This story is inspired by a review I got on This Can't Be Happening. A wonderful reviewer TooLazyToLogin (whose reviews I love to read) mentioned that there were not as many good Santana genderswaps out there and almost none were Santana got Brittany pregnant young. I of course I agree and noticed that this is even the case in my own work though I do have at least two Santana genderswaps one of them I'm not so fond of and plan to rewrite later, but back to my point that they're just not at lot of Santana knocking up Brittany young or on accident so I thought hey I'll write one. So here it is my new story a Santana genderswap where he knocks up Brittany in high school. Thanks for the idea TooLazyToLogin hope you and everyone else enjoys.
Oh and as I only have this first part written and typed up it will be at least two weeks before anymore is up unless I start writing like a mad woman this weekend. All mistakes are mine as I'm too lazy to get a beta.
Surprise!
Santiago paced in front of the bathroom door. He had heard from Mike who heard from Finn who heard from Quinn that Brittany was crying in the second floor girl's bathroom. He so wanted to go in and wrap his arms around her and make whatever is causing her so much pain go away. But on the other hand what if it was something he had done and he caused her to cry more. God Santiago grow a pair and go comfort your girl he thought.
"Babe?" Santiago tentatively says as he opens the door.
All he heard was sobbing so he rushes in to find his girlfriend curled up in a ball crying a positive pregnancy test sitting next to her. He doesn't know what to do so he does the only thing he can think of which is to gather her up in his arms and hold her.
"I'm…soo…sorry." Brittany sobs hiccupping a bit.
"Shh baby we'll get through this." Santiago whispers kissing the top of her head.
"But how?" Brittany sobs clinging tightly to him. "Your graduating this year and have a full ride to Ohio State. I won't let you give that up for me." she says finally managing to stop crying.
"I'd give up anything for you baby." Santiago whispers. "Whatever you decide to do I'll be behind you one hundred percent even if that means staying here for two more years until you graduate." he softly whispers rubbing her back.
Santiago and Brittany had grown up next door to each other and even though Santiago was two years older than her they were best friends. No one ever made fun of Brittany's childlike behavior as they grew up because Santiago despite being several inches shorter than Brittany would beat them up or get beat up trying. Everyone could tell that the normally stoic, standoffish Latino had a major crush on the younger bubbly, overly friendly blonde. Though it wasn't until his junior year and her freshman year that he acted on those feelings.
Up until that point he had been shorter than her, but between sophomore and junior year he shot up a foot and some, gained muscle and joined the football team that he felt confident enough to ask her out. She too had changed that summer, her hips became more promenade along with some curves she hadn't had before. She suddenly had boobs and she was no longer a gangly teen, but a beautiful woman in his eyes. And he wasn't the only one to notice. Almost every guy at the school wanted in her pants. Thankfully for him she only had eyes for him and enjoyed always being around him. So when he asked her out one day during lunch, she screamed yes and hugged him tightly.
"San you can't do that neither one of us would be happy if you did." Brittany whispered.
"I don't want to leave you here though with a baby if you keep it." Santiago whispers not wanting to upset her.
"San I could never get rid of our baby." Brittany gasps placing a hand over her belly.
"Shh…how about we go to the park?" Santiago suggests not wanting to have this conversation here.
"Can we feed the ducks?" Brittany asks pouting.
"Anything you want baby." Santiago says picking her up.
As he carries her out to his truck a million thoughts run through his head. He's too young to become a father, she's even younger. He's going to have to give up his scholarship to Ohio State to stay and help Brittany. He's going to become a Lima loser just like his dad and end up leaving too. Shaking his head he sighs as he hugs Brittany tighter to him, he won't be like his dad and leave when his family needs him.
"I'm sorry San," Brittany softly says bringing Santiago out of his thoughts.
"Do not apologize for this baby it's both of our faults. I'm also at fault for this too." Santiago whispers kissing her head.
"I love you so much." she whispers snuggling into him.
Santiago carefully places her in the passenger seat before making his way to the driver seat. She leans into the door staring out the window trying to figure out where everything went wrong. They were so careful and yet here they are pregnant. He was thinking the exact same thing.
"I love you B," Santiago says taking her hand.
