. When I regained my senses after several seconds I dropped Annabeth and her feet hit the floor with a light slap. She leaned against the stall and took a shaky breath. Her hands covered her eyes and she sighed blissfully.
I thought she was going to say something like, Wow! You're so great at sex! or, That has to be bigger than average! But, no.
"I can't believe we just did it for the first time in a bathroom stall." Annabeth groaned.
I guess some things never change.
"So," I pressed for answers, "How was it?"
"Fantastic but we have to move. Piper and Jason are waiting." she ripped my dignity out of my chest.
I peeled the condom off and flushed in into the toilet with a defeated look. Annabeth rushed to pull her jeans on and snatched up her bra from the floor. She saw my disappointed face and stopped. Heaving a sigh, she took my face in her hands and looked me dead in the eye.
"Percy," she whispered, "I love you and you're beyond fantastic at sex and you almost tore me in half with that thing."
"Alright, alright," I caved, "I'll take it."
We both rushed to get dressed, swearing and tripping over each other in the confined space. Bursting through the door, we smoothed our hair as best we could and walked out of the bathroom. Jason and Piper were nowhere to be seen.
"What the - " Annabeth's grey eyes scoured the area, "Where did they go?"
"Maybe we took too long and they left." I guessed.
"No," Annabeth sighed and looked at her phone, "We were gone for less than five minutes. What if something bad happened?"
"I think we would sense it." I stated before Jason and Piper burst through the door to the other unisex bathroom.
"Hey guys!" Piper chirped; her braid looked distraught as if it had been done hastily, "Sorry, we just had to use the restroom real quick before the drive back. Right, Jason?"
She kicked him in the shin and he flushed red, "Uh yeah." he croaked before clearing his throat, "Yeah, let's head back. It's getting dark."
Piper began walking towards the car, pulling Jason roughly behind her. Annabeth and I followed. During the drive, I wondered if I should tell Jason that his shirt was on inside out.
A/N: Yeah, sorry that they kind of turn into animals with the hissing and purring but whatever I don't give a shit anymore. I will write the Jason/Piper part soon. I am now taking smut and fluff suggestions! Either PM me, or review.
