Bringing out the Freak in Girls (Chapter 1)
This first chapter is based around the 5x09 episode where Brooke, Peyton, Haley, Mia and Lindsey are locked in the Tree Hill High school library. The first few opening exchanges are pulled directly from the real script – the happenings are just altered a little in parts. Thanks again to Vexer6 for the idea. It's fucking brilliant and I had a lot of fun writing this. Hope y'all enjoy.
Peyton and Lindsey bickered stubbornly at one another.
"I did not call you a bitch. I said I didn't like you," Peyton looked sternly at her enemy. The girl engaged to the love of her life. "Hey, if you get tired dragging that fat ass back to the gym, there is a water fountain down the hall."
"Whatever, you bulimic bitch," Lindsey hissed in reply, making her way for the door. "There's no handle."
"They're fixing them over the weekend," Brooke said, having found a piece of paper nearby with that same message.
"So what's that mean?"
"I think it means we're stuck," Haley said.
"We cannot be locked in here. I am totally claustrophobic."
"Looks like we are," Brooke reiterated their position. And she seemed strangely okay with it. "It's not all bad."
"No? How's that?" Lindsey walked back and forth, stressed.
"I honestly don't mind missing the game," Mia smirked. Basketball wasn't her thing.
"Exactly, Mia," Brooke agreed. "And besides... we can play our own game in here." She lunged at Lindsey and gave the taller girl a kiss right on the lips.
Peyton, Haley and Mia's jaws dropped all in unison.
"What are you doing?" Lindsey pushed Brooke off of her.
"Oh my God," Haley couldn't believe it.
"That was hot." Mia most certainly approved. She wasn't as shy and innocent as she let on.
"Yeah?" Brooke smiled, posing the question rhetorically as Mia moved in on her. The older girl knew a kiss was coming, and it did. Now Lindsey was a spectator to girl-on-girl kissing, and this snog lasted quite some time.
"Yummy," Brooke murmured as they broke their connection. There was more of it to come, and if Brooke could work her charm on the other three they'd all be in for some incredible sex. "You like that, P Sawyer," she giggled. Peyton couldn't wipe the lust off her face. It was evident the blonde was turned on.
"Where's my kiss?" Peyton grinned, and her bestie made sure the request didn't go unfulfilled. Mia took a seat on one of the tables, watched the pair and slid a hand down her pants. It was all moving awfully fast, and the Breyton kiss oozed and outpour of feelings. They had been best friends almost their entire lives and now they were making out like lovers.
Without another word, Brooke moved onto Haley. She knew Tutor Girl would be a hard one to crack, but Brooke wanted her to make the move. So she nose-grazed and teased with 'fuck me' eyes. Who could resist that, right?
"I so wanna eat you out," Brooke whispered. And that did it. Haley snogged her friend and Brooke had her third participant. It was all too easy... She eventually had to pry herself from Haley's grasp, and when she did, Brooke advanced in on Lindsey. "I want you to show us all the things Luke sees." She put a hand on Lindsey's waist, to which the taller girl trembled a little. "And I want you to make Peyton scream." Lindsey was not your typical party girl. She'd never gone out and gotten drunk. She'd never kissed another girl, let alone considered it. Yet here she was feeling open-minded and keen.
"Okay," she smiled; butterflies fluttering in her stomach.
By this point, Brooke just wanted the pussy. She took advantage of Lindsey's nerves and let her hands do the talking. Mia was already steps ahead with her jeans down around her ankles and both hands giving it to her cunt. And one other girl in particular took notice; Haley. This hot little finger-fucker getting off for everyone to see was her protégé and she wanted a piece of Mia's body. And soon enough, Mia spotted her friend staring.
"Come here, Haley," she offered with a wink. It was like bait for a hungry fish and Haley couldn't resist. The pair embraced and got all giggly as they kissed. Now it was Peyton the lone girl out and watching this glorious bunch of girls get hot and heavy. Her eyes were glued on BFF Brooke, and were granted a touch of telepathy. While snogging Lindsey and rubbing the layer of denim at her crotch with one hand, Brooke gestured for Peyton the 'come hither' call. The blonde practically leaped by her side, and then behind Brooke. Horny as fuck, she grinded up against Brooke and whispered sweet nothings in her ears.
