Both of their Glee Clubs gathered in the Ohio State Mall parking lot. New Directions hid, with the exception of Santana and Blaine, while the Warblers all gathered at once.
They sang and danced their hearts out, in hopes that one of their groups would win in order to do Michael for Regionals. Unfortunately, that plan backfired as Sebastian slushied Blaine, injuring his eyes. He and the Warblers walked away quickly before any of the ND could question them.
Thanks to Kurt, Santana managed to get Sebastian's number. She sent him a text. Sebastian felt his phone vibrate and saw an unknown number.
Unknown: Hey Twink
Sebastian: Who is this?
Unknown: It's Santana, you idiot.
Sebastian: How did you get my number?
Santana: That doesn't matter. Meet me in your rehearsal room in an hour.
Santana went home, changed out of her Cheerios uniform and changed into a black dress. She put on a black jacket, black hat, and black boots. She took her car keys and drove to Dalton Academy. She got out and headed into the rehearsal space, just in time to see the Warblers come in.
"Hey Andrew McCarthy! Don't know if you've heard, but Blaine may lose an eye. The same Blaine who was besties with most of you not four months ago" Santana said smirking.
Trent asked her if he was okay. Sebastian shot him a "shut up" look.
"Well sure, if he doesn't mind seeing in three dimensions" Sebastian heard Santana tell Trent.
"Trent, I got this" he looked over at Santana and took a step towards her.
"Bummer, about Blaine. He was pretty. He shouldn't have gotten in the way though; that slushie was meant for Kurt."
Santana glared at him, hard. If looks could kill, he'd be dead by now.
"You may look like a villian out of a cheesy 80s high school movie, but you should know that I am fully prepared to go all Danny Larusso on your ass," Santana said smirking. "Admit that you put something in the slushie. What was it huh? Glass, asphalt?"
Sebastian smirked at her before responding.
"Red dye number 6" Sebastian said, fake smiling. She returned the gesture.
"You're lying."
Sebastian pretended to be surprised. "She questioned my honor," he said while looking at his fellow Warblers. "I demand satisfaction in Warbler tradition."
"You want to have a duel," Santana asked. She turned to face the cello guys.
"Cello guys, can you hang back, I'm going to need you for this one."
Sebastian saw them sit down. "Everyone else, clear out. I don't want you to see me make a girl cry."
Sebastian smirked as he looked down on Santana.
"Let's just keep this on point" Santana pointed out. She went to go sit down. The music starts.
(A/N: Sebastian's in bold, Santana's italics. Both of them are underlined and italicized)
As he came into the window
It was the sound of a crescendo
He came into her apartment
He left the bloodstains on the carpet
Sebastian briefly brushed his hand over her shoulder, while singing the lyrics in her ear. Santana turned to him as he continued.
She ran underneath the table
He could see she was unable
So she ran into the bedroom|
She was struck down, It was her doom
Annie are you ok?
So, Annie are you ok?
Are you ok Annie?
Annie are you ok?
So, Annie are you ok?
Are you ok Annie?
Annie are you ok?
So, Annie are you ok?
Are you ok Annie?
Annie are you ok?
So, Annie are you ok?
Are you ok Annie?
Santana grabbed his blazer and tie, forcing him to face her as they sang. Sebastian hit her hat slightly before continuing, ignore his heart beat when he felt Santana grab him.
Are you ok, Annie?
Would you tell us that you're ok?
There's a sign at the window
That he struck you - a crescendo Annie
Santana briefly touched him before pushing him away, ignoring the spark feeling she just experienced. Sebastian straightened his jacket again and continued singing.
He came into your apartment
He left the bloodstains on the carpet
Then you ran into the bedroom
You were struck down
It was your doom
Annie are you ok?
So, Annie are you ok?
Are you ok Annie?
Annie are you ok?
So, Annie are you ok?
As Santana walked by, Sebastian couldn't help but check her out. "damn" he thought. "she looks fine"
Are you ok, Annie?
Annie are you ok?
