Payback's A Bitch
Summary: What if Nathan and Brooke walked in on Lucas and Peyton mid make-out session instead of Haley? Timelines are mixed together. It is set when Lucas was cheating on Brooke with Peyton, but Haley left for tour and Nathan said that if she left it was over. Nathan/Brooke (Brathan), mentions of Nathan/Peyton (Pathan/Neyton), mentions of Brooke/Lucas (Brucas) and minor Lucas/Peyton (Leyton)
Disclaimer: I don't own One Tree Hill or there would have been a totally hot Nathan, Peyton, Brooke, Haley, Taylor, Love Square plus One whatever that is.
Chapter: Cheaters & Revenge
In the library Peyton and Lucas were kissing like there was no tomorrow. They weren't worried about anyone finding them because they were in the secluded part of the library.
Brooke and Nathan had an English book report due and went to the library to find their books. Brooke was supposed to go with Peyton and Nathan was supposed to meet up with Lucas but they were unfortunately busy.
Brooke and Nathan treaded into the secluded part of the library. They tried not to make a noise as they already got shouted at twice by the librarian for laughing too loud.
As they get closer they can hear giggling and the sounds of moaning. Brooke removes the book from the shelf and they see Lucas and Peyton. Both Brooke and Nathan are extremely angry. Brooke turns to Nathan and says, "You wanna help me get revenge on their lieing cheating, skanky asses?"
Nathan sexily smirks and deviously replies, "Hell yeah. What do you have in mind?"
"This." Brooke says with a fiery gaze, as she runs her finger flirtatiously down his chest.
They both lean in. Nathan's lips presses against Brooke's softly but soon the kiss turns more passionate. Nathan's one hand cups her face and his other hand trails down to her waist. Brooke's hands end up in his hair.
Nathan's tongue traces across her teeth and she gives him enterance. He nips at her lip and she moans loudly. She breaks the kiss because she's out of breath and blurts out, "Damn, you're a great kisser! No wonder she kept going back to you."
Nathan cockily smirks, "That's not all I can do."
"Oh yeah? Then you'll have to show me some time." Brooke flirts back.
"Or I could show you right now and let you have your revenge fantasy." He flirts back.
Instead of replying with words she kisses him again this time a lot more needy. She breaks the kiss only for a moment and pulls his head back, kissing his neck earnestly.
This time he breaks the contact and latches onto her neck, placing soft kisses and then roughly yet gently sucking onto her neck leaving hickeys where ever he pleased.
She moans louder and louder and Lucas and Peyton can hear them. They didn't know who the noise was coming from so they went to inspect. Peyton held onto Lucas' sweaty hand. Lucas gives her a small smile. They walk to where the noise is coming from.
They see Brooke and Nathan making out. Nathan's one hand is up the back of her shirt and his other hand is cupping her soft cheek. Brooke's legs are wrapped around Nathan torso and her hands are moving through his hair.
Lucas and Peyton were stunned for a few moments before they both scream out, "What the hell is going on here?!"
Brooke let's her feet touch the ground softly and she removes her hands from his lucious dark brown locks. Nathan let's his fingers draw circles on her back before removing them gently. He removes his other hand from her face and they both turn around to face Lucas and Peyton.
"What you guys get to make-out and we don't?" Nathan raises an eyebrow at them.
Lucas and Peyton both open their mouths to answer and they have nothing to say, so they promptly close it. Brooke and Nathan smirk.
Then Peyton looks angrily at Brooke, "How could you do that to Lucas, I thought you loved him?!"
And Lucas looks angrily at Nathan, "And you, I thought you loved Haley?! How could you do this to me?! I'm your brother!"
Brooke looks at Peyton, "No P Sawyer, how could you do this to me?! You want to judge me while you're screwing my boyfriend?!"
She turns to Lucas, "And you, how dare you judge him?! You're screwing my best friend! Haley left him! She has no right to him! And you want him to choose you over someone his known for most of his life?! You chose Haley over him! He has every right to do the same!
Nathan finally speaks up and says, "She's right! Both of you can go fuck yourselves! Unless you're not done fucking each other! Behind your girlfriend's and your best friend's back, whom might I add you've known since you were five! She was the one who helped with everything! She was the one who always stood by you! And now you do this to her! And you have the audacity to judge her!"
Brooke grips Nathan's hand and pulls him out behind her. She lets go of his hand and bitch slaps Peyton across her face. She looks to Nathan but he's staring at Peyton in disappointment.
Nathan says to Peyton, "I'm disappointed in you Peyton. You're lucky you're a girl of I would hit you by now."
He turns to Lucas, "You on the other hand, are not so lucky."
He lifts his right hand up and curls his fist into a ball and aims right for Lucas. He hits Lucas square in the face and pulls his arm back. He punches Lucas again, this time in his right eye. He reels his hand back aiming for Lucas' other eye until Brooke places his hand on his arm to stops him.
Brooke looks into his enticing blue eyes, shakes her head and says, "He's not worth it..."
They walk out of there hurt on the inside but tough on the outside. Now they can heal each other.
Author's Note: Please review if you'd like me to continue with this or to just leave it as one-shot. Thanks for reading, hope you enjoyed :)! PM me if you have any ideas for this or anyone of my other stories :)!
R & R
Awesomeness2502