Sam and Murdock had known each other when they were younger. Knowing each other was an understatement. Foggy, Murdock and Sam were the closest friends there ever were. They all wanted to go into the same thing and had big plans of opening their own firm.

They would drink and hit on the same woman. The day Dean stepped back into Sam's life; he was sucked out of their lives. Sam was researching of where to go next and was excited when he saw something demonic like happening in hell's Kitchen. He told Dean and he agreed to go there with him.

He just didn't know that Sam had other plans as well. Once they had tracked down the demon and killed it Sam went out to find Foggy and Murdock. It was rather easy because they were well known lawyers. Not because they were amazing though they were, it was because they would take on unwanted clients. Sam walked in and Foggy's face lit up. "Sam… what?! Get over here!" Foggy said as he practically ran over to hug Sam.

"Hey buddy, It's been a while" Sam said as he gave a strong hug back to Foggy. "Murdock is out, but I know he will want to see you, so do you want to wait or get a drink and head to his house?" Sam smiled "Well I need a drink, so… uh?" Sam paused when he saw a blond woman sitting awkwardly watching. "Oh this is Karen Page, She works with us." Foggy said gesturing for her to get up.

Sam shook her hand "So I guess she is replacing me then huh?" He said jokingly. Foggy laughed and Karen smiled "Yes I guess I am. They talk about you a lot, so don't worry I think they could make room for you." Sam smiled "Well you, Karen are more than welcome to go out with us." Karen shook her head "No I'm gonna stay here.

You guys have fun. I hope to see you later Sam." Foggy grabbed his jacket and headed out with Sam. The grabbed a couple shots and started talking about what was going on. Foggy and Murdock were one of the first people Sam ever told what his dad did. They believed him without proof which was awesome. Sam had told them before he left he was going to be doing the same thing as his father had and they wished him the best of luck.

After Foggy's 4th shot and Sam's 2nd they headed out to Murdock's house. Foggy was too drunk to stay awake so he passed out on Murdock's couch. Murdock was more than surprised to have a visit from Sam, but was pleased. When the two hugged it brought up all the old feelings Sam had for the man.

They ended up talking and catching up. Murdock confessed to him that he was a vigilante which turned Sam on. At the same time he was also impressed. He asked all sorts of questions about his eyesight and other senses. After Daredevil as he was called explained as much as he could Sam told him about his hunting. At the end of that conversation the two talked about how things were years ago.

That was when Sam explained the crush he had on him. Murdock started laughing "What?" Sam said with a smile of his own. Murdock shook his head and caught his breath "I had a crush on you too." Sam looked at Murdock and this time he didn't stop himself from kissing him.