Brittany gives him a funny look.
"I just realized that I had never said I love you after you did earlier like we always do." Santiago tells her smiling.
"Ever with all this you still have the ability to make me smile." Brittany softly says as they get out of the truck.
"I just want you to be happy." Santiago says shrugging putting his arm around her shoulders.
"I'm happy when I'm with you." Brittany whispers placing a kiss on his jaw.
"Well that's good cause you're stuck with me." Santiago whispers into her hair.
When they reach the small pond in the back of the pond Santiago plops down on the bank pulling Brittany into his lap handing her a loaf of bread. Brittany squeals smiling up at him kissing all over his face.
"You're the best boyfriend ever." she happily says opening the bag and starting to throw some bread in the pond for the ducks.
"Not to make you upset or anything, but what are we going to do?" Santiago asks the younger girl.
"I don't know," she whispers leaning back again.
"We have time to decide baby." he whispers.
She nods before going back to feeding the ducks. This reminds him of the first time they meet, the day he finally got up the nerve to ask her out and the first time they had sex. And now this. Come to think of it he realized ducks played a big role in the important moments of his life thus far.
Flashback
Five year old Santiago walks proudly down the sidewalk by himself for the first time. He was coming back from his friend Puck's house which was only a block away from his house. He's all smiles as he walks by the park in between their houses it's his favorite place to go. Normally he would stop, but he couldn't or his mom would ground him. Glancing longingly to the pond crying. Against his better judgment he walked over to her.
"Hello," he softly says sitting next to her.
"No strange." the little girl says.
"I'm Santiago, now we not stranger." Santiago says smiling over at her.
"Lost," the little girl mumbles.
"What your name?" Santiago asks.
"Brittany," she says tears starting to fall again.
"We go my house and ask mami." Santiago suggests feeling bad that this little girl Brittany is crying.
"I want mommy." Brittany sobs clinging to Santiago's arm.
"I help find your mommy." Santiago says helping her up, but keeping an arm around her.
"Thaks," Brittany says snuggling into him.
"How old you?" Santiago asks frowning as he realizes that she's got to be younger than him even though she's slightly taller than him.
"Three," Brittany happily says smiling as she holds up three fingers.
"Oh, I five." Santiago says puffing out his little chest.
"Cool, friend?" Brittany mumbles.
"Yeah-"
"Brittany, thank god." a blonde tall woman says running over to the two young kids picking up Brittany. "Thank god honey you're okay."
"Santiago," a short Latina woman says coming out her hands on her hips.
"Sorry, I help Brittany back." Santiago says looking at the ground.
"Thank you Santiago for bringing her home. She's always wandering off." the blonde tall woman says.
"Hello I'm Maria, Santiago's mom and I'm glad that he could help." Maria says holding out her hand to her new neighbor.
"Susan Pierce and my husband's Riley. It's nice to meet you." Susan says.
"Play San?" Brittany asks trying to wiggle out of her mom's arms.
"Um…."
"I'll make sure no get lost." Santiago says wanting to play with his new friend.
Both women smile at how cute Santiago is looking at Brittany like she's the best thing ever.
"Okay,"
Twelve Years Later
Santiago nervously paces in front of his car waiting for Brittany to arrive. This is her first year going to McKinley and he doesn't plan on letting anyone hurt her. He's a junior and it's his job to protect her. Especially since over the summer she's blossomed from a gangly teen to a woman. He's noticed quite a few guys staring at her.
"Hey San," Brittany says skipping over and kissing him on the cheek.
"Hey Britt ready for school?" Santiago asks as they get in the car.
"I am now that I have the new star quarterback to show me around." Brittany sweetly says taking his hand and playing with his fingers.
Brittany isn't the only one that's changed over the summer. She too had noticed how her best friend had grown to now be six eight instead of a few inches shorter than her. He went from a gangly, slightly goofy looking teen to an extremely handsome, muscular man. She had never really thought about him romantically before, but now she's been getting jealous at all the Cheerios that talk about how handsome he is. Though she knows she doesn't stand a chance with him.
"Well I have to make sure my best friend is well taken care of." Santiago says as they pull into the parking lot.
"So I was hoping that you might join glee club with me." Brittany says hopefully.
