A/N: Link to Rachel's dress and lingerie can be found on my profile. This work goes alongside Teenage Hero and will only contain the mature versions of any chapters written there.
Dress upon dress had been tossed on Rachel's bed as she tried to decide what she was going to wear, an action that seemed to be in vain. Noah had made it clear that she should wear a dress though and so Rachel was going to do her best to comply with that request. What did one wear to lose their virginity and hopefully make a baby, though? Deciding that what was honestly more important was her undergarments, Rachel moved to her drawers and carefully pulled out her nicest and prettiest bra and underwear set before laying it on her pillow, the only spot on her bed not already occupied.
Because of the shape of that set, Rachel knew she needed a higher neck dress which quickly narrowed down the pool available to her. Her eyes kept lingering towards one though she felt like it might be too much. However, the more she thought about it the more she was sure that he would love it. It had little cut-outs on her stomach that she was certain he wouldn't be able to keep his fingers away from, at least for as long as the dress was on her, and the pale blue color only accented her tan skin. With that decided, Rachel found herself pacing her room wishing that it would be late enough in the day that she could start getting ready.
After watching Funny Girl to distract herself from panicking, Rachel fixed herself a small salad for dinner before returning to her room to perfect her makeup and hair. Thankfully, once she started it didn't seem like long before the clock was approaching nine.
While Rachel had been trying to find ways to kill time, Noah felt like he didn't have enough of it. Stopping by the mall, Noah picked up an air mattress, some sweet sheets, and a couple pillows. Then he spotted some string lights and that sent him on the hunt for a version that was battery operated. For a moment he debated stopping at the drugstore out of habit but then he remembered that protection would kinda defeat the point. Instead, he detoured to the local clinic, leaving an hour later satisfied with the papers he wanted in hand.
Figuring out the setup was the part Noah was having the most trouble with. After all, he wanted to surprise Rachel but at the same time he was picking her up and if he set up too early the surprise would be ruined. So he decided that he would just have to wing it when they actually got to the spot he had in mind, he'd find some way to distract her. Once he had loaded up all of his purchases, Noah made a quick stop back at his nana's house to shower and change before he returned to Rachel's, ready to change both of their lives.
The moment the door opened, Noah knew that there was no other decision better for him than this one. Rachel looked like an angel, one that had killer sex appeal on top of utter perfection. "Damn…" He breathed, his voice getting caught in his throat for a moment. "You look incredible…" If she wasn't a virgin, he wouldn't have hesitated to say 'screw his plans' and just take her upstairs.
Noah didn't look half bad himself. It was clear that he had shaved and the sleeves of his dress shirt were rolled up to his elbows, showing off forearms that made Rachel swoon. "You don't look shabby yourself." She whispered smiling up at him. "Um...should we go?" She questioned, reaching for her purse on the table beside the door. With a nod, Noah reached for her hand and led her to his truck, helping her up before running around to climb into the driver's seat.
The drive was about half an hour and it was definitely dark when Noah pulled down a gravel road and into a clearing. Horror movies flashed through Rachel's mind but all it took was a single touch of Noah's hand on her knee and Rachel was relaxed again, looking over at him. "I want you to wait here for just a few minutes." He declared. "Just trust me. I'm not going far." While she wasn't a huge fan of being left alone in the dark, Rachel nodded weakly and just closed her eyes, willing herself not to fall asleep even though it was starting to get late.
Quickly, Noah jumped out of the cab and moved around to the back of his truck, quickly using the pump to blow up the air mattress before wrapping the fitted sheet around it and sliding it into the back where it was a snug fit. The top sheet followed as well as a blanket and the pillows he'd purchased were placed both up by the windows as well as along the sides so that there were no hard edges surrounding the makeshift bed. With that done, he clamored to drape the lights over the top, wishing that he'd thought to park near low branches. While it wasn't perfect it would have to do, especially since he was sure that Rachel was starting to get stir crazy.
When he climbed back into the truck Rachel was slightly confused and blinked quickly when he turned the light on overhead before handing her a sheet of paper. "Figured it couldn't hurt to give you peace of mind…" He whispered. Scanning over the words Rachel realized that she was looking at an STI panel, a negative one at that. It hadn't even dawned on her that he might be carrying something but she couldn't help but lean over and kiss him realizing that he really was going to take care of her. "Now that that's out of the way should I show you my plans?" He questioned to which Rachel nodded enthusiastically.
