I Never Stopped Loving You

by mockingjay4610

It's 5 years later and his bitchy fiance, Jessica, is pregnant. He stumbles upon Initiates Diner and finds out that Will, Marlene, Lynn, and Uriah are alive. He also finds out Tris is alive with his 4 year old daughter, Olivia (Livi). Will Tobias pick a happy life with Tris and Livi? Or will he pick a miserable life with someone who needs him? Rated T for language.

1. Surprise

Tobias's POV

"Four! The baby is kicking!" Jessica screams. Jessica is my fiance. I really really hate her but she is carrying my child so I felt obligated to marry her. I hate the sound of her voice so I never told her my real name. The way Tris said my name was the best sound in the world. But she's dead and I will never be able to hear her again. It's been 5 years since she died.

"Four! Come here right now!" Jessica demands.

"Sorry, can't. Work just called and I need to do an earlier shift today." I lie. I'm out the door before she can say anything else. I go to this new coffee shop before work. I go in to see that it's crowded. But when I see the workers, my heart stops.

Uriah, Marlene, Lynn, and Will.

I run over to them. They look at me with fear in their eyes but it's replaced by fake happiness.

"Hello sir, welcome to Initiate's Diner. How may I help you?" Marlene says.

"Marlene, it's me, Four." I say.

"I'm sorry, my girlfriend doesn't know any Fours besides the number." Uriah says.

"Uriah, come on, I'm your brother's best friend." I say, I'm getting sick of this game.

"Look, we're not the people you're looking for. Uriah only has a sister, Lynn." Will says.

"Cut the crap Will." I snap.

"Sir, I'm going to have to ask you to leave if you cause any commotion." Lynn says.

"You're one to talk." I scoff.

She's about to say something back when we hear the bell of the door ring. I hear a familiar voice.

"Hey guys. Sorry I'm late. Livi is going to spend the day with us because Matt-" her voice stops when she sees me. It's Tris. Her eyes widen and then she slaps on a fake smile like the rest of them. I see she's carrying a little girl, about 4 years old I assume. "Hello sir, can I get you anything to drink?"

"Tris." I whisper.

"I'm sorry, I don't think I'm the person you're looking for." She says looking down.

"But-" I'm cut off by someone calling me. I get out my phone and see it's Jessica. I decline but when I look up, everyone's gone. What the hell just happened? I need to talk to Zeke and Shauna about this. Or Caleb and Cara. Or Lauren and Bud. Who do I go to first? Zeke and Shauna. It's his little brother, Uriah and her little sister, Lynn anyways.