Warning: Mature chapter, look away if your underage.
Beta'd by the wonderful Puckelberry4eva.
Chapter 1
When Rachel Berry heard the doorbell ring at 10 o'clock on a Friday night she immediately started to panic . She was home alone because her fathers were spending the weekend in a hotel for their wedding anniversary.
Rachel grabbed her cricket bat that she had beside her bed in case of an emergency and crept down the stairs. She was only in her pyjama shorts and vest top but if it was a robber or a murderer at her door then they probably wouldn't care what she was wearing.
"Fuck sake Berry," A voice shouted from the other side of the door followed by a few loud thumps against it.
Rachel recognized the voice immediately and kept her cricket bat raised as she opened the door.
"Are you seriously going to try knocking me out?" Puck asked glancing at the bat in the small brunettes hands. "Go on then crazy, take a swing."
"What are you doing at my house? It's late and a Friday night, shouldn't you be at some party getting off with some cheerio," Rachel asked lowering the bat. "This isn't some football prank is it?"
Rachel glanced over Pucks shoulder searching the darkness for any signs of Puck's friends. He had spent the last few years going out of his way to make her life hell so she had a right to be nervous.
Puck snorted and pushed his way inside. "Chill Berry I'm only here on a house call, your dad mentioned you were going to be home alone this weekend so mom asked me to come check up on you," Puck explained wondering into the kitchen.
Rachel nervously followed and entered the kitchen in time to see Puck grabbing two glasses from her cupboard and pulling a bottle of vodka from his jacket. It didn't come to any surprise that his jacket could hide alcohol.
"What are you doing?" Rachel demanded dropping the bat and grabbing the glasses before Puck could pour anything into them. "You're not getting drunk in my house."
"I've got to spend the next hour here to keep my Ma happy so there's no way in hell I can do that sober," Puck said snatching the glasses. "Do something useful and find something to mix it with."
"Just go do whatever you do on a Friday night and if your mother rings I'll tell her you stayed for a while," Rachel complained.
Puck ignored her and started his own search for something to mix the vodka with. Everything in Berry's house was 'sugar free' or 'organic' and there was no way in hell Puck was drinking any of that stuff. He finally food a cupboard full of sweets, sugary drinks and pork Rinds.
"Naughty little Jew," An amused Puck said pulling out the pork scratchings and shaking them at Rachel. "Never knew you had a wild side Berry."
"Those aren't mine, daddy eats them and that's his cupboard. My dad and I don't eat pork as you well know Noah and I don't have sugary products. I also don't drink alcohol which is illegal for our age so if you would kindly…"
"Shut up Berry," Puck interrupted grabbing a bottle of coke and mixing it with the vodka. He downed one glass before passing the other towards Rachel who just scrunched her nose up at it. "Come on you must have drunk alcohol before."
"Only on special occasions when both my fathers are there. I haven't been drunk and I don't intend to start in my kitchen with you."
"Listen up Berry because Puckerman's got some advice. You don't have any friends, you hardly ever socialize with anyone unless it's some sort of competition and you don't let loose ever. Give it up for one night, your sixteen; you're going to end up famous with no friends apart for a bunch of gold diggers."
"Go away Noah, your hardly my friend. You throw slushies at me every morning so what right do you have to lecture me."
"Fine," Puck shrugged putting Rachel's drink on the bench. "You're just scared because I could drink you under the table. I'll go swing by Santana's house and get her to help me drink this. Always thought she was the better singer anyway."
"Santana is hardly a better singer than me," Rachel snapped grabbing the drink off the bench. "I'm doing this to shut you up and not because I agree with you."
"Whatever Berry, down it," Puck encouraged.
Rachel slammed the now empty glass onto the bench and smiled in victory towards Puck.
"You know Santana could only ever drink four before she ended up under the table."
"Fine," Rachel said reaching up and grabbing three more glasses and placing them in front of Puck. "Fill them up, I can easily out drink Santana."
An few hours later Puck and Rachel were defiantly drunk. Rachel had been able to match Santana's record but ended up falling over before she could get to the fifth glass so Puck had cut her off and ended up hiding the vodka. They had somehow ended up in Rachel's bedroom although neither of them could remember how.
"Hmm," Puck mumbled picking up a 'Victoria's Secrets' bag from beside Rachel's dressing table. "Been a naughty girl Berry?"
Puck racked through the bag but couldn't find it anything inside and looked up raising an eye brow at Rachel.
"I erm… I've got it on," Rachel said indicating her chest.
"Show me," Puck smirked walking over to the small brunette. He placed a hand on either side of her top and slowly started to lift it. Rachel didn't say anything but a faint blush filled her cheeks. She'd stopped drinking over an hour ago and everything wasn't as fuzzy but she still felt more confident and adventurous than usual.
"Nice," Puck smiled tossing the shirt on the other side of the room and lowering his gaze to the bra. It was black with purple trim and seemed to push Rachel's small bust up. He moved his right hand forward to trace the outline of the trim before moving his finger to her cleavage and running his fingertips over it. "This is new."