Admittedly, she hadn't been sure what to expect when it came to a teenage boy's sense of romance but as she moved around the side of the truck to the back, where Noah directed her to stand in place while he moved to switch on the lights she couldn't help but gasp. It was basically a fairytale, stars above them, minimal lighting and not a soul around to interrupt them. "Oh my god…" She breathed. "You did all this for me?" While this had been started because of her desire for a baby, right now it felt like so much more than that.
Gently, Noah's hands wound around Rachel's waist and he gently lifted her so that she was sitting on the hatch of the truck before he easily jumped up to help her move onto the bed, kicking his shoes off as he did. "You deserved something more than a quick round in a bedroom or even a seedy motel." He shrugged really not thinking that it was that big of a deal, he'd give himself some credit of course but not as much as Rachel seemed to want to.
As they settled onto the mattress, Noah tugged Rachel's body closer to his, feeling her tense slightly. "Relax...we'll go slow." He promised, sliding his arm under her shoulders before pulling her mouth to his for a soft kiss. This was really going to shatter any expectations Rachel had about this moment in the best way possible.
The way Noah's mouth moved over hers was demanding but at the same time gentle and caring. Rachel couldn't help but whimper into his mouth her body responding to even the smallest of touches. She had never expected something like this but in this moment she wanted to give Noah just as much as he was going to give her. While she'd always expected her first time to be once she was married and a star, she was certain that couldn't feel as right as this did, here and now.
As their kisses continued, Noah moved his hands down Rachel's body, taking in every curve and inch of smooth skin that he could reach. He couldn't wait to reveal more of it but he wanted Rachel to be comfortable with each and every aspect of this before he let them progress. Pulling back, Noah again commented on how gorgeous Rachel was and she blushed before guiding his hand to the bottom of her dress. "You can take it off me…" She whispered just staring up at him in amazement.
Before he undressed her, Noah quickly pulled his own shirt over his head before pressing open mouth kisses to Rachel's neck and shoulders. It wasn't until she started to shake under him slightly from the pleasure that he reached to the hem of her dress, urging her to lift her hips so that he could tug the piece of clothing up and over her head. The sight that met his eyes when she was left in just her undergarments made him groan as his pants became increasingly uncomfortable. "Fuck babe….lace?" He murmured his fingers trailing over the floral pattern that covered her and just made her even prettier if that was possible. Girls like her weren't supposed to own lingerie like this and Puck palmed himself through his pants trying to control himself.
Rachel could only blush, reaching her hands up to caress the skin of Noah's chest. His attractiveness wasn't something anyone would question and part of her was still in disbelief that he was here complimenting her of all things. "Do you like it?" She whispered hoping that the choice had been the right one to heighten his reaction to her. When Puck's only response was to press his hips down into her, the message was clear.
It took only a flick of his thumb for Puck to undo his pants, quickly shimmying them off of his hips before groaning in relief of some of the pressure he'd been feeling. He had to remind himself that while he would end up inside of her, this was about her above all and he needed to make sure that she had the best memory of this possible. So, he kissed her again and his hand moved to graze the side of her breast before he reached to untie the string that held Rachel's bra together. Her back arched up for him and he quickly peeked down to catch a glimpse of her chest. While it wasn't huge, it was perfect to him and he made sure she was aware of just how attractive he found her by whispering in her ear.
Rachel had never felt a need as strong as the one she was feeling now. It was like her skin was on fire and she wanted nothing more than for Noah to do whatever it took to put it out. "Please…" She whispered back to him, to which Noah quickly nodded and tugged her underwear off of her hips before gently pressing a finger to her folds. She was completely drenched already and he grunted as he urged her to part her legs for him a bit more.
"Just relax Rae…" He urged as he kissed her again and pressed one finger into her core, immediately feeling her body clench around him. Slick and hot were the only words he could use to describe the way it felt and Noah couldn't wait until he was completely seated inside of her, that clenching around his hard cock. "God babe, you're fucking soaked." He stated as his mouth moved down her neck to her shoulders before he shifted his body a bit to be able to take one of her pebbled nipples into his mouth. While it wasn't cold out and they were under covers, it was clear that the slight breeze had heightened her body's reaction, something he was certain was only going to bring her to orgasm quicker.
