Title: Simply Fit

Author: Lillitgirlx2

Chapter: 1- Decisions

Rating: T for now I think

Disclaimer: Don't own. Don't sue.

A/N: Okay this is an idea I came up with watching Season 2. Part of the beginning is from Richard in Stars Hollow but there is a big twist on this. It is going to be a bit OCC but I hope you'll like it. Also, for those of you waiting for The Tragedy That Brought Us Together, I just can't get a good next chapter. It will be up, just don't know when. Anyway, read and review.

"Hey Rory, coffee?" Luke asked as Paris and I entered the diner. We, well she, was on a mission to find something bad about the town and where else to find something bad than in the diner. The only thing bad about it was the bad boy New Yorker living upstairs. He made me fall for him, slowly but I still did and still am. See, he has this just I don't know, vibe about him that just makes me want to kiss him and be with him, but I have a boyfriend. Who I should be thinking about but can't I just, Jess is so much more of what I want I mean yeah, Dean is nice and a good boyfriend but maybe just a good first boyfriend. I can't be with him forever and I need to see what else is out there like Jess for example. Well exactly like Jess.

"Thanks Luke," I told him as he poured me a cup of oxygen as my mother and I call it. "Who's your friend?" Referring to Paris I replied saying her name was Angela Landsbury. Well, she was trying to fit in so… I was just doing my part. He believed me and started to say 'hello' to her and if she wanted anything.

"You get a lot of truckers through here?" What? Is she on crack? She's not going to find anything here.

"Truckers?"

"Yeah. You know, guys on the road for weeks, lonely, looking for company, a little pick me up. Things like that." Paris said this like it could actually be true!

"What is she talking about?" Luke asked me. "Your guess is as good as mine." I tried not to talk a lot because I kept looking at the curtain that led to the stairs of the apartment. I wanted him to come down just to see him once. Possibly maybe to go upstairs to talk to him.

"It's pretty common knowledge that diners are breeding grounds for prostitution and drug dealers."

"What?"

She started going on about Reverend Nichols and how it could be a code name for Dr. Feelgood but I wasn't truly listening. I was off in my own world again. Thinking about him.

Well, well, well, speak of the devil and the devil shall appear.

"Hey, where'd he come from? What's up there? Is that where you keep the girls? You got yourself a little cathouse up there?"

"Wow, I think she got you Uncle Luke. You better give up now." Jess just had to pipe up with his sarcasm.

"Do not add to this insanity!" Luke exclaimed.

"An innocent boy like me should not be raised in an atmosphere like this," He replied.

"Jess!" Luke was going to blow!

"Look, Paris," I decided to come in now because if I didn't it was going to be ugly soon, "Luke and Jess live upstairs in the apartment. You are not going to find anything bad in this town. It's like sparkly clean so give up now!" Ugggh! She can sometimes be so weird it drives me crazy.

"Fine!" And with that she stomped out. Thank god!

"Wow, talk about going mentally crazy." Jess joked. Luke had already walked to the storeroom to cool down and figure out why this day in age people are so damn crazy.

"Yeah I know and I go to school with her."

"Ouch I feel bad for you."

"Yeah me too. Haha." I laughed as I thought about life without Paris. It looked quite nice.

"So, I found a book you were looking for from the bookstore I have it upstairs if you want it," he told me with his perfect smirk in place. We had been playing this game for a couple days ever since it happened.

I nodded and followed him upstairs. I don't think Luke ever gave it a second thought since I had a boyfriend and he thought that I would actually be good for Jess. When he got to the room I quickly followed him in only to have him turn around and close the door pushing me lightly against it.

"You know Gilmore, you could say this is a bit of a 'cathouse' seeing as we are up here, all alone," His voice was husky as he dragged out the last two words.

"Yes, but no one thinks anything about it. Even though it would be nice to be together I need to get my mom to like you and to find the right moment to break up with-" I didn't get to say his name since I was cut off by Jess's lips. You see, he first kissed me a couple days ago in the bookstore. No one but Andrew was there and we were in the back so he couldn't hear us. We had both told each other how we felt but I told him I needed time to break up with Dean. Even though I didn't have feelings for him anymore I couldn't just up an break up with him. So he said that he wouldn't want me cheating on Dean so long, but I believe he just wanted me for himself, so he told me a week and a half. I thought that was fair seeing as how this is the fourth day.

I felt him lick my bottom lip for entrance and press me further into the door. I opened up gladly and fought with his tongue. I had already taken off my school jacket downstairs so there was just my blouse. His hands that were at my waist slowly went up and down my sides producing a moan from me. My hands kept going from around his neck to his brown hair and then back down to play with the little hairs on his neck that never had any gel. With that he would groan and smile because I was the only one who knew that he loved that. I had to pull back for air but he never stopped. His lips trailed down and up my neck then up my jaw line. He pulled away panting much similar to me and rested his head on my shoulder. He both stood there trying to catch our breath before talking. Although this was a silent moment it was uncomfortable, I mean I am cheating on my boyfriend. That statement I had never liked but right now I didn't care. Dean was out of control and I couldn't handle it. I needed freedom from him and I needed Jess.

"You know Ror, one of these days I'm not going to remember that we are a secret and kiss you right in front of everyone at the diner. I almost did today, good thing Paris was there to redirect me," He confined as he pulled me toward the couch.

"Haha, I know Jess. I just…. I got to find a good time okay? This is my first time breaking up and I don't know, it just… You and I feel right and I know this is right but—" I was cut off again this time by his words.

"Rory, relax I know. You and I do feel right I just wish you could find the right time soon. I'm not going to force you to do this but…" he trailed off but me being smart I knew what he was going to say.

"I know Jess, but we won't be a secret for too long." I helped him out eith words as I cuddled into his side. We were both silent for a while, just thinking about the past, present and future. Then came the time to separate. We had been up here about half an hour and I needed to go home becuase my grandfather was bugging my mom. He got up and went to his bookcase to get a book for me. As I looked at it I was surprised, thankfully it wasn't a Hemmingway book, but Pride and Prejudice. My Pride and Prejudice.

"Hey! You stole me book again Dodger!" I smacked him lightly on the arm with the book. He just laughed and smiled.

"Yeah well, I thought you could use some notes Elizabeth." He had started called me Elizabeth the first time yesterday when we were on the bridge. He has flipped my words around from when he stole my book the first time. I was Elizabeth and he; well he, was my Mr. Darcy.

I just smiled at the name and the gesture. Knowing I would be reading this book tonight. I gave him a simple kiss and was going to leave but he had other plans. He wrapped his arms around my waist and depended the kiss. But before I could even put my arms around his neck he pulled away and pushed me towards the door with a little smack on the ass. I turned around and stuck my tongue out. As I walked down the stairs to the diner I thought about what had happened today and the last few. I thought about that that was the kind of relationship I wanted. Something simple where you knew each other's thoughts and could debate books and just fit together. When I thought of that I knew I had made the right decision. Jess. God, even his name brought a smile to my face.

A/N: Okay, so what do you think? Should I continue? Just letting you know now I will probably only have Updates once a week. School is crazier than ever. Also, if I get enough reviews I will probably be looking for a Beta. I know I am one but I can't correct everything. So if anyone is interested leave it in the review or PM me.

Press the little button and review please!

-A :)