"Hmm," Rachel mumbled biting her lip. She'd never been with anyone before and could feel the butterflies at the pit of her stomach. If she was sober then she wouldn't have even let Puck in her room but now she didn't care. Right now all she could focus on was the pleasure that shot down her spine every time Puck touched her breasts.
"You like it don't you," Puck smirked cupping both her breasts with his large hands. Rachel moaned from the contact and arched her back pushing her breasts further into his hands. "Naughty girl."
Puck leaned forward and captured her lips in a kiss. Rachel was caught off guard but couldn't help leaning forward into the kiss. His hands trailed from her breasts down to her waist. He used one hand to unhook her bra with professional skill. Rachel was impressed at how easily he had done it but she didn't comment. She didn't want to ruin things.
"You want me don't you?" Puck asked
Rachel reached out her right hand to run along Puck's stomach and to trace his six pack through his shirt. She groaned at the sensation, his muscles were so much more pronounced then she had realized.
Pucks hands returned to her breasts. His fingers flicked and twisted Rachel's nipple until it hardened while he trailed kisses along her jaw and down her neck. Rachel gasped and moaned at Pucks skilled hands. The noises went straight to Puck's groin and he moved forward to push his erection against Rachel's leg.
"Damn," Puck hissed through clenched teeth as Rachel moved her leg slightly to cause some friction. "I'll stop..." Puck kissed Rachel's cheek before removing his hand from her breasts. "Tell me if you want to stop baby and we'll stop."
"I don't want you to stop," Rachel blurted out before she could stop herself. "Please don't make us stop."
"Wouldn't dream of it," Puck grinned placing a gentle kiss on her lips. "Come on." Puck tugged her towards the pink bed pushing her down to lay across before crawling up her body.
Puck's lips wrapped around Rachel's nipple; he sucked, licked and kissed the breast taking time to tease the nipple before moving to give the other the same attention. His left hand trailed down her stomach towards her crotch.
His hand went inside her pajama shorts going underneath her knickers to get to her center. She was already soaked as Puck ran his fingers across her slit causing her to moan.
"Oh god, Noah," Rachel cried pushing her breasts further into his mouth. She pushed her pajama shorts and knickers down her legs and off her with Puck's help.
He applied pressure to her entrance before slipping a finger inside her. She froze at the intrusion so Puck stilled his finger so she could get used to the sensation. He waited until her inner muscles relaxed and her breathing even out he pulled the finger out and thrust it back in causing her to gasp. He moved it repeatedly in and out of her finding a good pace as he continued to lavish her breasts with his mouth. Using his spare hand to rub and squeeze the free breast, taking turns with each.
Puck added a second finger and moved his thumb to rub against her clit as he felt her inner walls begin to flutter around his fingers. He started curling his fingers, rubbing against her until he found the magic spot that caused Rachel to gasp and cry out.
"Come Rachel," Puck whispered against her breast. The words seemed to work and Rachel came screaming Puck's name.
"Oh god," Rachel gasped coming down from the high. Puck slipped his fingers out from her brought them to his lips sucking on the juice off them.
Rachel kissed him deeply, using her own tongue to taste every inch of his mouth while she used her hands to push against his shoulder. Rachel rolled him onto his back so she could straddle his hips. She could already feel his erection through his jeans pressing against the material as it strained to get to her.
"You don't get control," Puck smirked sitting up and taking a nipple into his mouth.
"You're a little overdressed, I thought you could do with a hand," Rachel said as her trembling hands popped each button of his shirt through the hole. She pushed the open shirt off his shoulders and Puck shrugged it off. His body was amazing; it was like something out of a women's pin up calendar. His years of workout and football obviously showed. It was no wonder most of the girls at school wanted him. Rachel trailed her hand down his chest to his stomach feeling every muscle clench under her touch, "You're beautiful."
"I'm not beautiful, I'll take sexy though," Puck chuckled against her breast. The sensation sent shivers down her spine. Puck thrust his hips up so his jean clad erection pressed against Rachel's folds causing her to press down harder onto Puck's lap. "Damn it, get these things off baby."
Rachel shuffled back so she straddled his legs and reached out to undo his button. She kept her eyes locked with his as she pulled the zipper slowly down. She never felt so nervous; she had no experience with this kind of thing but the encouraging nod Puck sent her way gave her confidence. Rachel reached out and pulled the jeans down his legs. He'd gone commando, of course he had.
Puck's erection sprang free as Rachel eased the jeans down his legs. He was much bigger than Rachel had ever imagined. Of course she had never seen a penis before but she had some idea about the average size and Rachel was positive that he was definitely not average.
"Wow," Rachel whispered nervously reaching out to run a finger along the tip of his penis. "I don't think… it's not going to fit."
Puck's laughter filled the room as he sat up to kiss Rachel's forehead. "It will fit, I promise."