Peyton hadn't been this turned on in years. When Brooke broke her kiss with Lindsey, she had the two sworn enemies kiss. Neither Peyton nor Lindsey needed little convincing. Their hatred toward one another didn't matter when it came down to lust and wanting to get your freak on. Brooke then made her way over to the table Haley and Mia were getting nasty on and the two girls followed. The first thing on the agenda: stripping. Brooke loved fashion design and loved clothes and everything, but she also appreciated a naked hot chick more than the next closet cunt-lover. So Brooke took initiative - unbuttoning her jeans, making the floor their new friend; letting her boobs breath a little. And both her little fucktoys followed like sheep. The three of them not only had each other's amazing bods to admire in the process, but Haley was on her knees right beside them, eating out Mia at a ferocious rate. So not surprisingly, the trio's panties were already a little damp before they even had the chance to leave 'em behind.
"I want you to fuck her, Lindsey." Brooke made her intentions clear the second her two lady friends were ready. "Let out anger out," she grinned.
"Is this what you want?" Lindsey pushed the blonde and bowled her clean over. She gave Brooke a glance as she stalked Peyton down and stood over her. In any normal situation, Peyton would have got right back up and given Lindsey a threat, but that's the last thing she wanted. She loved this little game and loved the sense of power this 'mean' girl had over her. It was kinky and would leave to a delightful fuck. Plus it was making Brooke rub herself and whimper already.
"Fuck me like Lucas fucks you, bitch," the blonde hissed. The 'freak' of these girls was well and truly out. As a little appetizer, Lindsey shoved Haley's face into the cunt she was eagerly lapping up. The married girl moaned as pussy juices ran down her chin and her nose was filled with the aroma. Even when Lindsey let up and let Haley fuck Mia in peace, the keen little rugmuncher kept her face planted firmly in the nice cookie. Brooke had both pair of girls to work with and her pussy was tingling as she masturbated.
The two rivals had their shit sorted. Peyton got on her hands and knees, and Lindsey mimicked it.
"Want my fingers in your pussy?"
"God yes," Peyton grunted.
"Yeah?" Lindsey took it nice and slow; teasing the blonde's clit, fingering her hole methodically slow. Until suddenly, BAM. "You want my man, huh? You wanna steal Lucas? Huh?" She shoved three fingers inside Peyton and unleashed.
"Oh, you bitch!" Peyton screamed, but she really loved it.
"You fucking bulimic bitch."
"Oh, god!"
"You like that, slut? Yeah, you know you do."
Peyton was moaning, Mia was moaning, and loudest of all, Brooke was moaning. The library was a 'moanfest' and the instigator of it all – the one left to her own devices – was the most vocal. Brooke was on the brink of orgasm and just wanted one teensy little treasure for when she did. The brunette dropped to her knees (hands still working her cunt over like an impossibly fast machine) and crawled the short way over to right up close and personal with all the action. From there, Brooke used Lindsey's tight ass like a dinner plate and licked away at the gaping backdoor hole. Lindsey barely even flinched but commented on what a nasty whore Brooke was, and that's when the sexy host came. She dug her tongue into future Mrs Scott's butt and kept it there 'til her orgasm passed.
The sounds that came out of Brooke were some of the most amazing one could ever witness, and maybe it was just Lindsey's keenness to replicate the ass-eating by doing the same to her blonde arch rival, but Peyton found herself becoming considerably weaker at the knees. As Brooke's squeals and screams died down to just moans, she lapped up Lindsey's cunt. So consumed by the abundance of perfection they were experiencing, the three girls didn't even notice their little rockstar friend above climaxing. And it was a pity, too, because Mia was a squirter. Her voice cracked, the squealing kicked in and she edged herself away from Haley's mouth with good reason. Mia thrashed her head uncontrollably to one side as she took aim. Before Haley could grasp what was coming, the floodgates opened and a wall of delicious cum came gushing at her. She had never been more turned as this chick whose vocal talents she admired so dearly drenched her face in juices. And she had never even been on the receiving end of a facial from Nathan. This was her debut into that part of sex and it was incredible. The pair got to kissing, before Mia sucked a little of her own cum off of Haley's beautiful features. They both excited to really get this orgy going.
So they tagged in and continued with the path the three hotties had made. Haley ducked in under Peyton and had the blonde give her oral, while Mia snugged in behind Brooke and kept this 'chain' mentality going. One after another had their mouths in some grade A pussy and sweat wasn't the only thing dripping off of these girls.