Rachel couldn't even begin to describe the feelings as Noah pumped first a single finger inside of her before adding a second and scissoring them to force her body to stretch out in accommodation. It wasn't like Rachel wasn't familiar with the technical aspects of sex but feeling them first hand was something else entirely. She just wanted more and more even if it all felt so good, deep down her body knew that there was just something better waiting to come out. And with his mouth on her breasts, Rachel reached down to grip at his hair, little gasps, moans, and whimpers escaping each time his mouth or hands did something different.
It all exploded before she even knew what was happening and a shriek of Noah's name left her mouth as her body seized up as wave after wave of pleasure rolled through her, Noah's actions not letting up and only prolonging the experience. "Woah…" She whispered, a lazy grin on her face when she was finally able to catch her breath. By then, Noah was just laying next to her, a smirk gracing his features as he took in how she looked post orgasmic bliss.
"It only gets better." He assured her as he slipped his fingers from her core to suck the juices off of his fingers. "So fucking sweet." He commented causing Rachel's face to crinkle before she turned her head away from him for a moment. He'd have no part of that though and he pulled her back into a deep kiss, forcing her to taste herself on his tongue. While it was dirty it was such a turn on at the same time and Rachel felt that ache between her thighs growing again.
"Are you ready?" He questioned needing to know that she was fully consenting to taking the next step before he actually went all of the way.
"I need you." She assured him, her fingers teasing lightly over his shoulder. "Let's make a baby."
Noah could only growl instinctively at the thought of her growing heavy with his child and she didn't need to direct him twice. Gently tugging her back under him, Noah slipped his boxers off before rocking his hips against her, teasing her with his length. Feeling him, Rachel almost panicked unsure of whether he was going to fit even if she technically knew that odds were slim he wouldn't. Thankfully, the sparks of pleasure from his fingers pressing against her bundle of nerves was enough to distract her and she smiled up at him before nodding.
This was it. This was the first time that Puck was going to have sex with someone that he actually kind of cared about. Not only that, but this was the first time that he was purposely not using protection because of a mutual decision to create a new life. That was a lot of pressure but the way Rachel was smiling up at him instantly brought him back down to earth. After pressing a sweet kiss to her lips, Noah guided Rachel's hands to his back and bicep before lining himself up with her core and gently pressing the tip inside. "Just breathe. Focus on me and the baby we're going to make." He instructed her, needing her to keep calm so that he didn't hurt her.
As he pressed inside of her inch by inch, Rachel's eyes filled with tears but they weren't from pain or discomfort as much as they were from just overwhelming sensations. Instead of gripping him tightly in pain, Rachel's hands moved over his skin softly if only to assure him that things were okay.
When their hips met, Noah could only let out a mix of a growl and a grunt as his hands moved to grip gently at her hips. "You feel so good, babe." He assured her just letting her adjust though it was almost painful for him to try to hold still.
"So do you." She gasped, her nails digging into his arm slightly. "Oh god, please move." She exclaimed, not sure really why she needed him to, but just that she did. Within a moment he had obeyed and Rachel's hips bucked against him uncontrollably. If she had thought earlier had been good, it was nothing in comparison as being so close to someone else that they were literally inside of you. All she could do was urge him to move faster, seeing that peak in the distance already and needing to reach it more than she needed to breathe.
While he'd been with his fair share of girls, Puck was certain in that moment that no one had been more captivating or sexier in the throes of passion than Rachel was. So much so that he was certain he was going to lose it. Needing to feel her cum with him, Noah pushed her leg back a bit to change the angle before also sliding a thumb between them to again press at her clit. "Let go for me Rae so that I can fill you up…" He moaned.
Within moments her body snapped and he felt her clench down on him so hard that he couldn't even move. The vice grip she had on his dick was all it took for his control to snap as well and he pressed his head into her neck as he pumped his load into her, hoping that soon enough their child would be growing inside of her. Not that he would be opposed to trying until it took because she had been the best lay he'd ever had.
Both were shaking as their orgasms ebbed and Rachel cried out softly before pressing her body closer to his. "You were fantastic." He whispered not sure whether she would need the assurance or not. As he moved to pull out of her, Rachel shook her head.
"Not yet." She mumbled, not ready to lose the solid connection to him. They wouldn't be able to stay like this forever but Rachel wanted to milk every moment she could have even if he was growing soft and their combined fluids were leaking onto the sheets beneath them.
Though it was hard for Noah to support his weight on top of her, he didn't move, instead just peppering kisses over her body.
When Rachel finally allowed him to roll off to her side, Noah wrapped his arms around her again. "Thank you. This was perfect." She breathed, twisting her head to look at him, her hair mussed and her lips swollen.