"Britt they're a bunch of losers I can't." Santiago whines not wanting his new football friends to make fun of him.
"But I don't want to go alone and Puck's in it. Please." Brittany pouts clinging to his arm.
Santiago really doesn't want to, but knows he'll do anything for the girl next to him.
"Fine, but only cause you're cute." Santiago says.
"Yay, I'll inform Quinn we're going to join." Brittany happily says snuggling into Santiago's body.
All he can do is smile as she wraps his arm around her and she tries to fuse with his body.
"I didn't think Quinn would want to join something like glee." Santiago says knowing Brittany's best friend is all about image.
"Apparently two guys she likes are in it." Brittany says shrugging as she looks up from her phone.
"Oh well if anyone asks I was blackmailed into this." Santiago grumbles not wanting to get slushied again.
"You know you're not as much of a bad ass as you want people to-"
"Hush we don't need that getting out." Santiago whispers covering her mouth with his hand.
Brittany giggles and continues to his lead into the school. Once inside she notices a lot of her fellow Cheerios glaring at her. In fact most of the girls that they pass are glaring at her, she's all smiles snuggling impossibly close to him. She had been terrified about coming here after hearing about all the awful things that had happened to her best friend for being small and a nerd, but now with him being the big man on campus to protect her she feels a lot better.
"So you have math Ms. Eaton first, she's really easy on Cheerios." Santiago says gulping as he notices her Cheerio top riding up a bit giving him a view of her abs.
He now realizes that before this moment he had never appreciated the perfection that is her body. He's literally holding the perfect woman in his arms.
"Thanks for everything San I know you'll want to go hangout with some of your friends so I'll just go into class and wait." Brittany softly says pulling away from him.
"I'll see you at lunch." Santiago says not wanting to leave her.
"Okay,"
Santiago watches her go into her classroom before heading out for the football field to find Puck.
"Hey man how it go with freshman blondie?" Puck asks wiggling his eyebrows.
"Fuck Puck I couldn't do it. She was all snuggled into me and I wanted to, but what if she says no and doesn't want to be friends anymore. I'd die if I couldn't hug her." Santiago whines collapsing next to Puck.
"Are you crazy man?" Puck asks staring at his friends. "That girl thinks you're the best thing in the world. She doesn't give any other guys the time of day that girl only has eyes for you."
"Really?" Santiago asks a huge smile on his face.
"Dude you're dumb. She would totally fuck you-"
"Don't fucking talk about her like that." Santiago growls throwing him up against the wall.
Kids stopped and stared at the footballers as they walked past the stadium to get to the school.
"Sorry," Puck whimpers when Santiago lets him go.
Santiago doesn't say anything he just heads off to class. It pisses him off that other guys were already thinking of his Brittany in a sexual way. So what if he was too he wasn't going to presser her to have sex with him like other guys would.
Three hours later and three classes later Santiago waits outside Brittany's health class for her to come out. She walks out with Quinn and his breath catches at just how beautiful she is.
"Hey Britt," Santiago says in his deep voice.
"San," Brittany gasps running into his arms to give him a hug. "I thought I was going to meet you at the cafeteria."
"Hey Santiago," Quinn says shaking her head.
"Quinn," Santiago says nodding. "I thought we could go off campus."
"Lucky bitch," Quinn jokingly grumbles.
"Um…..I'm not sure San," Brittany hesitantly says.
"Please,"
"Fine,"
Seven minutes later Santiago is taking out a picnic basket he had convinced a freshman to get for him and is leading Brittany to her favorite duck pond.
"Sanny," Brittany gasps.
"You deserve the best." Santana says taking a deep breath.
He's going to ask her now before any of the guys who keep staring at her try to ask her out. The only problem is he's terrified that she'll say no, but Puck making that comment made him realize that he needs to do this.
"San, you didn't have to do all this." Brittany softly says leaning back into him.
"Bemygirlfriend?" Santiago quickly asks.
"What?" Brittany says turning around to face him.
"Be my girlfriend?"
Brittany doesn't answer instead she launches herself into his kissing him deeply. In the background a duck quacks stealing their sandwiches as they make out.
