"You did a good job, today my apprentice." Supreme Leader Snoke said. "Thank You, Supreme Leader." Kylo Ren said. "The Resistance will soon kneel before me." Snoke said. "May I ask you something?" Ren asked. "Yes, what is it?" Snoke asked. "Its Captain Phasma, I'm afraid four times today she did not listen to the orders that I gave her." Ren said. "This is abnormal for the Captain, I'm afraid she must be punished but she can not be harmed or killed." Snoke said. "Are you leaving the choice of punishment up to me?" Ren asked. "Indeed I am, my young apprentice." Snoke said. Kylo Ren knew a few ways to do it.
"Captain." General Hux said. "Yes, Hux what is it?" Phasma asked. "Kylo Ren wants to speak with you." Hux said. "Very well, I'll leave now." Phasma said. Phasma knew almost right away that she was probably in trouble and was hoping she was not going to be tortured. She reached Ren. "You wished to speak with me?" Phasma asked. "I did, Captain, I wanted to talk about the battle from earlier." Ren said. "Of course." Phasma said. "You and your troops did very well but there were four orders I gave you that you didn't follow, am I correct." Ren asked. "Yes, I felt like what I was doing was the best course of action." Phasma said, sounding very nervous. "I have orders from the Supreme Leader himself." Ren said. "What were his orders?" Phasma asked. "You are to be punished for your actions and I get to choose how you are punished." Ren said. "I see, when do the punishments start?" Phasma asked. "Now." Ren said, seriously.