A/N: So this is my first ever Fanfic! I'm so excited to see what you think! I want all reviews good and bad, buuuut don't be mean. Cool? Anyways I really hope you like it!

XOXO Nicky

She's not her

Chapter 1

Percy's p.o.v

I didn't know what to do. I screwed up really bad and anyone who tells me otherwise is wrong. This is my life's mistake and now I'm gonna fix it.

-$$ line break $$-

So every half blood knows the story of how Jason, Piper, Leo, Hazel, Frank, Annabeth, and I saved the world. We're the heroes of Olympus blah blah blah. And then it was all happy ever after. Annabeth and I finished high school like regular teens. Obviously monsters attacked, and we fought them. Problems at camp? We fixed them. Jason was always running around both camps, Piper fixing arguments, and Frank, as praetor had a lot of war games to organize. Hazel was centurion now and helped Frank,over at Camp Jupiter . Leo on the other hand made a fabulous entrance with his new girlfriend. It was a lot longer but this is the gist of it. He didn't warn me. He let us know he was alive but we didn't know for sure. I mean, how would we? The fire explosion was huge! But he landed next to the strawberry fields, with a gleaming Festus and…jeez. Man it was awkward. I gave Leo a hug and tried avoiding her but she wouldn't let me.
"Wow Percy thought you would remember me even if it has been a while."
"Um yeah hi Calypso."
"Dude be nice. Everyone this is Calypso. She couldn't resist this Bad Boy Supreme."
Annabeth was glaring at me.

-$$ line break $$-

So yeah life went on as normal as it could for half-bloods. Annabeth and I were the perfect couple, so the story goes. But one mistake I made ruined my life.

It happened in college when Annabeth and I were going to move in together. Of course we already lived right next to each other in New Rome, but we wanted to make it real, you know? One bedroom, one closet, one bed, you know the works. The harder part though was springing the question. I couldn't tell if she wanted to so I just did it casually like it didn't mean a lot to me.( It meant the world to me.) It went somewhat like this.
"… it's great. We build models and stuff. And there's this girl who really knows her stuff. It's awesome. We're working on a project together…"
"Okay, okay I get it. You love your architecture class. But I have a question."
"Sorry and shoot."
I held her hands in my own and looked deep into her sexy grey eyes and whipped out a red rose and went down on one knee and said…
Yeah no. That's definitely not what I did.
"So hypothetically speaking if a guy wanted to ask a girl to move in with him what would her answer most likely be?"
"Well how close are they? Are they related or dating? Is just like a one time thing or have they been together a long time? Technically if have to analyze the situation…Wait. Are you…"
"Only if you want to. I mean you don't have to but I want to and I thought maybe you might too…"
I was sort of babbling by then. But she just laughed and smiled and said "Seaweed Brain you're so stupid! I love you! Of course I want to!" So I picked her up and spun her around and laughed too.

-$$ line break $$-

Since me and Annabeth( sorry Annabeth and I) were so close Malcolm was like my brother from another mother. We were visiting Camp Half-Blood for winter break. We wanted to see what everybody else thought about us moving in together. He said yes of course and had a favor of his own to ask.
"Dude can you help me get a girlfriend?"
"Um what? I mean yeah sure. Anyone in particular?"
"Um yeah. This girl, uh,in the Aphrodite cabin? Her name is Lacy?"
"Oh yeah I know Lacy. Pipers good friends with her. I'll ask her."
"Thanks man."
So I went on my mission. I knocked on the door and just my luck. Drew opened and said
"Well hey Percy boo! Haven't seen you in a while!"
"Yeah hi Drew. Do you-"
"Of course I'll go out with you! We can go to the movies this Friday! I'm so glad you got over that stupid girl Annabelle or whatever!"
And with that she shut the door in my face. I stood there shocked. What just happened? I walked back to my cabin and ran into Annabeth. "Hey Wise Girl." I leaned in for a kiss but she turned away. There was a cold look in her eyes. "Annabeth what's-" she cut me off, "Just stupid Annabeth now aren't I? Sorry but looks like you have to cancel our movie on Friday since you have other plans!" She exaggerated her last two words."Annabeth is this about Drew? You know how she is. Why are you mad at me?" I was slightly miffed now. Annabeth knows how Drew is!
"Yeah but you were asking her out!"
"No I wasn't! I was asking her if she knew where Piper was!"
"And why would you need to know where Piper is?"
"If you must know your brother Malcolm likes Lacy, and asked me to help him ask her out! So I needed Piper to find out if she likes him too!"
"Yeah okay. Whatever. I thought we were past lying to each other." She huffed and started walking away.
"I'm not lying!" I called. But she kept walking.

-$$ line break $$-

I was really upset. I thought she would understand, but I guess not. My pity party was interrupted by a knock on the door.
"Who is it?" I called out hoarsely.
Annabeth cracked open the door.
"Can I come in?"
I just looked at her. Gods of Olympus she was beautiful. I looked away. She came in and sat by my bed.
"I talked to Malcolm."
I said nothing.
"He said that what you said was true. And I'm sorry. I should've believed you but I was angry. Drew has such nerve that she thinks she can steal you like that. And I'm sorry that I reacted that way. I don't know if we broke up or not, but I'm asking you to give me another shot?"
I know she said sorry and that we were inseparable but I was angry. She should trust me. We'd been together more than 2 years. I'd met her almost 7 years ago! And this stuff happened before. Some girl would flirt with me, she'd get angry, we'd work it out and that was it. But this time it went differently. All my anger and resentment came out in one, short whispered syllable that decided life after this for both of us.
"No."