This takes place after the St. Berry kiss in Funeral (2x21). This is for my friend's birthday.
Rachel POV
I ran to the bathroom to sort out my feelings. Why did I feel butterflies when Jesse kissed me? I thought I was in love with Finn.
"Rachel!" I heard a voice call behind me. I turned around to see Finn chasing after me.
"Go away Finn."
"I wanna be with you."
"It's too late. You've broken my heart too many times."
"No it's not! It's never too late for us. He's broken eggs... on you."
"Yes it is. I don't wanna be with you. At least he apologized."
"I know you wanna be with Jesse, but I wanna change that. I'm in love with you Rachel."
"No, you're not. You're only in love with the girl who's happy at the moment. If it's not painfully obvious Quinn ships Quam."
"Excuse me?"
"After you broke up with her after a FUNERAL she ran to me and told me everything."
"Define everything."
"How she got back with you to make Sam jealous and to be prom queen. I know what you're thinking and she won't take you back."
"You said Quinn ships Quam. What do you ship?" he asked hopefully.
"St. Berry and Lonely Finn."
"Lonely Finn? You've been throwing yourself at me since sophomore year and now, when I wanna be with you, you're pushing me away?"
"I told you, I ship St. Berry. I have to go." I ran away.
*********************************Later**********************************
Rachel POV
I walked into the choir room to find Jesse in the front of the room and Puck holding a guitar behind him. Jesse took my hand.
"This is for you, Rachel."
"What's going on?" Finn asked.
"CheckyesJuliet
Are you with me?
Rain is falling down on the sidewalk
I won't go until you come outside
Check yes Juliet kill the limbo
I'll keep tossing rocks at your window
There's no turning back for us tonight
Lace up your shoes
Here's how we do
Run baby run
Don't ever look back
They'll tear us apart if you give them the chance
Don't sell your heart, don't say we're not meant to be
Run baby run, forever will be
You and me
Check yes Juliet
I'll be waiting
Wishing wanting yours for the taking
Just sneak out and don't tell a soul goodbye
Check yes Juliet
Here's the countdown:
3,2,1 you fall in my arms now
They can change the locks, don't let them change your mind
Lace up your shoes
Here's how we do
Run baby run
Don't ever look back
They'll tear us apart if you give them the chance
Don't sell your heart, don't say we're not meant to be
Run baby run, forever will be
You and me
We're flying through the night
We're flying through the night
Way up high
The view from here is getting better with you
By my side
Run baby run
Don't ever look back
They'll tear us apart if you give them the chance
Don't sell your heart, don't say we're not meant to be
Run baby run, forever will be
Run baby run, don't ever look back
They'll tear us apart if you give them the chance
Don't sell your heart, don't say we're not meant to be
Run baby run, forever will be
You and me
You and me
Youandme"
I ran up to the front of the room to hug Jesse but Finn got to Jesse before I could. He punched Jesse. Jesse fell into Puck and Puck fell into the band members. I started crying. Everything in my life is messed up. I went to run into the bathroom but I felt arms wrap around me.
"Go away Finn. You mess everything up." I looked up to see Jesse hugging me. "Jesse? How did you get up that fast?"
"I need to tell you I love you. I had to do it fast before Finn convinces you to get back with him. I really truly love you."
"I love you too."
The end! The song is Check Yes Juliet by We the Kings.