Peyton in particular was loving her first taste of a cunt. Her amazing eyes were all the sexier and she was drooling madly as she pigged out on Haley's delicious pinkness. The brunette moaned Peyton's name as she lay there spellbound with utter pleasure. On the other end of this girl-bang, Mia was helping herself to Brooke's juices. This musical prodigy just loved the taste of cum, and the feel of it down her throat. And seeing as how Brooke was still shaky from that orgasm, her pussy was delicious and dripping. It made her Mia's perfect candidate.
Feeling as if she had to step up the ante, Lindsey made the bold move of venturing into Peyton's ass. The blonde wasn't expecting anal, and that's exactly why Lindsey felt the need for it. To get this bitch moaning again. With her fingers lubed in Peyton's pre-cum, she dug two of them deep inside the delectable, scrawny ass.
"BITCH!" Peyton shrieked. The pain was rather intense – and Lindsey's callousness really ticked the blonde off – but again, it was Peyton's dirty side that shone through in the end. "You filthy bitch," she gritted her teeth as this chick she was supposed to hate gave her something to love.
"Say my name," Lindsey demanded. "You know what? Call me Lindsey Scott." Her relationship with Luke fuelled this whole dyke business between the pair, and it was a rush – a thrill.
"Peyton Scott," the blonde cackled (rather menacingly and creepily). She was now looking back at her counterpart and leaving Haley unattended, but that didn't matter none, because her teacher friend was already taking care of herself. "That's my ring he gave you, bitch!"
Lindsey didn't know what that meant in the heat of things, and she wasn't going to drop everything for 'question time', so she just took it at face value and saw it as Peyton being the nasty whore she was.
"Oh, really?" Lindsey laughed, equally as menacingly as Peyton had. And then came the intense pounding. Peyton got up from where she was perched on her elbows and wrists; now to the palms of her hands. Lindsey worked her fingers in and out of the blonde's ass like an impenetrable force. And to make things more unbearable for Peyton, Lindsey rubbed her clit at an astronomical rate as well.
"Ohhh, FUCK! Fuuuuhhck!" She bellowed time and time again.
"LINDSEY Scott! LINDSEY Scott!"
Brooke was peering over Lindsey's shoulder, absolutely adoring the sight of her best friend being pummelled and shouted at. She was dying to see Peyton's cumface.
"Fuck her. Fuck her," Brooke murmured.
"I'm CUMMMMMIIIIIIIIINGGGH!" Peyton completely lost it as she came to that point of no return. She jerked around with Lindsey's fingers puckered deep in her ass and not going anywhere any time soon. This orgasm was the rawest experience of her life and she felt like her entire urinary tract was going to pop out as she came. Brooke watched on in awe, totally speechless and uber horny as Peyton's cunt spat and dripped all over the place. She felt an overwhelming desire come over her, and as much as Mia didn't appreciate the gorgeous girl leaving, Brooke lunged in to make camp under Peyton. She opened her mouth wide and caught every bit of cum she possibly could.
"Thirsty, Brooke?" Lindsey grinned, squeezing the fashionista's boobs and letting Peyton's tight butt go free (for now). "Dirty girl," she popped the two fingers of the moment down Brooke's gob and the brunette treated them like a prize.
"Ohh, Brooke," Peyton moaned, so in love with her best friend's freakiness. Here was Tree Hill's richest and sexiest babe essentially tasting her ass. It didn't get much filthier than that.
"My turn, bitches." Lindsey was eager to have her own special treatment. Brooke wasn't quite ready to see those delicious fingers go, though, and where they went, she followed. Lindsey sat herself up and soon Mia got in behind her. The pair of them shared a kiss, before Mia let the older girl lay back about 30 degrees on her for support. Lindsey spread her legs, and by this time Peyton's intentions were well and truly made. While Brooke lay by Lindsey's side sucking her fingers once again, Haley was up on her feet and contempt on making Luke's fiancé finish what Peyton had started.
It was all like some beautifully-orchestrated karma sutra manoeuvring, but in actual fact everyone just sort of fell in place. Very little words were said because each girl knew what they wanted. Peyton spread Lindsey's snatch and immediately went to town on it. She wanted the pussy. Mia was happy with being a spectator and giving Lindsey a place to rest. Haley just wanted to cum; and Brooke wanted to suck the smell of Peyton's ass off of some pretty fingers. Simple.
