Mistake, A Sonny with a Chance FanFic


By: Froggylover4281


Summary: I thought I changed after I started dating Sonny. I didn't know my ego was still there. It was a mistake, to choose an award over her. Now all I can do is hope I'll get her back...


POV: Chad


"She's got a more... gentle touch... when it comes to breaking up. You'll see. When Sonny breaks up with you, you'll say, 'Wow, that was gentle.'"

"And when she doesn't," I retorted, "you'll say, 'Huh, I was wrong. Sonny digs Chad. 'Cause Chad's awesome, Chad's the best. Everybody loves Chad."


"You felt weird about winning, I felt weird about losing, and now, thanks to me, we don't have to feel weird anymore. But, you do have a very weird look on your face."

"It's called disappointment, Chad. You were so miserable that you weren't the center of attention for one day that you went and ordered a re-count?"

"Whoa, okay. I just wanted things to go back to normal, like I promised."

"Normal? Oh, you mean the normal where you always win and I always lose? I don't like that normal. Boyfriends and girlfriends are supposed to support each other, root for each other. I can't be in a relationship with someone who always puts himself first."

"Whoa, I did this for us, okay?"

"No, Chad. The only us there is now is between you and this award. I hope you two will be very happy together."

"Wait, are you breaking up with me? Because I thought I was helping."

"That's the worst part about it. Goodbye, Chad."

"Sonny, don't do this, this is ridiculous-"

"No, just go.

"Bu- but, I just-"

"Chad, there are no second chances this time. I'm sorry. You won the re-count, but you lost me."


As I stared at the television in my dressing room, watching So Random!, the memories flooded back to me. It was a year after Sonny and I broke up, and I hadn't gotten over it. Sonny and I decided that we'd just stay friends, but sometimes I can't help feeling that if it weren't for me, Sonny and I would still be together. If it weren't for my overly-large ego, maybe we'd still be dating. Maybe if I hadn't screwed up, everything would be perfect again- except for the Randoms STILL not getting over the fact that Sonny and I were going out.

Tawni said that she had a gentle touch, and I would realize that after she broke up with me. But, being the jerk that I was, said that nobody would want to break up with me, because everybody LOVES Chad Dylan Cooper. But I went and messed up our relationship, resulting in Sonny breaking up with me and me sulking in my room for days afterward, feeling as miserable as a person can feel.

I doubt that everybody loves Chad Dylan Cooper now.


"Hi, I'm Sicky Vicky," Sonny announced on the TV. I sighed sadly, remembering the time that Sonny faked she was sick and I had to be substitute-Sonny for the day. I remembered how I had grabbed our cardboard heads and put them next to each other making smooching noises, my attempt to gross the Randoms out. I remembered how I'd found Sonny at the beach, and how I... the memories were too painful.

I turned off the TV and headed over to MacKenzie Falls, since we were going to shoot a new episode that day.


"I can't take this anymore. We need to get back together. Right here, right now. I can't live without you, Sonny."

She raised an eyebrow.

I snapped back to reality.

"Cut!" Chastity yelled. "Did you say Sonny?" She eyed me cautiously.

"What?" I exclaimed. "Of course not. You must be hearing things. I most definitely did NOT say Sonny."

"No," Chastity replied, "I heard the name-"

"Moving on!" I interrupted. "3... 2... 1... Action!

"I can't take this anymore. We need to get back together. Right here, right now. I can't live without you, Chloe."

Chastity shook her head. "I'm sorry, MacKenzie. I can't forgive you for what you did to me. Leave me alone. I never want to see your face again!"

"Chloe!" I shouted, but she ran away... far, far away. "Don't leave me!"

But she did.

Good riddance.

"And... scene!" the director announced. "Lunch break!"

"Yippee," I mutter under my breath, and head over to the cafeteria.