The Night That Started It All
It was a particularly nice night; there were no clouds in the sky. The moon was a beautiful waxing crescent, and the stars were shining brighter than ever.
Gray had had enough of Juvia that day so he was at the bar drinking away his rage.
"Another." Gray said to the bartender. He had already drunk three beers that night, but he continued.
Natsu walked into the bar just as Gray received his drink.
"Uhhg. You're here," Gray complained.
"Right back at ya," Natsu retorted then sat down next to Gray," so is Juvia getting on your nerves again?"
"Do I even need to answer that question?" Gray replied rhetorically. "By the way, why are you here?"
"I was looking for you."
"I thought you absolutely hated me to the core."
"W-well, you see, y-you are usually at the guild so I was worried."
"Not even going to bother to ask about your sketchy behavior."
"Hey, I never got the chance to ask you how you get away with underage drinking."
"My man Brandon hooks me up" Gray pointed to the bartender.
"Should I try?" Natsu asked genuinely interested.
"Do you know how to hold your alcohol?"
"No idea what that means."
"This is going to be interesting." Gray said to himself as Natsu waved down Brandon.
Five beers later...
"Hit me." Natsu ordered the bartender, who looked just a touch annoyed.
"Nope. I think you've had enough." Gray scolded.
"Aw, come on I've only had a couple" Natsu whined.
"You've had five!"
"You know what? You're right! My bunny rabbit needs me!" Natsu yelled as he fell out of his chair.
"Natsu," Gray face palmed, "You don't have a bunny rabbit." He helped Natsu back into his chair.
" Oh yeah, I forgot... Hey! I have to tell you a secret."
"Okay..."
"You can't tell Gray though."
"But I am-" he was cut off by Natsu at that moment.
"I think he's sexy."
"..."
Natsu blinked a few times and squinted.
"Wait a minute..." he said.
"Natsu," Gray put on a serious face, "is that true?"
Natsu sat there looking ashamedly at the ground having just realized whom he was really talking to. With a bashful face he said,
"Maybe..."
Gray jumped out of his seat, grabbed Natsu's arm and dragged him into a nearby alley.
"What are you-" Natsu tries to say until Gray cut him off by kissing him passionately. When they released, they were both blushing profusely.
"Gray." Natsu said breathlessly.
"Shh. Let's go back to my house."
"Okay." The pink-headed Dragon Slayer agreed.
Lucky for them, Gray's apartment was only a block away. Gray carried Natsu bridal style the whole way while making out and trying not to trip. When the arrived, Gray shut the door and slammed Natsu up against it, and he bit Natsu's lip
"Uuuh." Natsu groaned. Gray took the opportunity to slip his tongue into Natsu's mouth. He easily won the battle for dominance and started sucking on the teenagers burning hot tongue.
"Natsu... the bed." Gray said between kisses. He led Natsu to the bed and pushed him down onto the mattress. He lifted Natsu's shirt up and over his head and tossed in the corner. Somehow Gray wasn't wearing his shirt anymore, and Natsu had no idea when that happened.
Gray laid kisses down Natsu's neck and over his chest. He scooted himself down to Natsu's legs and caressed Natsu's hardening cock through the fabric of his pants.
"Ahhh. Gray..."
"Oh Natsu, you have no idea how adorable you are right now."
"Gray, Gray please... my pants."
"That eager, are you?" Gray slid up to Natsu's chest and licked one of his nipples.
"Please... touch me more." Natsu squirmed
Gray caressed Natsu's crotch while circling his nipple with his tongue.
"Is this your first time Natsu?"
"Uh huh"
Gray smirked, lowered himself and tore off Natsu's pants and threw them in the corner with the shirt. He sat back for a second to admire his little Natsu.
"So cute."
"No I'm not!" Natsu sat up a little, but Gray pushed him back down.
"Yes you are."
Natsu was about to protest again, but Gray stuck his hand into Natsu's boxers.
"Nnngg."
"See? Adorable."
Gray took the boxers off and discarded them to the small pile of clothes.
"Damn! Your HUGE Natsu!"
"Shut up."
Gray leaned down and licked all the way up Natsu's length. Natsu's breath hitched.
"Gray! What are you doing!"
Gray lifted up for a second.
"What do you think I'm doing?"
"I don't care...I want more."
Gray started to suck vigorously on Natsu's cock until he climaxed.
"Gray!" Cum spurted out into Gray's mouth. He licked up every last drop.
"Natsu, get on your hands and knees."
"B-but." Natsu stuttered.
"Now." Gary said demandingly.
Natsu complied and did what he was asked of. Gray reached over to his bedside table, opened to drawer and pulled out some lube. He drizzled it over his index and middle finger. The fingers circled the entrance and Natsu knew what was coming next.
"Gray...Please." he begged.
"Your such a slut." Gray laughed as he penetrated Natsu.
"Aaaaaaah!"
Gray then slipped in a third finger.
"Gray!"
"Shh... Calm down, the neighbors might hear you."
"But I can't hold it back." Natsu whined while Gray continued to finger fuck him.
"If you can, I'll give you a reward."
"Nhng... I'll... try."
"Good boy. Ok, I think your ready."
Gray removed his fingers and Natsu whimpered at the loss. Gray somehow still had his pants on, but they were shed in an instant.
"Don't laugh." Gray said as he removed his underpants. Natsu turned his head
"Don't laugh at wha- Phhhfffttt!"
"Shut the fuck up."
"It's so small and adorable!" Natsu giggled. Gray spanked Natsu.
"Ow! Hey!"
"Shh, neighbors."
"Oops, forgot."
Gray lined himself up with Natsu's ass and slowly pushed into him.
"Ahhhh! Gray!"
"Hmmmm Natsu, your so tight."
Gray waited a moment to let Natsu adjust (He didn't need to take to long though, lol small dick) and then started thrusting.
"Natsu your burning hot." Gray said very seductively.
"More..."
Gray fucked Natsu senseless until,
"Gray... I'm gonna...Gray!"
Natsu came all over the bed and Gray came into Natsu's ass shortly afterward. They both collapsed onto the bed panting.
"Natsu...you were great."
"...really?"
"really."
"I love you."
"I love you too."
And then they slept.