His strong hand covered hers as he wrapped it round his penis. He slowly moved their hands up and down his penis getting a slow enough rhythm for Rachel to catch onto. When he moved his hand away from hers Rachel kept the rhythm up, moving her other hand to cup and fondles his balls. His cock jerked at the sensation and Puck groaned falling back onto the mattress.
The rhythm increased as Puck groaned and started to thrust his hips up in encouragement. He nearly broke the bed springs with his ass when he felt Rachel's hot little lips wrapped around the head of his penis. She was nervous and inexperienced but it just made Puck more excited. She'd never touched anyone else's dick and tonight she was all his.
"God you're amazing," Puck groaned as Rachel sucked more of his cock in, taking as much as she could in. She used her hand to stroke the base of his penis while her other hand continued to roll his balls. "Shit babe."
Rachel took him in deeper relaxing the muscles of her throat as she took him further down. She knew that she didn't have a gag reflex but she'd never had the opportunity to use it. Rachel swallowed causing her throat to tighten around his cock sending him close to the edge and he quickly pulled her off. He wasn't very keen on this ending so early. Of course she'd been told how excited a boy would be when they found out about this but Rachel wasn't convinced. It wasn't that big of deal right?
"Fuck!" Puck groaned trying to calm himself down. "You deep throat Berry? How the hell did you learn that?"
"I don't have a gag reflex," Rachel shrugged. "I've never had the opportunity to use it before."
"Shit babe, I'm happy for you to practice that skill all night but first we've got some serious loving to be getting on with." Puck rolled them both so he was once again on top.
Puck was a true stud. He could get any girl because he could change his style accordingly. Rachel was a nervous virgin. She'd had a lot to drink but she'd sobered up by now although she was properly still using it as an excuse. Puck was a stud but he didn't take advantage of girls that defiantly wasn't cool.
Puck's skilled fingers moved down to cup her core, she was soaked and his finger glided straight into her. He added a second finger and then a third trying to stretch her as much as possible to prepare her. He spread his fingers out causing her to gasp as he pumped into her a few times before withdrawing and placing his hand back next to her head.
"This is going to hurt, I'll go slowly and you're stretched out a bit but it's still going to hurt," Puck warned.
"I know, you'll help me thru this though, I trust you Noah," Rachel said raising her hand placing it on the bulk of his arm. "Go on."
Puck kissed her lips again before reaching down between them and lining himself up at her entrance. He moved the tip of his penis around to gather some of her wetness and spread it out a bit before slowly pushing forward. She was so tight and he was barely even inside her. When she relaxed he pushed further into her until he came to her barrier.
"You ok?" Puck croaked glancing down at her flushed face, her eyes were squeezed close as a tear trailed down her cheek from the pain. "Hey, it's ok. The pain will be over quick then it'll be really good Rachel I promise."
"I'm ok, just do it," Rachel pleaded opening her eyes. "Get it over with please."
"You'll be fine baby," Puck whispered. He pushed forward breaking her barrier and continued till he was fully sheathed inside her. Her muscles squeezed against the intrusion so Puck let out a deep breath as he tried to stop himself from just fucking her, she wasn't Santana.
When the throbbing pain Rachel felt slowly subsided into something else, need. She opened her eyes ready for Puck to move when she saw his frozen form above her. His eyes locked with hers and his teeth were gritted together as he tried to maintain control.
He was stud, he didn't have control issues! Well he hadn't had them before; something about being with Berry was different. She trusted him completely and was giving him her virginity, something he felt completely guilty about the moment he took it.
"Noah?" Rachel asked placing a hand on his cheek. "Are you ok?"
"Yeah, you?" Puck said rubbing his cheek against her hand.
"I'm fine but do something… please," Rachel begged willing her hips slightly. "But slowly, please go slow."
"You got it Rach," Puck said before pulling out a few inches and thrusting slowly back in. He tried to be gentle and slow. He kept his eyes locked with hers trying to remember that she was a virgin and he had to be slow.
As Rachel got used to the sensation she started moving up to meet his thrusts. She lifted her legs and wrapped them around his legs allowing him to go deep.
"Faster please, Noah faster," Rachel begged scratching her nails against his hard back.
"Hold on tight," Puck smirked before pulling out till the tip was only left in and thrusting back in. His rhythm got harder and faster as he felt himself get close to the edge. He was pretty sure that Rachel was close so he reached between their joined bodies and rubbed her clit as he slammed into her.
"You're so fucking tight," Puck whispered into her ear. "You feel amazing baby, my cock slamming into you."
The dirty talk seemed to egg Rachel on and Puck couldn't last any longer and slammed brutally into her coming fast and hard. The motion pushed Rachel over the edge and her walls clenched around Puck's cock squeezing the last of his sperm out of him.
"God, that was," Rachel gasped coming down from her high.
"Mmm," Puck muttered pulling out and relaxing beside her. "Sleep babe."