Are you ok, Annie?
You've been hit by
You've been hit by
A smooth criminal
They were silent for a moment, letting the cellos fill up the silence. Santana went to one side of the room while Sebastian went to the other. They started copying each other's movements before Santana took a deep breath before continuing.
(I don't know)
Annie are you ok?
Will you tell us that you're ok?
There's a sign at the window
(I don't know)
That he struck you - a crescendo Annie
(I don't know)
He came into your apartment
(I don't know)
He left the bloodstains on the carpet
(I don't know why baby)
Then you ran into the bedroom
(I don't know)
You were struck down
It was your doom Annie
Annie are you ok?
Dang Gone It - Baby!
Will you tell us that you're ok?
Dang Gone It - Baby!
There's a sign at the window
Dang Gone It - Baby!
That he struck you - a crescendo Annie
Hoo Hoo
He came into your apartment
Dang Gone It
He left the bloodstains on the carpet
Then you ran into the bedroom
Hoo Hoo
You were struck down
Dang Gone It
It was your doom
You've been hit by
You've been struck by
A smooth criminal
They faced each other, catching their breath.
"I was better" Santana said.
"You weren't even close" Sebastian told her. He turned around, trying to separate himself from her.
"I was better! Now tell me the truth, what did you put in that slushie?!" Santana exclaimed.
"Rock salt" Sebastian said simply.
Santana stared at him wide eyed.
"You know I can just report this to your headmaster"
Sebastian stared at her in horror. "You wouldn't!"
"I would"
"What can I do to make you not report," Sebastian asked her as he stepped towards her.
Santana felt his breath on her lips. She looked at his lips briefly, before reverting back to his eyes.
Sebastian looked at her lips for a second before looking back at her eyes. Soon, Sebastian leaned down and kissed her. Santana didn't waste any time and kissed him back aggressively. Sebastian felt her deepen the kiss. He slid his tongue over her mouth, and she granted him access. Sebastian explored her mouth with his tongue before they pulled back for air.
"That's all you get from me" Santana said, before turning and walking away.
She slipped her hand in her pocket, stopped the recording and smirked.
"I can't wait to get him expelled" she thought.
Before heading back to school, she felt someone grab her wrist. She turned her head and saw Sebastian.
"What do you want, Twink,"
"You" he said smirking.
He leaned down and kissed her again. They ended up hiding in a corner.
"One time, Smythe!"
"One time."
Three rounds later, they finally exhausted themselves. Santana checked her phone. She had missed two periods already and she did not want to miss Glee. She quickly looked at Sebastian. He was asleep.
"Good. Now for my escape." She quickly gathered her clothes, put them back on and headed back to McKinley.
The next day, Sebastian got a call from Kurt. He was told to bring the Warblers and head down to the McKinley auditorium. He sighed in annoyance, gathered his group and told them that they were to go to McKinley right away.
Meanwhile, at McKinley, Artie and the rest of the Glee club were arriving to the auditorium. Sebastian and the Warblers stepped through the curtains.
"Nice of you to show" Artie said.
"Is whatever this is going to take long? I can't stand the stench of public schools" Sebastian retorted.
"It won't take long and all you have to do is sit down and listen" Quinn explained to him slowly.
The Warblers took a seat in the auditorium.
"We're not doing Michael for Regionals" Artie tells them.
"I didn't think you'd surrender that easily"
"We're tired of the fighting and the backstabbing. We're showchoirs! We're supposed to be supportive of each other."
"This is what we call, "taking the high road" which I was shocked to find out it has nothing to do with marijuana."
Everyone rolls their eyes at Puck.
"Just because you're doing Michael doesn't mean you understand Michael"
"And you do," Sebastian questioned.
"Yes. and we're about to show you" Mercedes tells him before breaking out lyrics.
[Artie:]
Ouh!
Ouh!
I took my baby
On a saturday bang
Boy is that girl with you
Yes we're one and the same
[Rachel:]
Now I believe in miracles
And a miracle
Has happened tonight
Hee!