"You better make me cum," Haley remarked sternly to the girl at the center of attention. Lindsey was itching for another pussy in her mouth. As she'd learnt, it was much better than cock.
Haley stood over her, spread her pussy to its limits, and made sure to get right up in Lindsey's grill. "Yeah, that's it," she approved. Lindsey munched on it immediately, and Mia – horny as hell – played with the older girl's tits as she watched it all go down.
"You taste so fuckin' good," Peyton said, squeezing and pinching Lindsey's thighs as she chowed down on her rival's cunt more ferociously with each passing moment. "Peyton Scott, bitch." She slapped some ass as she made the comment, to which Lindsey squealed. And the slapping passed on like a fever to Mia. The young girl gave Lindsey's boobs a few smacks, and a fair share to Haley's butt as well.
"Cum on her." Mia was desperate to see it. To see her musical mentor's sticky juices on this hot babe in the middle of it all. "Cum on her face," she moaned.
Both Haley and Lindsey were making some noise. (Actually, they all were, excepting Brooke.) And Haley's dam was about to burst. She was never a screamer in the sack, but when an orgasm hit it was a different story.
"Shit, shit, shit, shit, SHIT!" Haley grinded herself harder into Lindsey's mouth as she rode her climax home. "Ohhhh... GOD! God YES, LINDSSEEEEEY!" She didn't have the sexiest of cumfaces, but that's just because the orgasm was so damn intense. And the more intense, the better.
Haley grabbed Lindsey's head and crammed her crotch harder into it again. For a few seconds there, Lindsey was going without breath. The horny married chick was suffocating the poor girl and smothering her with pussy juices. But Lindsey fucking loved it, like any nymphomaniac probably would. The same rule that applied to the intensity of a climax applied to smut. The smuttier, the better.
"Oh my Goooohhhd," Haley bent over like a stripper and kissed her beaver-eater on the lips. "You're talented, girl," she laughed. Lindsey's chin was dripping with cum and the shorter girl adored it. Haley got down next to Peyton and worked with what her blonde friend gave her. Peyton played nice and shared. Haley was given the clit while Peyton honed in on finger-fucking. "Do her ass, too," the brunette bit her lips, dying to see it happen.
"Yeah?"
"Yeah." They looked into one another's eyes, Peyton blindly finding Lindsey's butthole and sliding a finger in there.
"You like that?" she smiled; Haley glancing for a quick look but now more turned on by pretty face before her. The pair kissed like a long-time couple – confidently and with meaning – then it was back to business.
Lindsey could do nothing but moan as Peyton stuffed her holes and Haley made a toy of her clit. And to make things all the more erotic, Mia (being the freaky girl she transformed into with a little help from Brooke, just like the rest of them) gave Lindsey a few fingers to deepthroat.
"Cum, baby," Haley encouraged, watching Lindsey intently as she rubbed the girl's clit.
"She likes those fingers," Brooke popped up from Lindsey's side, admiring what the clan was doing to this wife-to-be. "Fingers in every hole." She kissed their fucktoy and whispered all sorts of slutty things in her ear afterwards.
"Come on, baby, CUM," Haley gave Lindsey's tits a little grope, and just as she did, the cries came. Lindsey's screams topped that of Brooke's and this professional writing editor couldn't have scripted a better orgasm herself. All four girls watched smiling as Lindsey thrashed about in pure ecstasy.
"Oh my God," Brooke laughed, totally impressed and wowed.
"Aaahhhhh," Lindsey was still well and truly sensitive. She was shaking at the thighs and her pussy was tingling like crazy.
"I think she wants more," Peyton told the group.
"God, no," Lindsey giggled. She really couldn't go another round – not with her body the way it was now.
"She needs more," Peyton grinned. This blonde showed no mercy.
The group was keen. They wanted to see Lindsey get fucked senseless. She had such a euphoric orgasm and they all wanted seconds.
"You bitches," Lindsey laughed for a moment – a bit scared of these girls doing more to her, but ready to be completely smitten and given an almost 'out-of-body' experience.
Peyton slid her fingers back in Lindsey's tight holes and it was on again. Who said a bunch of hot chicks being locked in a library was a bad thing? The 'freak' in these girls loved it...
-
END OF CHAPTER ONE
Please leave reviews with what you liked or didn't like; what you want to see come out of this story in the future, etc. I always say this (and I will again): that kind of support really helps motivate me to write.