For Creepypasta Jr. She asked for a SlenderXJeff fanfic from me and here it is! I decided to make a parody of a funny and sweet YAOI fanfic. Enjoy!


Today was the day. No going back on plans. Jeff the Killer was going to come out and confess his love for the Slenderman.. With a gift.

Today was Valentine's day, and Jeff has been nervous the past few weeks. Would Slender reject his gift and love? Or will he feel the same way? Jeff sighed.

He parked his car in Slender's driveway and sat back in his seat. He wasn't quite sure if he was ready yet. He glanced over at the bouquet of flowers and picked them up. Holding the flowers close to his chest, he wished himself luck, and exited the car.

As he looked at Slender's house, he saw the front window curtains draw back, and the Slenderman was looking out. When Slender noticed him, he smiled and waved, then scurried over to answer the door. Jeff walked up the porch steps.

Before he could knock, Slender opened the door and practically pulled him in with his tentacles.

"Jeffery! Why are you here? Aren't you going to spend Valentine's day with Laughing Jack?" the Slenderman noticed the flowers and pointed at them. " Are those for Jack? They're beautiful! He'll love them!"

"Ah.. Um, no," Jeff stuttered. "These are for you."

Slender was astonished. "Jeffery... What are you trying to say?"

"I'm trying to say that I-I have really liked you for a while now and-"

"But, but Laughing Jack..."

"I may even have more feelings than 'like' and-"

"Won't he be sad?"

"I think I love you," Jeff finished.

The Slenderman opened his non-existant mouth as to say something, but quickly shut it. He studied the bouquet closer and took it out of Jeff's hands hesitantly.

"Jeffery, I'm flattered. I really am, but I have to ask about-"

"I left Laughing Jack," Jeff stared down at the floorboards, twiddling his thumbs. "He has someone else..."

"Wh- Why would you leave him? You two were so happy together. Well, at least it seemed like it."

Jeff looked up at Slender, staring into his non-existant eyes.

"I left him for you." Jeff stepped closer to Slender, grabbing the flowers and setting it down somewhere else nearby. Jeff took hold of Slender's hands before he could protest.

"I had a feeling I could be happier with you. I don't know if you even like me. I don't know if you even like men, but I do know that everytime I look at you and everytime I hear your voice and that beautiful laughter, that I'm hopelessly in love with my friend."

The Slenderman continued to stare at Jeff. His face was flushed pure red. Slender glanced down at Jeff's hands, which were intertwined with his. Jeff stared back at him, eyes full of hope.

"Jeffery, I never knew you felt that way about me. I always pushed back my feelings for you because of the same reasons."

"So... so all this time you-" Jeff's words trailed off. He was too busy worrying about his own feelings and the terrible thought of being rejected, that he never acknowledged Slender's affection towards him.

The Slenderman nodded, a invisable smile on his face. "Jeffery, you could have confessed sooner. You kept me waiting, friend."

"I'm sorry. Oh, and Slendy?"

"What is it?"

Jeff leaned forward, closer and closer to Slender's ear.

"Slendy, will you be my Valentine?" he whispered.

"Of course, Jeffery," Slenderman grinned, pulling Jeff into a hug.

He had a feeling this was the start of a beautiful relationship…


Yeah… So, that's it! I know it's a lame story but hey, I hope you enjoyed it! The original story is from Pewdiecry. Sorry if you were insulted by this! XP

PS: Can you guess who's the person LJ went with?