Ah!
[Santana and Artie with New Directions:]
But, if
You're thinkin'
About my baby
It don't matter if you're
Black or white
[Santana and Rachel:]
I am tired of this devil
I am tired of this stuff
I am tired of this business
Sew when the
Going gets rough
I ain't scared of
Your brother
I ain't scared of no sheets
I ain't scared of nobody
Girl when the
Goin' gets mean
Santana looked at Sebastian while she sang those lyrics out directly to him. She could feel her heart beat racing. Sebastian, meanwhile, tried his best to avert his gazes at the Latina but ended up failing as she sang. He felt his heart beat racing.
[Artie:]
Protection
For gangs, clubs,
And nations
Causing grief in
Human relations
It's a turf war
On a global scale
I'd rather hear both sides
Of the tale
See, it's not about races
Just places
Faces
Where your blood
Comes from
Is where your space is
I've seen the bright
Get duller
I'm not going to spend
My life being a color
[Kurt:]
Don't tell me you agree with me
When I saw you
Kicking dirt in my eye
[Santana and Rachel with New Directions:]
But, if
You're thinkin'
About my baby
It don't matter if you're
Black or white
I said if
You're thinkin' of
Being my baby
It don't matter if you're
Black or white
I said if
You're thinkin' of
Being my brother
It don't matter if you're
Black or white
[Santana:]
Yeah yeah yeah!
One-by-one, the Warblers began to climb up onto the stage until Sebastian was the only one left in the audience.
[Rachel:]
Whoo!
Black or white!
[Santana, Artie and Rachel with New Directions:]
It's black, it's white
It's tough for you to get by
It's black, it's white, whoo
It's tough for you to get by
It's black, it's white
([Santana:] Yeah yeah yeah!)
It's tough for you to get by
([Rachel:] Black or white!)
It's black , it's white, whoo
It's tough for you to get by
It's black, it's white, whoo
([Santana:] C'mon!)
It's black, it's white, whoo
([Santana:] Aah)
([ND:] Yeah! Yeah! Yeah)
It's tough for you to get by
It's black, it's white, whoo
It's tough for you to get by
([ND:] Yeah! Yeah! Yeah!)
([Artie:] Oouh!)
Everyone started clapping until it was only Sebastian.
"Very moving" Sebastian said sarcastically.
"Come on Sebastian, give it up!" His fellow Warbler said.
"That is the kind of attitude that lost us Regionals last year" Soon, he heard Santana's voice.
"I could call the cops or your headmaster to get you kicked out of school or even arrested for assaulting Blaine with that slushie" she said as she walked up the stage to face him. She ignored the heart beat that she was feeling when she saw the boy.
"All of this would be just awfully terrifying if you had any prove whatsoever" Sebastian tells her.
"You mean like," Santana pulls a small tape out of her pocket.
"You on tape admitting to it?" Sebastian glanced at her in horror.
Santana fake smiled at him before passing the small tape to Kurt.
"But you know what, it just wouldn't be fun winning Regionals if you weren't there to suffer from all the agony and defeat" Kurt said as he threw the tape to Sebastian.
"At least now all your teammates know exactly the kind of guy you are." Santana smirked at him in glory.
"In other words, I win" she thought.
"Now get the hell out of my auditorium. SCHOOL'S OUT!" Artie yelled out.
ND and Warblers slowly began to file out. Sebastian waited until Santana was the only one left.
"Very nice" he said as he held the tape in his hand.
"What do you want Twink," Santana said impatiently.
"You know exactly what I want"
"I'm not giving it to you. We said one time and we ended up going for three rounds that day. Besides, I have a girlfriend"
Sebastian scoffed. "What your girlfriend doesn't know won't hurt her."
Before Santana could reply back, he quickly went on stage and kissed her. Santana tried pushing him away but he held on tight against her and soon, he felt her kissing back. They felt their hearts beat fast as Santana wrapped her arms around his neck and pulled him towards the curtains backstage, where they went for a quick round that day.