Seven Months Later
"Baby where are we going?" Santiago asks following Brittany out of his house.
"I want to go to the pond." Brittany whines.
"Babe it's eleven I was supposed to bring you home an hour ago." Santiago says gathering a blanket she had thrown at him.
"Sanny," Brittany says turning around and wrapping her arms around his neck. "My dad doesn't care what time you bring me home. He trusts you. You do know that he told me trusts you to do the right thing way more than me."
"I don't-"
Brittany cuts him off with a kiss. She's ready for him to have all of her, but with both their parents always home it seems to her so she's taking this into her own hands.
"I want to give myself to you." Brittany softly says.
"You…what!?" Santiago gasps stopping halfway to the park.
"I'm ready for you to take me completely San. I don't want anyone else ever. We both know that when I graduate I'll go wherever you are and we'll start our life together." Brittany reasons really wanting this.
"Britt,"
"Sanny,"
"I don't want to hurt you." Santiago whispers as Brittany lays down the blanket down on the far side of the pool.
"I want you to be my first and only." Brittany whispers.
Santiago gulps knowing that he'll give in to what she wants even though he's reluctant to take away something so precious.
"You have to promise to tell me if anything hurts." Santiago whispers as she lays the blanket down.
"Okay," Brittany softly says wrapping her arms around his neck and kissing him.
Santiago pulls away slightly looking into Brittany's eyes looking for any signs of doubt. When he doesn't see any he slowly lowers her down onto the blanket his hands shaking as he gently grabs the hem of her shirt. It terrifies him that he's not only about to take her virginity, but he's going to lose his too. What if he's no good and she doesn't want him anymore.
"Sanny, stop thinking so much." Brittany softly says grabbing his hands and pushing them under her shirt up to her boobs.
Santiago gasps when he feels the soft flesh under his hands so he gently squeezes them causing her to moan.
"Take off my shirt." she orders.
He nods and lifts it off exposing her top half completely. He can't help, but stare at her wonderful boobs. Licking his lips he allows her remove his shirt before diving in and sucking on her right nipple. He's been imagining what it would be like to kiss her perky boobs for months.
"Remove our pants." she orders knowing that her boyfriend is more lost than she is.
It takes him several minutes for him to finally get his pants off and then it takes even longer to get her pants off as his hands are shaking so much.
"San, you're going to have to get me ready for you." she tells him knowing that he doesn't know what he's doing.
"Okay,"
His hands are still shaking as he slowly pulls her underwear off of her long legs. When he finally sees her smooth mound he pauses trying to gain enough confidence to actually do something.
Sensing his hesitation she grabs his wrist and moves his hand to her mound. She urges him to slowly put one finger into her moaning as he does. Gaining confidence from hearing her moans he slowly thrusts in and out of her a few times before trying to add another finger while flicking her clit.
"I think I'm wet enough now." she whispers cupping his cheeks and guiding his mouth to hers.
They kiss deeply for several minutes, her swallowing his moans as she strokes his shaft. He's never felt anything so good as her hand on his dick and he can't even imagine what it will feel like when he feels her around him.
"Baby, I need to be in you or I'm going to blow." Santiago whispers grabbing for his pants so he can get the condom out of his wallet.
"San, I'm on the pill." Brittany whispers.
He takes a deep breath before sitting up a bit to line himself up. She knows that he's scared to hurt her so she pulls him down gasping as she feels his tip starting to push into her.
"Baby," he moans as he pushing into her.
"Don't move." she orders causing him to stop and allow her to get use to him. "You're so big baby."
It takes another minute before he's finally bottoming out in her.
"God you feel amazing squeezing me so tightly." he moans lifting himself up on his forearms to look at her.
"Make love to me." she says wrapping her arms around his neck and bucks her hips up into him.
At first everything they do is awkward. He doesn't know what to do really and is thrusting at a sporadic pace. She has her limbs wrapped around him as she thrusts up into him also at a sporadic pace. Neither of them really know what to do to make the other feel as good as they feel.
"Baby I'm going to blow." he moans starting to get the hang of thrusting at an even pace.
"Oh baby right there." she moans tightening her muscles around him causing him to blow his load into her.
"SHIT!"
He pulls out of her and watches as his cum pours out of her.
"San I need you…" she trails off in desperation.
At first he doesn't get it, but then it clicks that she didn't cum so he decides that he would like to taste her. He kisses his way down her body before he reaches her mound and pauses slightly before diving in.
"OH BABY!"
It doesn't take long for her to lose it.
"Wow babe," Santiago whispers climbing back up her body and kissing her.
"That was amazing." Brittany moans curling into him.
"How do you feel?" Santiago asks slightly worried that she's going to regretted this.
"Weird, but a good weird like my body is all tingly." Brittany whispers burying herself into his body.
"I love you and that you trust me enough to be your first." Santiago whispers kissing the top of her head.
"I wouldn't have it any other way."
She falls asleep on him and he carefully gets up not moving her. He gets himself dressed before wrapping her in the blanket and lifts her up in his arms walking back towards his house completely missing the duck that is waddling over to where they had been.
End Flashback
"San my dad just texted and I have to go home and watch Katie." Brittany says bringing him out of his thoughts.
"Do you want me to come over?" Santiago asks.
"Yeah,"
Santiago helps her up and they walk over to his truck both equally terrified about the future now and yet sure that they would be together no matter what.
"Britt don't worry we'll figure this out together like we always do." Santiago whispers taking her hand in his as he drives the block to their houses.
"I can't help, but worry San." Brittany snaps before her face softens. "I don't want you to give up everything that you've worked so hard for, for me." she softly says.
Before Santiago can say anything the door opens and Katie comes tarring out.
"Britty, Sanny!" Katie shouts trying to open the truck door.
"Hey munchkin," Santiago says getting out and scooping her into his arms.
Watching her boyfriend swing her little sister around all she can think about is how great of a father he'll make. She honestly can't think of anyone who she'd rather have a child with then him.
"Are you helping Britty watch Katie?" Riley asks always feeling better when Santiago's with his elder daughter to protect and help her.
"Yes sir, if that's okay with you." Santiago says always the gentleman.
"Of course it's fine I know we both feel better when you're with Brittany." Susan says waving bye.
Santiago smiles at them feeling slightly bad that they both trust him so much and yet he's been defiling their oldest daughter for months and then on top of that he's now knocked her up.
"Can we watch the Little Mermaid?" Katie asks pouting.
"Yeah San can we." Brittany adds.
"Fine, but only because you're both cute." Santiago sighs thinking this is going to be a long Disney film night.
After getting popcorn and pizza ready while Brittany got Katie in her pj's Santiago sat in the middle of the couch with the girls snuggled on either side of him. He thought it was cute that Katie had a crush on him while Brittany just found it annoying. She didn't like when her boyfriend got dragged into playing princess and made them late for a date. Also it was hard for her to get alone time with him at her house period.
Luckily Katie was exhausted and ten minutes in she was out.
"I'll put her to bed." Santiago offers standing up with her in his arms.
"Hurry back," Brittany whispers watching him carry her little sister upstairs.
Watching him with her sister she knows that their child is going to be the most spoiled thing ever. Seeing her boyfriend like this makes her think that maybe they can make this work. She's not willing to let him give up his scholarship she'll go with him if she needs to. She can finish high school up nearby and live with him. Yeah that's a good plan she'll have to tell him this later.
"Well she's down for the night." Santiago says sitting back down and allowing Brittany to snuggle back into him.
"Good I like having alone time with you." Brittany says burying herself into his side.
"Can we put on Game of Thrones?" Santiago asks knowing his girlfriend will be out in under thirty minutes.
"I guess,"
Santiago changes the channel quickly before she can change her mind and starts at season one episode five were he left off. He just got into this show, but Brittany hates it so it's hard for him to find time to try and catch up. What he doesn't know is that even though she hates how violent it is she really loves to watch him watch it as very few things aside from her and football get him excited plus they have great sex after each episode as he tries to make up for forcing her to watch something so violent.
"Sanny I love you." Brittany yawns burying her head in the crook of his neck.
He knew she was asleep now so he held her tightly to him.
"I'm so scared baby." he whispers. "I can't lose you. No matter what you decide I will always be here for you. You're my world and I go where you go no matter what."
